• Both were among five trainees involved in recording ‘educational video’ during surgery at Lady Willingdon Hospital
•
asserted
Both → involve → Hospital
Post-grad trainees allowed to appear in final exams
ISLAMABAD:
asserted
trainees → allow → exams
In two significant interim orders drawing a distinction between professional discipline and the pursuit of education, a medical tribunal on Tuesday allowed two postgraduate doctors, who face two-year suspension of their medical licences, to continue postgraduate training and appear in their forthcoming final examinations, while their appeals against disciplinary action remain pending.
asserted
appeals → draw → action
The three-member tribunal, headed by retired Justice Safdar Saleem Shahid, granted identical interim relief to Dr Tayyaba Fatima Toor and Dr Muhammad Essa, suspending the operation of the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council disciplinary order dated July 28, 2026, but only to the extent necessary to enable them to continue and complete their postgraduate academic and training programmes and appear in their final postgraduate examinations.
asserted
tribunal → head → examinations
The tribunal was careful, however, not to disturb the disciplinary findings at this stage or restore an unrestricted licence to practise medicine.
asserted
tribunal → disturb → medicine
It expressly clarified that the interim arrangement was provisional, subject to the final outcome of the appeals, and did not amount to an adjudication permitting the appellants to undertake independent clinical practice.
asserted
arrangement → clarify → practice
The two doctors were among five postgraduate trainees whose cases attracted considerable attention following the circulation of what became known as the “OT video leak scandal” at Lahore’s Lady Willingdon Hospital.
asserted
what → attract → Hospital
In April this year, the PMDC had publicly stated that five doctors — Dr Tayyaba Fatima Toor, Dr Zainab Tahir, Dr Muhammad Essa, Dr Ayesha Afzal and Dr Maham Amin — had appeared in preliminary proceedings concerning a video circulating on social media.
asserted
doctors → state → media
The council subsequently referred the matter to its Disciplinary Committee for final determination.
asserted
council → refer → determination
The disciplinary proceedings eventually resulted in the suspension of the medical registration licences of the appellants for two years.
asserted
proceedings → result → years
That decision is now under challenge before the Medical Tribunal, and Tuesday’s orders concern only the doctors’ applications for interim relief, rather than the merits of their appeals.
asserted
orders → concern → appeals
At the centre of the tribunal’s reasoning is a distinction likely to have wider relevance for disciplinary proceedings involving doctors who are simultaneously postgraduate trainees.
asserted
who → have → doctors
The tribunal held that there was a “material distinction” between permission to pursue an academic programme and appear in an examination, on the one hand, and permission independently to practise medicine under a professional licence, on the other.
asserted
tribunal → hold → other
The former, it observed, could, in an appropriate case, be protected provisionally without finally determining the latter.
uncertain
it → observe → latter
The distinction enabled the tribunal to preserve the regulatory authority of the PMDC while ensuring that the pendency of an appeal did not itself cause academic consequences that could become irreversible before the legality of the disciplinary action had been finally determined.
uncertain
legality → enable → action
According to the orders, counsel informed the tribunal that the appellants had already substantially completed their prescribed postgraduate training and cleared the requisite intermediate or mid-term component.
uncertain
appellants → accord → component
Their final postgraduate examinations were stated to be due in approximately four months.
asserted
examinations → state → months
The tribunal observed that if the doctors were prevented from completing the remaining academic component and consequently missed their forthcoming examinations, success in their appeals at a later stage might not adequately restore the academic opportunity already lost.
uncertain
success → observe → opportunity
Conversely, it held, permitting them provisionally to continue their academic programmes and sit the examinations would neither determine the validity of the disciplinary proceedings nor confer an unconditional right to practice medicine during the pendency of their appeals.
asserted
permitting → hold → appeals
The cases will now proceed on their merits before the medical tribunal.
asserted
cases → proceed → tribunal
The Aporia
