On September 17, immigration attorney Rachel Marandett went looking for a man held by ICE in the agency’s detainee locator.
asserted
Marandett → look → locator
Searching his name returned zero results—and Marandett, an attorney with the American Friends Service Committee, began to worry he’d been deported without anyone noticing.
asserted
anyone → search → Committee
“He was missing, and I panicked,” Marandett said.
asserted
Marandett → miss → ?
“I sent a frantic email.”
asserted
I → send → email
Through other channels, she was eventually able to learn that he had not been sent out of the country.
asserted
he → learn → country
In fact, he hadn’t been moved at all.
asserted
he → move → fact
His name was just missing.
asserted
name → miss → ?
That man is one of thousands of detained immigrants with “Final Orders of Removal” whose records have been hidden or deleted from ICE’s tracking system, leaving families and lawyers unable to locate them.
asserted
records → detain → them
As the Associated Press reported on Monday, those records began to vanish September 15.
asserted
records → report → Monday
Thousands of people in ICE custody are likely affected.
asserted
Thousands → affect → custody
ICE disputes the claim.
uncertain
ICE → dispute → claim
“ICE does not “disappear” people.
asserted
ICE → disappear → people
This is a ridiculous lie that the media is peddling to demonize ICE law enforcement,” an ICE representative told Mother Jones via email.
asserted
representative → peddle → email
“Additionally, Illegal [sic] aliens in detention have opportunities to communicate with their family members and lawyers.
asserted
aliens → have → members
But that communication can’t happen unless family members and lawyers know where the person is being held.
asserted
person → happen → ?
And obstacles to communication can have life-altering consequences—particularly for those whose orders of removal have been issued in absentia, or because they missed a court date.
asserted
they → have → date
“Often they didn’t even know the court hearing happened,” Marandett said.
asserted
Marandett → know → ?
If lawyers find out in time, they can file a motion to reopen a person’s case based on lack of notice.
asserted
they → find → notice
ICE “is working rapidly overtime,” as the agency’s representative put it in their statement, to deport as many people as possible.
asserted
representative → work → people
And being unable to locate a client can hamstring a lawyer’s last-minute appeal.
asserted
being → locate → appeal
One notable absence from ICE’s Detainee Locator is Wilber Garcés Pérez, the Venezuelan delivery worker shot by a federal agent in Texas on Sunday.
asserted
absence → shoot → Sunday
Garcés was taken into custody, hastily discharged from the hospital with a bullet still lodged in the back of his neck, and moved to detention within hours of being shot.
asserted
Garcés → take → hours
He was then, according to the Washington Post, left on the floor of the South Texas ICE Processing Center with the bullet still in his spine.
uncertain
He → accord → spine
Meanwhile, Garcés’ lawyers and family were unable to track him down.
asserted
lawyers → track → him
Eventually, attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch was able to get in contact with him, she said in a series of social media posts.
asserted
she → get → posts
His deportation order, Lincoln-Goldfinch said, was issued in error when Garcés, who reportedly has a work permit, missed an immigration court hearing and was ordered removed in absentia—after the court sent notice of the hearing to the wrong address.
uncertain
court → say → address
“I see this all the time in my practice and it’s a mistake we can easily correct,” Lincoln-Goldfinch wrote.
asserted
Goldfinch → see → practice
“It does not justify shooting people in the street.”
asserted
It → justify → street
Other groups of people who technically have final orders of removal—but are not, in practice, about to be deported—may also have their names removed from the Detainee Locator.
uncertain
names → have → Locator
That includes immigrants who have open circuit court appeals, as well as those who were granted withholding of removal under the United Nations Convention Against Torture and can’t be deported to their home countries.
asserted
who → include → countries
It may also include some people in active habeas corpus litigation, in which a lawyer must provide proof of where their client is.
uncertain
client → include → proof
Usually, the best proof of where Marandett’s clients are being held is a screenshot of the Detainee Locator.
asserted
clients → hold → Locator
Without it, “you may literally not know what district to file a lawsuit in.”
uncertain
you → know → lawsuit
There’s little apparent consistency in who disappears.
asserted
who → ’ → ?
Immigration attorney Stefi Bastiaensz says that one of her clients, who came to the US fleeing political persecution in Nicaragua and has been held in New Jersey’s notorious Delaney Hall detention center for nearly a year, is technically under a final order of removal while his case moves through the appeals process.
asserted
case → say → process
His profile, however, still shows up on Detainee Locator.
asserted
profile → show → Locator
“What makes my firm panic is whether ICE is looking underneath the final order,” Bastiaensz said.
asserted
Bastiaensz → make → order
A pending habeas petition, or other relief, may not matter to the agency.
uncertain
petition → pende → agency
There are other ways lawyers can find their clients—immigration lawyer Pedro Chavez posted some examples in an Instagram video—but none are as efficient as the detainee locator.
asserted
none → be → locator
And families can be left with very few tactics beyond waiting for a phone call from their loved one or contacting their member of Congress.
asserted
families → leave → Congress
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
