The New South Wales government’s crackdown on “AI-doctored” rental listings has hit a wall, after it made an example of a supposedly manipulated ad that turned out to be a genuine photograph of a $5,000 courtyard mural of Bondi beach.
asserted
that → doctor → beach
In a media release on Friday announcing protections against misleading rental ads, the state government provided a link to a property in Leichhardt, claiming it was an “AI-doctored rental listing in Sydney’s Inner West”.
asserted
it → announce → West
But the listing agency IB Property denied the images were altered.
asserted
images → deny → ?
A spokesperson confirmed the photograph shows a mural of Bondi beach on an internal courtyard wall visible through the unit’s windows, rather than a false digital depiction of coastal views.
“We can confirm that the image has not been altered or digitally generated using AI, Photoshop or any other image-editing software,” the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → confirm → AI
When Guardian Australia visited 2/14 Norton Street, the artwork was not visible from the street.
asserted
artwork → visit → street
IB Property explained the mural sits within an internal courtyard and provided photos taken inside the unit confirming it remains in place.
asserted
it → explain → place
“The mural was commissioned and paid for by the landlord at a cost of approximately $5,000, and we can also confirm that there are no plans for it to be removed,” the spokesperson said, adding that the property was leased in February 2026 and has not been advertised since.
asserted
property → commission → February
The better regulation and fair trading minister, Anoulack Chanthivong, whose office issued the media release, didn’t respond directly to questions from Guardian Australia, but did issue the following statement:
“Every renter knows the frustration of seeing a property online, only to turn up and find it looks nothing like the listing.
asserted
it → issue → listing
“These laws are about putting an end to misleading practices and making sure renters get a fair go.
asserted
get → put → go
We will always stand on the side of renters.”
asserted
We → stand → renters
Despite the mix-up, the new laws target an increasing market issue.
asserted
laws → target → issue
Under the legislation, real estate businesses in NSW will face fines of up to $22,000 for failing to disclose digitally altered or AI-generated property images.
asserted
businesses → face → images
The bill targets the rapid rise of “housefishing” – where digital alterations distort the true size and condition of a home.
asserted
alterations → target → home
Chanthivong said the new laws would establish strong protections against misleading property marketing and support ethical AI use.
asserted
laws → say → use
The regulations take effect in early 2027.
asserted
regulations → take → 2027
Virtual staging v distorting reality
asserted
staging → distort → reality
The legislation arrives as generative AI embeds itself in property marketing nationwide.
asserted
AI → arrive → marketing
Tim McKibbin, the chief executive of the Real Estate Institute of NSW, said generative AI complicates pre-existing digital enhancement in the industry.
asserted
AI → say → industry
“This technology has been available for some years now … people have used Photoshop,” he said.
asserted
he → use → Photoshop
“People were removing trees and removing telegraph poles … clearly that is false and misleading.”
asserted
that → remove → poles
McKibbin draws a line between virtual staging and false advertising.
asserted
McKibbin → draw → staging
“I’ve seen instances where agents have put furniture into the photographs …
asserted
agents → see → photographs
Now, that is merely giving you an indication of what you could do,” he said.
uncertain
he → give → what
Stewart Bunn, of First National Real Estate, said consumer trust is being tested by poor industry examples, referencing a 2024 instance where an LJ Hooker branch used AI to generate a listing with nonexistent schools.
“We have seen examples across the industry where AI-generated images have depicted renovations that have not occurred, furnishings that create an unrealistic impression of scale, landscaping that does not exist or finishes that materially differ from the actual property,” Bunn said.
asserted
Bunn → say → property
“The best practice is simple: if a buyer would be surprised by what they see when they arrive at the property, the advertising has gone too far.”
AI ‘hallucinations’
An RMIT University report led by Dr Leah Li, funded by the Australian Property Institute, found a “significant lack of sector-specific AI frameworks to guide responsible AI practice within the property profession”.
asserted
report → surprise → profession
Public confidence remains fragile: a 2026 Cotality study showed only 40% of Australians trust AI-generated outputs, compared with 62% in Canada, 52% in the US, and 46% in the UK.
asserted
% → remain → UK
Dr Shuai Wang, a research fellow at the University of Queensland, said generative AI systems prioritise visual appeal over accuracy.
asserted
systems → say → accuracy
In real estate, this can manifest as “hallucinations”.
asserted
this → manifest → hallucinations
“AI hallucinations can occur when AI-generated images introduce features that were never part of the property,” Li said, fundamentally changing a prospective tenant’s perception of “size, layout, condition, or amenity”.
asserted
Li → occur → size
Leo Patterson Ross, the chief executive of the Tenants’ Union of NSW, said deceptive imagery can artificially inflate rental markets by creating fake demand.
“By inflating the number of people who appear interested in a place and increasing pressure on someone to rush to put in an application or even offer above the advertised rent.”
asserted
who → say → rent
Patterson Ross said stricter measures were necessary, rather than just disclosure.
asserted
measures → say → disclosure
“The bill only requires disclosure of the use of digital alterations.
asserted
bill → require → alterations
We think any use of imagery that misrepresents the property should be disallowed.”
asserted
that → think → property
Li said long-term resolution will require national coordination combining “transparency requirements, professional accountability, industry standards, regulatory oversight, and consumer education”.
asserted
resolution → say → requirements
“Trust does not come from simply adopting AI; trust comes from transparency about how AI has been used and confidence that it is being used responsibly.”
asserted
it → come → transparency
For tenants navigating tight rental markets, AI distortion has added a frustrating layer of deception.
asserted
distortion → navigate → deception
Roxanne Gardiner, 26, said AI-generated imagery was “rife” during her search for a rental in Brisbane’s eastern suburbs.
asserted
imagery → say → suburbs
“I was constantly getting scammed by listing photos,” she said.
asserted
she → scamme → photos
“What’s so embarrassing is we didn’t even realise one of the first houses we saw was AI until we rocked up there.
asserted
we → ’ → houses
“The AI furniture is not accurate to the rooms and would usually make them look bigger than they were.”
asserted
they → make → rooms
…and 14 more, not listed.
The Aporia
