In short:
The Victorian education department has been fined $150,000 after a Year 10 student severed three fingers while using a guillotine.
asserted
student → fin → guillotine
The department pleaded guilty to two counts of breaching the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
What's next?
asserted
What → plead → Act
Magistrate Peter Dunn said the incident warranted conviction and had a devastating impact to the student and their family.
asserted
incident → say → student
The Victorian Department of Education has been fined $150,000 after a year 10 student had three fingers severed by a guillotine in a jewellery design class.
The Department of Education pleaded guilty to two charges of breaching the Occupational Health and Safety Act in Wodonga Magistrates' Court today.
asserted
Department → fin → Court
In addition to failing to ensure students' health and safety, it had been charged with failing to provide supervision and failing to implement safety measures such as signage and competency tests.
asserted
it → fail → signage
In a summary of agreed facts read to the court, the guillotine was identified as a Metal Master Treadle Guillotine model SG416A, operated by a foot pedal, that lowered a metal beam and created a shear point with the guillotine table.
asserted
that → agree → table
The court also heard that the machine had no rear guarding.
asserted
machine → hear → guarding
Students left unsupervised
The court heard an art teacher at Beechworth Secondary College was supervising a jewellery class on February 9 2024 when a student, known as C, had asked if they could use a specific guillotine located in a back room attached to a main classroom.
uncertain
they → leave → classroom
Another teacher then entered the classroom and asked the art teacher about a filing cabinet outside.
asserted
teacher → enter → cabinet
The two teachers stepped outside to deal with the cabinet, leaving four students unsupervised.
asserted
teachers → step → students
One student, referred to in court as M, operated the machine by pressing the pedal while the student who was injured measured metal at the rear, with his hand away from the cutting blade but still near the shear point between the edge of the beam and the table.
asserted
hand → refer → beam
The injured student confirmed his fingers and hands were clear while holding metal at the rear of the machine, then told M to cut.
asserted
fingers → injure → M
As M started to press the pedal, student C yelled at him to stop because he could see the other student's hand was still in the danger zone.
uncertain
hand → start → zone
But the beam had been lowered to the table, severing three of the student's left fingertips.
The injured student was transported to the Royal Melbourne Hospital and stayed there for nine days.
asserted
student → lower → days
Apart from one day, they did not return to school for the rest of the term.
asserted
they → return → term
Investigation revealed shortfalls
asserted
Investigation → reveal → shortfalls
Although a safe work procedure existed and risk assessments had been conducted in previous years, no risk assessment or competency records were completed from the beginning of the first term of 2024 until the day of the class.
WorkSafe were also notified of the incident and attended the school a few days later on February 12.
asserted
WorkSafe → exist → February
A department investigation found inadequate supervision, a lack of guarding and signage on the machine and missing training records.
asserted
investigation → find → machine
A prohibition notice also required the guillotine be locked, have extra signage, and be operated only by trained staff.
asserted
guillotine → require → staff
The court heard that later that month two new guillotines, with guarding on their rear, replaced the older models.
asserted
guillotines → hear → models
In March 2024 the school's principal told inspectors she had not found any documented risk assessments for the class in question.
asserted
she → tell → question
The department also updated and published its plant and equipment management policy and safe work procedures online to improve accessibility and visibility for school staff after the incident.
asserted
department → update → incident
Defence lawyer Felicity Fox told the court the department's investigation and actions showed its commitment to safety.
asserted
investigation → tell → safety
This included an updated hazard alert guideline on the use of guillotines in classrooms and updated safety procedures for Beechworth Secondary School.
asserted
This → include → School
"I want to make it clear in this plea that the department's taken both this incident and this prosecution very seriously,"Ms Fox said.
asserted
Fox → want → incident
"[It] is evidenced in my submission by the very early plea of guilty and the significant steps that the department has implemented both at the school and across the department."
asserted
department → evidence → department
The court heard that Beechworth Secondary College had since relocated the trades classrooms to provide a better line of sight to guillotines.
asserted
College → hear → guillotines
Victim impact statements from the student and their family were submitted but not read aloud in court.
asserted
statements → submit → court
'Horse has already bolted'
asserted
Horse → bolt → ?
Magistrate Peter Dunn told the court that statements and material submitted to the court suggested there had been "some kneejerk reaction from some people at the school, including teachers or otherwise".
uncertain
statements → tell → teachers
"They haven't really wrapped their arms around the victim," he said.
asserted
he → wrap → victim
In reply, Ms Fox said psychologists and student support services were made available immediately after the incident.
asserted
psychologists → say → incident
She also said the department's conduct and integrity division had "ongoing involvement and an investigation", but said it was inappropriate to comment further.
asserted
it → say → involvement
When imposing the fine, Magistrate Dunn credited the department with taking steps to replace the machine and updating procedures, but said the incident was serious and warranted conviction.
asserted
incident → impose → conviction
"Here we have a machine that has an obvious, in my mind, defect," he said.
"
asserted
he → have → defect
It's not guarded, there's no lines painted around it, there's no signs outlining operating procedures, there's no safe system … put in place for its use.
asserted
It → guard → use
I suppose in one sense the horse has already bolted."
asserted
horse → suppose → sense
Magiustrate Dunn said the school would have certainly desired a better outcome.
asserted
school → say → outcome
Magistrate Dunn told the family of the injured student that he recognised the devastating impact the incident had on their lives.
asserted
incident → tell → lives
The Aporia