Emma, the NRL and Tones and I seem to be at war – but I can’t make sense of what’s going on.
asserted
what → seem → sense
I’ll try to catch you up.
asserted
I → try → you
The Dance Monkey singer made headlines this week after it was leaked she’d turned down an offer to perform at next weekend’s NRL grand final.
asserted
she → make → final
The rugby league boss Peter V’landys said negotiations broke down due to “artistic differences”, and some claimed it was because the Aria award-winning artist didn’t want to play her biggest hit.
asserted
artist → say → hit
Instead, the grand final will go ahead without pre-game entertainment, and V’landys has put $1m towards junior rugby league – an idea he’d been toying with for a while, he said.
asserted
he → go → while
“Rather than giving a performer $90,000 a minute, we would prefer to give it to grassroots,” he said on Tuesday.
asserted
he → give → Tuesday
“When you look at it realistically for 11 minutes, it’s not worth it.
asserted
it → look → minutes
Wait – she turned down maybe $90k a minute because she hates her own song?
asserted
she → wait → song
I don’t love it either, but that’s a lot of money.
asserted
that → love → money
We don’t know exactly how much she would have been paid – but it’s definitely true that Tones and I, whose real name is Toni Watson, isn’t a fan of Dance Monkey, her ubiquitous megahit that spent 24 weeks at No 1 on the Aria charts.
asserted
that → know → charts
In 2022 she told Kent Small on the Nova Network that she “loathes” it, adding “a lot of the time I don’t want to sing it”.
asserted
I → tell → it
But according to her management, that isn’t the reason she turned down the gig.
uncertain
she → accord → gig
Regan Lethbridge of Lemon Tree Music told the ABC they were contacted about the show only three weeks ago, on 5 September; that “no deal had been signed or confirmed in writing”; and that Tones and I had “explored all avenues to make it work”, but had “a prior commitment with Macklemore” in the US.
asserted
it → tell → US
Then the plot thickened further: we emailed the NRL, and they are refuting a lot of what her management said.
asserted
management → thicken → what
Through a spokesperson, the NRL told us that discussions with Tones and I’s label Sony began well before the 5 September date cited by her management.
asserted
discussions → tell → management
They denied the claim that Tones and I were unable to perform because the request was too last-minute and she had prior commitments; and although they didn’t make a direct link between her allegedly refusing to play the song and the cancellation, they did tell us that her management made it clear that she wouldn’t play Dance Monkey.
uncertain
she → deny → Monkey
And what did Tones and I’s team say to THAT?
asserted
team → say → THAT
Neither her label or management have responded to our increasingly unhinged requests for clarity.
asserted
label → respond → clarity
But this morning, Tones and I did share an Instagram post announcing three live shows in March 2027 (locations to be announced), with a cheeky aside “PSA: Will be singing all Songs.”
asserted
PSA → share → Songs
And the Macklemore prior commitment – what’s that about?
asserted
that → ’ → what
It’s an interesting side-plot to the story given the last few weeks that Macklemore’s had – but again, details are thin on the ground.
asserted
details → ’ → ground
The pair are friends and collaborated on the single Chant in 2022, and a week ago – when Ed Sheeran was doing a lot of fence-sitting – Tones and I posted a photo of her and Macklemore performing live together: “I am proud of you always, Ben”, she wrote, to which Macklemore replied, “Love you”.
asserted
Macklemore → collaborate → you
Maybe they’re making music together?
asserted
they → make → music
Maybe they’re just hanging out?
asserted
they → hang → ?
We couldn’t find any show dates, and her management didn’t get back to us.
asserted
management → find → us
So no one will be playing before the NRL?
asserted
one → play → NRL
Tones and I did have a crack at suggesting some worthy replacements on Instagram on Tuesday, a diverse group including G Flip, Kaiit, Budjerah, Ruel, Baker Boy and Miss Kaninna.
asserted
Tones → have → Flip
Shannon Noll had a stab at it too: “Looking at all the legends that have played at the NRL GF!” he posted.
asserted
he → have → GF
But V’landys has made up his mind: “People will come to the game with or without it.”
So the mystery of what actually went down here remains somewhat unsolved …
asserted
what → make → it
It’s possible that everybody’s telling a little bit of the truth: that Dance Monkey may have been a problem in some meetings, but that Tones and I had her dance card full regardless.
uncertain
card → ’ → meetings
We may never know.
uncertain
We → know → ?
The Aporia
