In short:
A study found higher amounts of chytrid fungus in a frog species exposed to coalmine wastewater compared to nearby unexposed sites.
asserted
study → find → sites
The mine company said any casual link between altered water chemistry changes and severity of infection was speculative.
asserted
link → say → infection
Scientists said water quality monitoring programs should include factors like frog health.
asserted
programs → say → health
Frogs in Australia's oldest national park have higher rates of a deadly fungus when exposed to wastewater from a coalmine compared to unexposed waterways, a study suggests.
uncertain
study → have → waterways
The study, published in the Journal of Hazardous Materials Advances last month, looked at chytrid fungus levels in two species of frog in Royal National Park, downstream from the Metropolitan Mine, south of Sydney.
asserted
study → publish → Sydney
Lead author Shannon Kaiser, an ecotoxicologist from Macquarie University, said the wastewater from the mine could not definitively be identified as the cause of the observed disease pattern.
uncertain
wastewater → say → pattern
"However, the association is concerning and suggests pollution and wildlife disease risk may interact in freshwater ecosystems,"he said.
uncertain
pollution → suggest → ecosystems,"he
Mr Kaiser said water quality monitoring programs should be expanded to reflect the potential disease risk to animals from environmental changes.
asserted
programs → say → changes
Typically water monitoring measures things like pollution, temperature and oxygen.
asserted
monitoring → measure → pollution
"Our results suggest biological effects, including frog health and pathogen loads, should also be considered," Mr Kaiser said.
asserted
Kaiser → suggest → health
In response, a spokesperson for Peabody, the mine's operator, said any causal link between water chemistry changes and frog infection intensity described in the study was speculative.
asserted
link → say → study
The study was undertaken between December 2022 and February 2023, a few months after unlicensed discharges of coal contaminated water from Metropolitan Mine overflowed into Camp Gully Creek.
asserted
discharges → undertake → Creek
The NSW Environment Protection Authority fined the mine's operator, Peabody, more than $500,000 and issued clean-up orders along with new regulatory conditions after the incident.
asserted
Authority → fin → incident
The Peabody spokesperson said it had invested more than $1.5 million in upgrades since 2022 to reduce discharge risk.
asserted
it → say → risk
"Including expanded water storage capacity and [Metropolitan Mine] now publishes real-time water quality data on its website covering some of the parameters examined in the study," they said.
"
asserted
they → include → study
Metropolitan separately funds a three-year program in the Royal National Park to support rehabilitation of the southern stuttering frog, a species affected by chytrid fungus.
asserted
Metropolitan → fund → fungus
"
What happened to the frogs?
asserted
What → happen → frogs
Cooper Riach, from Sutherland Shire Environment Centre, raised concerns about frog health after seeing the coal waste enter Camp Gully Creek in 2022.
asserted
waste → raise → 2022
"You could put your hand into the water and just swish your hand around a bit and all this oily, thick, viscous substance would come off the base of the creek," he said.
uncertain
he → put → creek
"We came across a little green frog, which had unfortunately gotten caught up in all this, and it had just got covered in this coal waste."
asserted
it → come → waste
Mr Kaiser saw a photo of the frog and decided to study how exposure to wastewater might impact adult amphibian body condition, immunity, and disease outcomes.
uncertain
exposure → see → condition
Frogs were sampled from sites both exposed and unexposed to wastewater discharge from the coalmine.
asserted
Frogs → sample → coalmine
Unexposed sites included other tributary creeks to the Hacking River, and points on the river before the mine.
asserted
sites → include → mine
Forty-five of the frogs were swabbed to see if they had the chytrid fungus, which can infect their skin.
asserted
which → swab → skin
"Because frogs rely on their skin to regulate water and salts, heavy infections can cause the disease chytridiomycosis, which can be fatal," Mr Kaiser said.
asserted
Kaiser → rely → water
Eighteen frogs tested positive for the fungus across both exposed and unexposed sites.
Leaf green frogs in exposed sites were more severely infected compared to unexposed sites.
asserted
frogs → test → sites
"[Leaf green] frogs in exposed streams carried higher disease load," Mr Kaiser said.
"It dictates whether an infection remains harmless or becomes fatal.
asserted
infection → expose → load
A frog can be infected, but not be lethally impacted.
asserted
frog → infect → ?
"
Leaf green frogs that were dead or showing signs of late-stage chytridiomycosis were only found in exposed sites.
But the infection intensity did not differ greatly between exposed and unexposed sites for the Stony Creek frog.
asserted
intensity → show → frog
The overall number of frogs across both species and their body condition did not differ significantly between sites downstream of the mine and areas that did not receive wastewater.
asserted
that → differ → wastewater
Could something else influence frog disease?
uncertain
something → influence → disease
Mr Kaiser said there could be other reasons the frogs had an increased transmission rate of chytrid in tested exposure sites.
uncertain
frogs → say → sites
Most of the exposed sites were in the Hacking River where having a higher density of frogs, compared to smaller creek areas, could influence fungus spread.
uncertain
having → expose → spread
"It could be that something else is entering that stream that we're not aware of from further upstream from beyond the coalmine," he said.
uncertain
he → enter → coalmine
An EPA spokesperson said it received the frog study and acknowledged the value of emerging environmental research for understanding potential impacts from mine discharges.
asserted
it → say → discharges
They said it had recently required the mine to engage independent experts to undertake macroinvertebrate monitoring in Camp Gully Creek.
asserted
it → say → Creek
"The EPA is currently reviewing the monitoring results to determine whether any further studies or actions are necessary," the EPA spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → review → results
The Aporia