The nutty professor dubbed the “father” of effective altruism (EA), the theory beloved by AI doomers who want the power to police the technology, expressed support for bestiality and said the life of a newborn baby is worth less than a chimp’s or a hog’s.
asserted
life → dub → chimp
Peter Singer is an Australian philosopher and bioethicist who argues that killing disabled infants is not morally wrong, that sex with animals is preferable to raising them for food and that even necrophilia can be moral.
asserted
necrophilia → argue → food
Since the 1970s, he has suggested rejecting traditional concepts of right and wrong and replacing morality solely by calculating and maximizing interests.
uncertain
he → suggest → interests
Now 80, he could have disappeared like many other new-age 20th-century philosophers, if his theories hadn’t been picked up by the wealthy Silicon Valley masters of the universe, including AI bosses such as OpenAI’s Sam Altman and Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei.
uncertain
theories → disappear → Altman
But these apocalyptic theories have less to do with stopping Skynet and more to do with tech bosses seizing power and tightening ranks around their doomsday cult, critics warn.
asserted
critics → have → cult
“In Peter Singer’s universe, there are no rights for anyone,” Scott Walter, former Special Assistant for Domestic Policy to President George W. Bush, told The Post.
asserted
Walter → be → Post
There are only the interests that are claimed or the goals that we set,” said Walter, who is now president of the think tank, Capital Research Center.
asserted
who → be → tank
Taken to its logical extremes, this view has brought Singer to dark places.
asserted
view → take → places
“Killing a disabled infant is not morally equivalent to killing a person.
asserted
Killing → kill → person
Very often, it is not wrong at all,” Singer once wrote in his 1979 book, “Practical Ethics.”
asserted
Singer → write → book
In the same book, he questioned whether a newborn baby’s life was worth as much as a chimpanzee’s.
asserted
life → question → chimpanzee
“If the fetus does not have the same claim to life as a person, it appears that the newborn baby does not either, and the life of a newborn baby is of less value to it than the life of a pig, a dog, or a chimpanzee is to the nonhuman animal,” Singer wrote.
uncertain
Singer → have → animal
Time hasn’t softened his views.
asserted
Time → soften → views
In 2023, he shared a link to a previous interview comparing bestiality favorably in comparison to factory farming.
asserted
he → share → farming
Animals are often superior to humans or at least to the humans that he would be happy to have euthanized,” said Walter.
asserted
Walter → euthanize → that
He added that Singer’s views on killing the disabled have parallels with Nazi Germany.
asserted
views → add → Germany
Walter compares the words of Hitler’s physician, who carried out the first act of euthanasia on a disabled child in the Third Reich, with Singer’s previous claim that even children with hemophilia don’t deserve to live.
uncertain
children → compare → hemophilia
“The passage from Singer says, ‘We’re going to kill the hemophilic kid, so that the next kid can have a better life,'” Walter said.
asserted
Walter → say → life
What makes the comparison all the more tragic is that Singer is a descendant of Holocaust victims, having lost three grandparents in the Nazi deathcamps, Walter points out.
asserted
Walter → make → deathcamps
EA grew out of Singer’s writings, as well as his 2013 TED Talk, but the term itself was coined by his former student, University of Oxford philosopher William MacAskill.
asserted
term → grow → Oxford
In its most basic form, it aims to reduce human suffering to numerical calculations and spreadsheets.
asserted
it → aim → calculations
Its supporters assert that individuals should concentrate on maximizing getting rich, and then donating money to causes based on calculations of maximum impact.
asserted
individuals → assert → impact
That means prioritizing “the hungriest tribe in Sub-Saharan Africa … [over] the Salvation Army or your kid’s Girl Scout troop,” Walter explained.
asserted
Walter → mean → Army
“Postmodern atheist types are often in search of meaning; effective altruism gives them a way to find that meaning without actually defending the claim that right and wrong exist,” Capital Research Center investigative researcher Parker Thayer told The Post.
uncertain
Thayer → give → Post
“That’s essentially, I think, one of the reasons why it was so appealing,” added Thayer, describing the movement as “reductionist” and a “doomsday cult.”
asserted
Thayer → ’ → reductionist
A classic example of EA application in the tech world was Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of the defunct crypto exchange FTX, who started out wanting to help the world — but then justified accumulating billions in wealth by saying he could help even more people with the money later.
uncertain
he → start → money
When EA’s mathematical calculations are extended into the far future, the potential lives of trillions of future human generations pale into insignificance, Thayer explained.
asserted
Thayer → extend → insignificance
Also animal rights,” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
But after COVID, these models took on a more apocalyptic air, while also bringing in big-money figures, such as convicted fraudster Bankman-Fried.
asserted
models → take → Fried
“Bankman-Fried was one of the first people to introduce this from a funding perspective.
asserted
Fried → introduce → perspective
He set up a whole organization that’s now already closed down, obviously, about preventing pandemics,” Thayer said.
asserted
Thayer → set → pandemics
Start your day with all you need to know
Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.
asserted
Report → start → news
That energy has now moved on to AI doomerism, he explained.
asserted
he → move → doomerism
“It’s just another way that they think the apocalypse could happen.”
uncertain
apocalypse → ’ → ?
But while it is tempting to see these figures as cranks, or laughable would-be cult leaders with a messiah complex, Thayer believes that the implications are extremely dangerous.
asserted
implications → see → complex
With previous apocalyptic cults, “once the doomsday doesn’t happen, the cult dismisses itself,” he said.
asserted
he → happen → itself
“However, in this case, it’s going to be harder, because the AI safetyists almost never make a falsifiable prediction on the record.
asserted
safetyists → go → record
“You’ll notice that they’re never willing to give a timeline or a sense of scope or even really describe the methods by which the AI is allegedly going to end the world,” he said.
uncertain
he → notice → world
Walter added that instead, the real danger lies in giving AI doomers “massive government power” over our lives.
asserted
danger → add → lives
“The idea that we should allow a partnership between Anthropic, OpenAI, and the Feds, now that would be a recipe for entrenching this wretched cult in a big bad way,” Walter said, arguing against a doomsday view of AI.
asserted
Walter → allow → AI
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
