A misunderstanding between Dublin City University (DCU) and the Department of Higher Education has seen €4.4million of taxpayers’ cash wasted.
asserted
4.4million → see → cash
The university has written off the €4.38million in professional fees associated with the development of a new student accommodation block, with nothing to show for it.
asserted
university → write → it
Members of the Dáil’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) described the revelations as ‘absolutely scandalous’ and said the write-off ‘called into question the whole project appraisal process’.
asserted
off → describe → process
The committee heard DCU redesigned a proposed 1,235-bed student accommodation block after the Department of Higher Education refused to provide funding for the project.
asserted
Department → hear → project
The project was due to be co-funded by the university and the department, which provided funding for only 400 beds.
asserted
which → co → beds
The project remained unviable when it was redesigned for 400 beds, and was abandoned altogether when it emerged students would have to pay €11,500 for a room for the academic year, compared to a target of €6,500.
asserted
students → remain → 6,500
It is understood that DCU’s development team wrongly believed the Department of Higher Education would agree to co-fund the project after its completion, to subsidise rents.
asserted
Department → understand → rents
A Government source claimed the department chose to redirect funding to a different student accommodation development at Trinity College.
asserted
department → claim → College
The chairman of the PAC, John Brady, commented that the inability to reduce rents through subsidies was ‘the straw that broke the camel’s back, in relation to the engagement between DCU and the department’.
asserted
that → comment → DCU
The Sinn Féin TD told the committee: ‘The information I have is that DCU were led up the garden path by the department and the co-funding [arrangements] of this particular project.
‘
asserted
DCU → tell → project
The department came back and said, “You need to scale back – this needs to be 400 [beds]”.
asserted
this → come → ?
That pushed up the costs.’
asserted
That → push → costs
Co-funding from the department would have seen rents for the accommodation subsided to an affordable rate, estimated to be around €6,500 per student, for the academic year.
asserted
rents → see → year
However, after the building was redesigned, any potential cost savings were said to have been eaten up by construction inflationary costs, and non-subsided rents increased to an estimated €11,500.
asserted
rents → redesign → 11,500
DCU then walked away from the project and wrote off €4.4million worth of professional fees – for designers, surveyors and architects – in its most recent financial statements.
asserted
DCU → walk → statements
Dublin City University (DCU) ultimately took the decision to shelve the project
asserted
University → take → project
Labour TD Eoghan Kenny said: ‘Ultimately, this project is dead in the water.
asserted
project → say → water
I cannot see how this project will ever proceed.
asserted
project → see → ?
‘It is the taxpayer, once again, having to take up the charge for ultimately what is a failure from the department and the college itself, while many young adults are trying to avail of student accommodation in Dublin.
asserted
adults → have → Dublin
The university first gained planning permission at the site in 2019 and has since been seeking funding solutions to deliver the project, including from the European Investment Bank and Housing Finance Agency.
asserted
university → gain → Bank
Construction was impacted by the Covid pandemic and inflation caused by the outbreak of war in Ukraine.
asserted
Construction → impact → Ukraine
Grant funding was eventually provided by the Government to finance 405 beds in 2023.
asserted
funding → provide → 2023
As inflation continued, however, the university has not been able to find a provider that can deliver the complete project at its current agreed budget.
asserted
that → continue → budget
In October last year, DCU decided to shelve the project.
asserted
DCU → decide → project
This increases with the introduction of new university placements, and sees students scramble annually for secure accommodation in or near their respective campuses.
asserted
students → increase → campuses
The Oireachtas has previously heard of students sleeping in cars or couch-surfing as a result.
asserted
students → hear → result
In its annual financial accounts, DCU detailed that loan funding, drawn down from the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund, was secured against its delivery of existing student accommodation for the project.
asserted
funding → detail → project
The university has previously constructed purpose-built student housing on all three of its campuses in Dublin: on its main campus in Glasnevin, at the St Patrick’s School of Teaching Campus, and at its All Hallows campus.
asserted
university → construct → campus
DCU stated that on a ‘prudent basis’, it was writing off €4.38million – which includes VAT – spent on approved plans associated with its new on-campus student accommodation project.
asserted
which → state → project
‘Due to construction inflation, the project is awaiting a funding solution that can deliver affordable accommodation for students,’ the university’s statement reads.
asserted
statement → await → students
It detailed that the write-off ‘may be reversible’ should the project proceed to delivery and that DCU has planning permissions in place for the development until 2029.
uncertain
DCU → detail → 2029
However, Fianna Fáil TD Séamus McGrath told the PAC yesterday he cannot see the project going ahead.
asserted
project → tell → PAC
‘This calls into question the whole project appraisal process,’ he said.
asserted
he → call → process
‘To go so far down the road without anyone calling for a halt, and to spend €4.38million, only to be stopped at that point...
asserted
anyone → go → point
Any suggestion that some of that could be recovered is trying to get a soft landing here.’
uncertain
some → recover → landing
DCU’s financial statement details that all spending associated with professional fees had been authorised ahead of time.
asserted
spending → detail → time
A DCU spokeswoman said the university continues to work with all stakeholders, including the Department of Further and Higher Education, to identify and secure a funding solution.
asserted
university → say → solution
Mr Brady said: ‘There seem to be huge failures here, on a national level, which have led to a student accommodation crisis and we’re left with a writing off of €4.38million.
asserted
we → say → 4.38million
It is absolutely scandalous, given every year the accommodation crisis that faces students.’
asserted
that → give → students
A spokesman for the Department of Higher Education said that costs of a proposed tender ‘raised value-for-money concerns and, consequently, a decision was taken not to progress the project’.
asserted
decision → say → project
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
