Will Alberta’s dual-practice model reduce surgery waits — or only for those who can pay?
asserted
who → reduce → those
Some warn Alberta's dual-practice model could run the risk of repeating mistakes made in Quebec
After nearly three years languishing on the public waitlist for a hip replacement, Cheryl Stewart will finally receive surgery this week.
uncertain
Stewart → warn → surgery
Stewart told CBC’s The National that her pain wasn’t bad at first, but that as time went on, her hip “got 10 times worse,” until she could barely move beyond a short walk from her bed to her kitchen or bathroom.
uncertain
she → tell → kitchen
She’s one of the Canadians caught in the crossfire as provinces search for ways to reduce wait times that have been a problem for more than a decade.
asserted
that → ’ → decade
But in Alberta, where Stewart lives, the province's latest bid for a solution is introducing a controversial system where doctors can simultaneously work in public hospitals and do private care on the side, a model that health advocates say could not only increase public wait times, but may be in violation of the Canada Health Act.
uncertain
advocates → live → Act
The new model, which begins rolling out this month for eligible practitioners as part of a suite of changes brought in by Bill 11, is called dual practice.
asserted
which → begin → Bill
Proponents argue that with proper guardrails, it won’t siphon surgeons from the public care system, but will instead lower wait times for elective surgeries across the board by increasing surgical capacity.
asserted
it → argue → capacity
Critics warn that the data doesn’t support this, and say dual practice promotes a system where money, and not medical need, determines who receives care.
asserted
who → warn → care
Those waiting for non-emergency procedures like hip and knee surgeries, which are often delayed, are feeling the brunt.
asserted
which → wait → brunt
Skipping the line wasn’t an option for Stewart.
asserted
Skipping → skip → Stewart
"To have to go private and spend $35,000, of which I don't have a penny of, that would be an impossible thing for me to come up with," she said.
asserted
she → go → penny
“It’s a two-tiered system.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
You certainly don’t feel like you’re in the upper tier, that’s for sure.”
asserted
that → feel → tier
The 77-year-old added that “all of us have worked and all of us have paid our taxes,” and that it seems “unfair” for some people to be able to pay to get seen faster.
asserted
people → add → taxes
Comparing wait times
Data from both within Canada and from international jurisdictions throws cold water on the idea that private care investment frees up resources for the public sector.
asserted
investment → compare → sector
Alberta’s proposed system is unique within Canada, but it bears similarities to a model already active in Quebec.
asserted
it → propose → Quebec
There, doctors must notify the government before switching from public to private and, as of last year, receive approval first.
asserted
doctors → notify → approval
Quebec — where more than 800 doctors have opted out of the public system to operate privately — has the worst track record out of the four largest provinces on wait times for elective surgeries, according to data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI).
Health-care groups call on Ottawa to stop Alberta’s dual medical practice model
Federal health minister voices concern as Alberta implements dual-practice health-care model
Canadians are supposed to receive hip and knee surgeries within six months of the surgery being ordered, according to the national benchmark set by CIHI.
uncertain
Canadians → opt → CIHI
But according to the latest national data on hip replacements, while 84 per cent of patients in Ontario, where the system remains almost entirely public, get their surgery within that national benchmark time, only 54 per cent of public patients in Quebec meet that benchmark.
uncertain
cent → accord → benchmark
Currently, Alberta falls below the Canadian average of 69 per cent, with 63 per cent of patients on the public side receiving their hip replacement surgeries within the benchmark.
asserted
cent → fall → benchmark
Quebec introduced restrictions on the movement between public and private systems last year to curb the exodus of doctors, but the Montreal Gazette found last month that specialists are still pulling out of the public system.
asserted
specialists → introduce → system
A 2024 study looking at Australia found that when the government tried to push private care to relieve the burden on the public system, it yielded a “limited” real-world impact, only shaving off an average of less than half a day in wait times at public hospitals.
asserted
it → look → hospitals
Private practice expansions in Australia, Ireland and the U.K. exacerbated inequalities and increased surgical wait times, a May article in The Lancet noted in reaction to Alberta’s dual-practice proposal.
uncertain
article → exacerbate → proposal
Alberta insists it will maintain control by imposing strict rules on dual-practice doctors, including mandatory minimum hours in public operating rooms, if needed.
asserted
it → insist → rooms
“We’re going to make sure that doctors who do go into dual practice — and 400 have expressed an interest to do so — that they continue to provide the service to the public system that they historically have,” Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said in a news conference earlier this month, stressing that the intent is to allow surgeons to do more elective surgeries in total by being able to bill privately for extra work on top of their work in the public system.
Private incentives
But experts caution that government oversight of surgeons, who operate as independent contractors, is difficult to enforce.
Karen Palmer, a health policy professor at Simon Fraser University, said these systems simply don't work.
asserted
systems → go → University
"There is no country in the world that allows dual practice ... that has found a way to eliminate its harmful effects even with regulation.
asserted
that → be → regulation
Dual-practice models can also create a built-in conflict of interest, she said.
asserted
she → create → interest
"It incentivizes physicians to increase their public wait times so that patients feel that they sort of have no choice but to pay privately.”
asserted
they → incentivize → choice
Alberta physician Dr. Braden Manns said introducing more private options might allow those with funds to get quicker access, but warns it splits focus for doctors.
uncertain
it → say → doctors
“If the surgeon can get four times as much to do surgery, private, for-pay surgery, they’re going to prioritize that,” he said.
asserted
he → get → that
Manns, who is also the senior associate dean of the Cumming School of Medicine at the University of Calgary, co-authored a recent commentary in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, arguing dual practice will worsen access to public health care.
“We have problems, but these changes are not going to fix them for the public system,” he said.
asserted
he → co → system
“So the only ones benefiting are the chartered surgical facilities, investors and then the insurance industry.”
asserted
ones → benefit → ?
‘Literally killing me’
Those stuck in agony may feel they have no other choice.
uncertain
they → kill → choice
Charlottetown resident Neil Payne was told he’d be waiting 12 to 18 months for surgery on his deteriorating hip, but after six months of being off work, battling pain that sometimes kept him bed-ridden for hours, he couldn’t take it.
asserted
he → tell → it
“It was literally killing me,” Payne, who is a father of seven, said.
asserted
who → kill → seven
So he went to a Montreal clinic to pay for surgery — placing him more than $20,000 in debt.
“It’s a big hit, really," he said.
asserted
he → go → debt
But he has no regrets.
asserted
he → have → regrets
"It was life changing for me."
asserted
It → change → me
One physician who works in both the private and public systems in Quebec maintains that private clinics can help public care, while acknowledging that demand for private care spikes when public hospitals are underfunded.
“With guardrails, it absolutely can work as a complement to what’s available for patients,” Dr. John Antoniou said.
asserted
Antoniou → work → patients
Critics say proven public solutions can do a better job.
asserted
solutions → say → job
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
