For the past nine months, Liberia has used its experiences of prolonged armed conflict to serve as a principled voice in United Nations debates about the humanitarian consequences of a number of the most intractable geopolitical crises – from Gaza and Sudan to Ukraine and Iran.
asserted
Liberia → use → Ukraine
Yet, hidden beneath this virtuous veneer lies a troubling contradiction.
asserted
contradiction → hide → veneer
As my country prepares to assume the rotating presidency of the UN Security Council (UNSC) in December as a non-permanent member, it is flouting our Constitution and contravening UN conventions by hosting deportees expelled from the United States.
asserted
it → prepare → States
A year before its current charm offensive across the Atlantic – where a delegation led by the president is now courting American lawmakers in Washington and broadcasting its peace and security agenda at UN General Assembly convenings in New York – Liberia signed an agreement on September 10, 2025 with the Trump administration to accommodate an undisclosed number of third-country nationals deported from the US.
asserted
Liberia → lead → US
Since January 2025, the Trump administration has struck deportation agreements with 35 countries, almost a third of them in Africa, to receive foreigners whose US immigration statuses range from regularised (and legal) to protected from removal.
asserted
statuses → strike → removal
Liberia’s cooperation is one of the largest and has proved particularly controversial.
asserted
cooperation → prove → largest
Late last month, the first 20 of an expected 1,200 deportees arrived in a widely reported – and condemned – handover at Roberts International Airport (RIA).
asserted
20 → expect → Airport
In a dramatic turn of events, the six who refused to disembark were whisked off to Equatorial Guinea under opaque terms.
asserted
who → refuse → terms
For those still in Liberia, it is equally unclear who they are, why they were deported, where they will reside, whether they are free to leave, and what legal standing they possess.
uncertain
they → deport → standing
Although the agreement between Monrovia and Washington is skimpy on the details, it remains politically fraught, ethically suspect and illegal.
asserted
it → remain → details
Deportations without due process, and involving cruel and inhumane treatment, contravene principles within the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
asserted
Deportations → involve → Rights
Consenting to host third-country nationals without legislative approval breaches Article 34(f) of Liberia’s Constitution.
asserted
Consenting → consent → Constitution
Several deportees who landed at RIA on August 20 said they had been detained in the US without due process, contrary to articles 8 and 10 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantee the right to an “effective remedy” and a “fair and public hearing” before an independent court or tribunal.
asserted
which → land → court
They also said they had been chained during the flight to Liberia, treatment that may violate Article 5, which states that “no one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment”.
uncertain
one → say → treatment
Other UN agreements which may have been flouted include the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which both Liberia and the US are parties.
uncertain
Liberia → flout → which
On the home front, Liberia’s Constitution states plainly that any “treaties, conventions and such other international agreements negotiated or signed on behalf of the Republic” must be ratified by the National Legislature.
asserted
treaties → state → Legislature
Our Legislature neither deliberated on nor approved the agreement to host third-country nationals, which was unilaterally authorised by the executive.
asserted
which → deliberate → executive
On that basis, implementing the agreement without legislative approval is unconstitutional.
asserted
implementing → implement → approval
By accepting mostly Black and brown deportees under such questionable arrangements, Liberia is complicit in executing “make America white again”-era expulsions that would shame its founding mothers and fathers who fled 19th-century chattel slavery and racial discrimination in the US.
asserted
who → accept → US
This small West African country – once a 21st-century poster child for post-war stability – has undercut any credibility it might wield in UNSC deliberations going forward.
uncertain
it → undercut → deliberations
So, what exactly do Liberian policymakers in the executive branch of government hope to gain?
asserted
policymakers → hope → government
What’s in It for Liberia?
asserted
What → ’ → Liberia
As a scholar who researches migration to/from/within Liberia, I was naturally curious about the terms, conditions and implications of Liberia’s bilateral agreement with the US.
asserted
I → research → US
An official press release issued two days before the first batch of deportees was expected turned my curiosity into suspicion.
asserted
batch → issue → suspicion
It spins the agreement as a “humanitarian” arrangement for the “dignified, safe and orderly transfer” of non-criminals removed from the US.
asserted
It → spin → US
It also claims that although Liberia had “not demanded or received any compensation or promise of reward”, “support” would be available for managing the programme and strengthening migration management.
uncertain
support → claim → management
The word “support” deliberately muddles the truth.
asserted
support → muddle → truth
Why would a low-income country agree to host up to 1,200 third-country nationals without monetary incentives when the Trump administration previously paid five foreign governments more than $32m collectively to accept roughly 300 deportees?
asserted
administration → agree → deportees
Nothing added up, so I went looking for answers.
asserted
I → add → answers
I encountered evasion at every turn.
asserted
I → encounter → turn
The minister of foreign affairs said she could not share the agreement with me because it was “at the level of the National Security Council”.
uncertain
it → say → Council
Instead, she forwarded me the press release I had already read – and doubted – as a consolation.
asserted
I → forward → consolation
The president’s national security adviser feigned ignorance.
asserted
adviser → feign → ignorance
The National Security Agency director admitted he had the agreement and would get back to me.
asserted
he → admit → me
I am still awaiting his response.
asserted
I → await → response
And Liberia’s then minister of justice, who has since assumed the role of acting minister of defence, declared haughtily that the agreement remained classified because it was entered into with a “foreign country”.
asserted
it → assume → country
Despite these policymakers’ lack of transparency, I discovered the agreement hidden in plain sight on the US State Department website.
asserted
I → discover → website
It raised alarm not only because of what it says, but also because of what it leaves out, particularly the legitimacy of expelling third-country nationals whose protection claims in the US are pending, as well as rewarding a foreign government [Liberia] for facilitating this.
uncertain
claims → raise → this
If The New York Times’ August 21 story is anything to go by, Trump administration officials agreed to pay Liberia $5m for accepting deportees.
asserted
officials → go → deportees
Not only does this contradict claims of receiving no “compensation or promise of reward”, but remuneration also violates Article 34(f) of Liberia’s Constitution because it was not approved by the National Legislature.
uncertain
it → contradict → Legislature
…and 21 more, not listed.
The Aporia
