Justice Department under Trump asks EU to scrap $137M US fine for Elon Musk's X
EU issued $137M US fine to X for 'deceptive design practices'
The European Union's executive arm said Friday it's prepared to defend a 120 million euro ($137 million US) fine against the social media platform X after the U.S. government threw its support behind a legal effort by Elon Musk this week to have the case dismissed.
asserted
case → ask → Musk
The European Commission fined X late last year for breaches of the bloc's landmark digital regulations, stoking tensions with Washington.
asserted
Commission → fin → Washington
The fine amount equates to $194 million Cdn.
asserted
amount → equate → Cdn
The EU action followed a two-year investigation and was the first penalty issued under the bloc's digital regulations governing online content.
asserted
action → follow → content
Regulators said X's blue checkmarks broke the rules because they involved "deceptive design practices" and could expose users to scams and manipulation.
uncertain
they → say → scams
The U.S. Justice Department said Thursday that it had filed an application to support X's bid to have the case annulled at the European Union's General Court.
asserted
case → say → Court
"We will not tolerate the European Commission engaging in regulatory overreach to try and control American engines of innovation and economic growth," said Brett Shumate, assistant attorney general of the Justice Department's Civil Division.
asserted
Shumate → tolerate → Division
European Commission spokesperson Thomas Regnier said Friday that it is the EU's "sovereign right" to draft legislation aimed at protecting its citizens.
asserted
it → say → citizens
"We are enforcing our legislation objectively, transparently and with a solid case," he told reporters.
asserted
he → enforce → reporters
"We are ready to defend our position in court.
asserted
We → defend → court
We have a lot of evidence at our disposal, and it will be for the court to decide as always."
asserted
court → have → disposal
The commission is the top enforcer of the 27-nation EU's Digital Services Act (DSA), which requires tech companies to clean up their online platforms under threat of hefty financial penalties.
asserted
which → require → penalties
The DSA imposes a set of strict requirements designed to keep internet users safe online, including making it easier to report counterfeit or unsafe goods or flag harmful or illegal content like hate speech as well as a ban on ads targeted at children.
asserted
it → impose → children
But the rulebook has become a flashpoint with the Trump administration, and U.S. officials have criticized it as amounting to online censorship.
asserted
officials → become → censorship
When asked whether the Justice Department had informed the commission that it intended to back Musk, Regnier said: "We do not need to be informed about anything."
asserted
We → ask → anything
He said the commission doesn't expect the case to hurt broader relations between Brussels and Washington, notably in talks to mitigate the damage of Trump administration tariffs.
asserted
case → say → tariffs
"From our perspective, nothing will change because of a DSA case," he said.
asserted
he → change → case
'At odds with U.S. law'
The Justice Department warned that the fine, if upheld, "may have significant implications" for U.S. online platforms and other companies providing digital services in the EU.
uncertain
fine → warn → EU
Shumate said in Thursday's statement that the "European Commission inappropriately attempted to expand its regulatory authority to reach American companies not present or operating within its jurisdiction."
asserted
Commission → say → jurisdiction
- Analysis
As Canada deepens ties with Europe, could it leave U.S. banks and dollars behind?
Republican senator warns Carney against tightening Canada's links to European Union
Former U.S. federal prosecutor Ankush Khardori said on his website Friday that Shumate's contention was "a basic category error that also happens to be at odds with U.S. law.
uncertain
that → deepen → law
"
"A company does not have to be physically 'present' somewhere in order to operate within the jurisdiction and be subject to that jurisdiction’s laws," he said.
asserted
he → have → laws
Khardori also said it was "galling" that the Justice Department called on the EU to be "consistent with how territorial jurisdiction is generally understood in international law," given that the Trump administration has been accused of activities that are contrary to international law, including their seizure of Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro and its deadly strikes on boats allegedly being used for drug trafficking.
uncertain
that → say → trafficking
Musk on Thursday evening was among the tech executives attending a state dinner held by Trump honouring China's leader Xi Jinping.
Musk giving to Republican candidates again
It was the second time in three months that the Justice Department has intervened to defend a company owned by Musk.
asserted
Department → attend → Musk
In July, the Justice Department filed a motion to intervene in a civil rights lawsuit that alleges Musk's xAI is illegally running dozens of natural gas turbines to power a $20 billion US AI data centre in Mississippi.
asserted
xAI → file → Mississippi
In that case, the groups suing xAI said it failed to get a permit for its power plant, which is located near homes, schools and churches.
asserted
which → sue → homes
Trump and the world's richest businessman appeared to dial down a war of words that stunned Washington and Wall Street alike last year after Musk called Trump's tax breaks and spending cuts a "disgusting abomination."
asserted
Musk → appear → breaks
The statements followed a controversial designation of Musk as a special government employee, where he oversaw a cost-cutting blitz within the federal bureaucracy.
asserted
he → follow → bureaucracy
Musk was encharged with those responsibilities despite conflict of interest concerns, given that his companies often have bid for government contracts or have been embroiled in civil litigation with federal agencies.
asserted
companies → encharge → agencies
Musk's time with the Department of Governmental Efficiency, which ended in May 2025, could come under scrutiny, however, if the Democrats regain one or both chambers of Congress in the Nov. 3 midterms.
uncertain
Democrats → end → midterms
Some Democratic lawmakers want Musk subpoenaed to testify about his actions at DOGE.
asserted
Musk → want → DOGE
Musk is again using his super PAC to help fund Republican candidates ahead of the midterms.
asserted
Musk → use → midterms
The Aporia
