In short:
A jury has heard a key witness previously lied in 2022 police interviews about knowing missing man Christopher Jarvis.
asserted
witness → hear → Jarvis
The man says he has memory issues and denied using that to his advantage in the court proceeding.
What's next?
asserted
What → say → proceeding
The trial in the Victorian Supreme court at Warrnambool continues.
asserted
trial → continue → Warrnambool
A key witness in a cold case murder trial over the disappearance of a Warrnambool man in 2006 has admitted to previously lying to police.
asserted
witness → admit → police
Steven Frederick Johnson, 74, has pleaded not guilty to one charge of murder in relation to the disappearance of 38-year-old Christopher Jarvis on June 13, 2006, from his Wangoom home near Warrnambool.
asserted
Johnson → plead → Warrnambool
It is the crown's case that Mr Johnson orchestrated a violent attack on his tenant, Mr Jarvis, over $2,210 in unpaid rent, before disposing of his body and setting his car alight.
asserted
Johnson → orchestrate → car
The defence argues that Mr Johnson wanted to lawfully solve the rental dispute and he had no involvement in the disappearance.
asserted
he → argue → disappearance
In the Supreme Court in Warrnambool on Thursday, the jury heard from a key witness, who cannot be legally named, who claimed to have assisted Mr Johnson with the alleged killing.
asserted
who → hear → killing
During cross-examination earlier in the trial, defence lawyer Patrick Doyle SC suggested the man was not truthfully recalling events in a number of circumstances, including how well he knew Mr Jarvis.
uncertain
he → suggest → Jarvis
The man told the jury he had only met Mr Jarvis when he had paid $100 to Mr Jarvis for marijuana, and on another occasion Mr Jarvis failed to provide the drugs or refund the man.
asserted
Jarvis → tell → man
Mr Doyle suggested that the man knew Mr Jarvis better than he let on, and had met Mr Jarvis many times and had socialised with him.
uncertain
he → suggest → him
The man denied this.
asserted
man → deny → this
On Thursday, audio from a November 2022 police interview with the unnamed man was played in court.
asserted
audio → play → court
In the recording, police explained to the man that they were speaking to people about the 2006 disappearance of Christopher Jarvis and that Mr Jarvis had the man on his contact list.
asserted
Jarvis → explain → list
During that interview, the police officers asked whether he knew Mr Jarvis and the man told the officers he did not.
asserted
he → ask → officers
"Doesn't ring a bell, sorry," the man said in the recording.
asserted
man → ring → recording
The defence repeatedly put it to the man that he had lied to police in 2022 about knowing Mr Jarvis, before the man admitted he did.
asserted
he → put → Jarvis
Yes, I did.
asserted
I → do → ?
I lied to them," he told the court.
asserted
he → lie → court
When questioned on another detail in the 2022 police interview recording, the man denied lying to detectives.
asserted
man → question → detectives
"I didn't lie about it, I just didn't tell the truth," the man told the jury.
asserted
man → lie → jury
"Can you explain that distinction to us, please?" Mr Doyle asked the man.
asserted
Doyle → explain → man
There was a moment of silence in the court room before the cross-examination continued.
asserted
examination → be → room
Earlier in the trial, the man told the jury that he had memory problems.
asserted
he → tell → problems
"Are you a bit selective when you invoke this problem with your memory?" Mr Doyle asked the man.
asserted
Doyle → invoke → man
The man replied no, and said he had trouble remembering his children's birthdays.
asserted
he → reply → birthdays
On Thursday, the man reiterated to the court that he had memory issues.
asserted
he → reiterate → issues
"I'm not here to recall every single thing," he told the court.
asserted
he → recall → court
"I'm not here using that as an excuse."
asserted
I → use → excuse
Earlier in the trial, the man had told the court Mr Johnson was "greedy" with money.
asserted
Johnson → tell → money
On Thursday, Mr Doyle asked the man whether he was exaggerating his client's "meanness" with money, after offering examples of where Mr Johnson might be perceived to have been financially generous.
uncertain
Johnson → ask → examples
"Everyone owed Steve money, according to Steve," the man replied.
uncertain
man → owe → Steve
Earlier, the jury heard the two men had met up numerous times in the days prior to Mr Johnson's arrest in November 2022, after police had been asking questions about Mr Jarvis's disappearance.
asserted
police → hear → disappearance
During his evidence, the man told the court Mr Johnson said to him on one occasion, "I'm too old to go to jail for this shit".
asserted
I → tell → shit
"He told me to keep me [sic] mouth f*****g shut and not say anything,"the man said.
asserted
man → tell → mouth
The trial continues.
asserted
trial → continue → ?
The Aporia