Prime Minister Mark Carney touched on a wide range of topics during an hour-long interview with the New York Times yesterday — F-35 jets, Starlink satellites, trade in potash and automobiles and more — but the biggest takeaway was that he had prepared over the past year for the “extreme tail risk” that U.S. President Donald Trump might order military action against Canada.
uncertain
Trump → touch → Canada
“I think you have a responsibility in these roles to look at extreme tail risk,” said Carney, using a term from the financial world that was his metier as a former central banker for Britain and Canada.
asserted
that → think → Britain
“That’s just risk management … it would be irresponsible not to.”
asserted
it → ’ → ?
The expression refers to a scenario that is considered unlikely but not impossible — the “tail” of a probability curve where the centre represents the most likely outcomes.
asserted
centre → refer → outcomes
Carney told the Times that, based on Trump’s threats to make Canada a 51st state, he had carefully examined the possibility of U.S.-led military action, but declined to discuss in detail what that involved.
asserted
that → tell → what
Timothy Sayle, a professor at the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy at the University of Toronto, said Carney’s comments indicate a valid concern.
asserted
comments → say → concern
“It makes sense to me that it’s at the real extreme end of possibilities, but I don’t think it’s a zero per cent chance,” he told National Post.
asserted
he → make → Post
The U.S. incursion into Venezuela this year and its threats against Greenland made its allies, including Canada and Europe, take notice, Sayle said.
asserted
Sayle → make → notice
“It can seem outlandish, but … the United States has made these decisions to enter Venezuela and then to attack Iran that were pretty low-probability events, and yet they did happen.
asserted
they → seem → Iran
So that’s why I can understand the prime minister’s point that it’s maybe very very very low risk but, as he said, can’t be totally ignored.”
asserted
he → ’ → point
As to what form a potential invasion might take, Sayle said the “wild unpredictability of the current American administration” made it difficult to predict, but he imagined several small-scale scenarios.
uncertain
he → take → scenarios
They included “some sort of hot pursuit of a suspected criminal, or somebody that ICE was seeking, across the Canadian border.”
asserted
ICE → include → border
He added: “You could imagine an increase of U.S. forces, like the strengthening of U.S. forces in Canada in some way.”
uncertain
You → add → way
Sayle also suggested “the presence of naval ships, the presence of or overflights by aircraft and … what could be described as something in the shared interest, but in which Canada was not consulted in the usual means.
uncertain
Canada → suggest → means
Americans could either publicly or invisibly flex their might and indicate that Canada’s sovereignty wasn’t quite as secure as we’d like to think.”
uncertain
we → flex → might
The notion has been ridiculed at high levels.
asserted
notion → ridicule → levels
This month, when a Canadian reporter asked Admiral Samuel J. Paparo, commander of the U.S. Pacific Command, about the possibility of military action against Canada, he was met with incredulity.
asserted
he → ask → incredulity
Paparo called it “preposterous” and added: “Would you ask me please, also, what my attack plans are for the Martians?”
asserted
plans → call → Martians
Sayle said that could change.
uncertain
that → say → ?
“Canada and the United States militaries obviously have worked so closely together for so long,” he said.
asserted
he → work → ?
“I’m sure there’s a lot of goodwill and close relationships in the senior ranks, but we are, of course, seeing changes to how general officers are selected in the United States, and who keeps their jobs.”
asserted
who → ’m → jobs
Paparo concluded his remarks by saying he will ultimately follow the orders of the commander-in-chief.
asserted
he → conclude → chief
“And so we have, I think, lots of protections against this; relationships, friendships, common sense,” said Sayle.
asserted
Sayle → have → this
“But these things don’t always govern in a crisis.”
asserted
things → govern → crisis
Carney is hardly the first to speculate on the possibility of war between Canada and the U.S.
asserted
Carney → speculate → Canada
Back in 1921, Lieut.-Col. James “Buster” Sutherland Brown drafted Defence Scheme No. 1, a plan for a Canadian pre-emptive attack against the United States in the event of a conflict between them and the British Empire.
asserted
Brown → draft → them
A Washington Post article from 2005 said the plan called for Canadian soldiers to make for Albany, Minneapolis, Seattle and Great Falls, Mont., at the first signs of a possible U.S. invasion.
asserted
soldiers → say → invasion
The article quotes Floyd Rudmin, Canadian author of the 1993 book “Bordering on Aggression: Evidence of U.S. Military Preparations Against Canada,” as saying Brown even entered the country in civilian clothing to do reconnaissance.
asserted
Brown → quote → reconnaissance
“He had a total annual budget of $1,200,” said Rudmin, “so he himself would drive to the areas where they were going to invade and take pictures and pick up free maps at gas stations.”
asserted
they → say → stations
The plan was terminated in 1928, and many of the documents relating to it were destroyed.
asserted
many → terminate → it
Vincent Rigby, Canada’s former national security and intelligence adviser, told National Post this year that a U.S. invasion “falls into the category of very low probability, but very high impact, to put it mildly.”
asserted
invasion → tell → it
Rigby, who spent 14 years with the Department of National Defence, said the Canadian military is supposed to plan for all scenarios.
asserted
military → spend → scenarios
“They’re very good at it and, given the current situation in the world, given the current state of Canada-U.S. relations, given the current state of U.S. foreign policy, I’m not completely surprised that they’re looking at possible scenarios.
asserted
they → ’re → scenarios
Carney’s comments to the New York Times also included talk of the trade war, a fact Sayle calls salient.
asserted
Sayle → include → war
“It’s a signal to the whole world,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → world
“I don’t think it’s a significant signal to the American government, but maybe a signal more broadly to American politicians and industry leaders as to how seriously Canada is taking this current difficult period with the United States, and I think in some ways it might strengthen the Canadian negotiating hand when it comes to trade issues, because the prime minister is signalling that this was a sort of existential moment for Canada.”
uncertain
this → think → Canada
He added: “Even though it’s an American news outlet, this is a major headline in an international paper that Canadians will see too.
asserted
Canadians → add → that
So … there may be these instrumental reasons for doing it, like the trade negotiations, and signalling to Canadians just how serious he’s taking this moment.
uncertain
he → do → moment
But it’s obviously a pretty important signal of the state of the relationship with the United States, and how different that is than anything in our living memory.”
asserted
that → ’ → memory
The Aporia
