Ahead of the U.S. Supreme Court hearing oral arguments in Boulder’s climate lawsuit against major energy companies next month, more than 60 amicus briefs were filed in support of each side.
asserted
briefs → hear → side
Eight Colorado counties — Archuleta, Delta, Garfield, Grand, Mesa, Montezuma, Montrose, and Rio Blanco — filed a brief opposing Boulder’s lawsuit, along with the Associated Governments of Northwest Colorado.
asserted
counties → file → Colorado
How many Colorado cities and counties filed briefs in support of Boulder more than eight years after the case was first introduced?
asserted
case → file → Boulder
That is a striking fact, given the effort from environmental groups and Boulder itself to portray the lawsuit as a defense of Colorado communities.
asserted
That → give → communities
Boulder’s lawsuit has become a national cause célèbre for climate activists.
asserted
lawsuit → become → activists
Democratic attorneys general from around the country and party leaders in Washington, D.C., support it.
asserted
attorneys → support → it
Deep-pocketed environmental activist organizations support it.
asserted
organizations → support → it
Plaintiffs’ lawyers looking for big payouts support it.
asserted
lawyers → look → it
All the while, Boulder has struggled to find comparable support at home.
asserted
Boulder → struggle → home
Even Phil Weiser, as he campaigns for governor, appears determined to avoid taking a position on the substance of Boulder’s claims.
uncertain
he → campaign → claims
That creates an obvious problem for Boulder.
asserted
That → create → Boulder
So, the national supporters of climate litigation needed a more sympathetic Colorado face.
asserted
supporters → need → face
Agriculture contributes approximately $47 billion annually to Colorado’s economy, making it one of the nation’s leading agricultural states, and maintaining agriculture’s historical significance as one of Colorado’s leading economic industries.
asserted
it → contribute → industries
Yet, in a state with a nearly two-century legacy of farming and ranching, the plaintiffs’ bar found a grand total of only seven self-professed ranchers to file an amicus brief in support of Boulder.
asserted
bar → find → Boulder
But these aren’t ordinary rural Coloradans who have wandered into a Supreme Court fight simply because they care about the environment.
asserted
they → wander → environment
One rancher sits on the board of Conservation Colorado, one of the state’s most powerful environmental advocacy organizations, which boasts a high-powered political operation that campaigns for imposing greater costs on energy companies.
asserted
that → sit → companies
Several have spent years operating within national political, environmental, or issue-advocacy networks.
asserted
Several → spend → political
One ran for office as a Democrat, while another served in the legislature and worked as a lobbyist.
asserted
another → run → lobbyist
One even led a political outreach organization in Florida.
asserted
One → lead → Florida
That’s a long way from the cattle herds roaming rural Colorado.
asserted
That → ’ → Colorado
While everyone is entitled to participate in the process, those affiliations matter enormously when national activist groups falsely present these individuals as credible evidence that rural Colorado is rallying behind Boulder.
asserted
Colorado → entitle → Boulder
What this small, politically motivated group also ignores are the real problems that the 30,000-plus authentic ranchers and farmers face, including the rising cost of energy.
asserted
ranchers → ignore → energy
Instead of addressing that issue, Boulder’s lawsuit only tries to make the problem worse by targeting the energy industry for the lawful production of oil and natural gas with a possible multibillion-dollar penalty that would only cause prices to rise even higher.
asserted
prices → address → penalty
Boulder’s attempt to dismantle the energy industry would deeply imperil the ranching community.
asserted
attempt → dismantle → community
Trucks, tractors, irrigation pumps, and all kinds of farm equipment are powered by diesel or gasoline.
asserted
Trucks → power → diesel
Radical environmental activists might romanticize about reverting to the horse and buggy days, hand tools, subsistence farming, and other fantasies, but the world gets fed by farmers and ranchers whose work requires affordable, sustainable supplies of energy.
uncertain
work → romanticize → energy
Natural gas is the key ingredient for the production of commercial fertilizer, which increases crop yields by up to 50%.
asserted
which → increase → %
Without it, the price of food would skyrocket, and hunger would spread across America and the globe.
asserted
hunger → skyrocket → America
That isn’t hyperbole, that’s fact.
asserted
that → ’ → ?
The same radicals waging war on the energy and agriculture industries also howl the loudest about the suffering and hungry poor in the world without understanding what it really takes to produce and distribute massive amounts of safe, affordable, nutritious food.
asserted
it → wag → food
The ranchers’ Supreme Court brief was prepared pro bono not by a local Colorado law firm, but by a New York impact-litigation firm that advertises its work representing activists, progressive nonprofit groups, and organizations seeking large financial payouts from American companies.
asserted
that → prepare → companies
Similar lawsuits have been filed across the country with the support of well-financed environmental activist groups, an army of California and New York-based plaintiffs’ lawyers, and Ivy League academics who have spent years developing and promoting the legal theories behind them.
asserted
who → file → them
Still, not one additional Colorado county was willing to join Boulder before the Supreme Court, nor did the thousands of other bona fide ranchers around Colorado feel compelled to join the New York attorney-led brief.
asserted
thousands → join → brief
The extreme drought conditions throughout most of the Western U.S., labor costs and shortages, tariffs, and already escalating energy costs have farmers and ranchers once again in a big pinch.
asserted
conditions → escalate → pinch
They don’t need yet another financial fast-ball tossed their way.
asserted
They → need → ball
That group of seven has the right to speak for themselves, but they do not speak for the majority in Colorado, and they surely are not representative of the salt-of-the-earth farmers and ranchers that have always been and still are the heart and soul of Colorado.
Bob Beauprez is a fifth-generation Coloradoan.
asserted
Beauprez → have → Colorado
He enjoyed careers as a dairy farmer, banker, real estate developer, member of the U.S. House of Representatives 2003-07, and was the Republican candidate for governor in 2006 and 2014.
asserted
He → enjoy → 2006
Today, he operates a bison breeding ranch in Jackson County with his wife, son, and daughter-in-law.
asserted
he → operate → wife
The Aporia
