A small Christian college founded by controversial, self-described "libertarian theocrat" and "Christian nationalist" pastor Doug Wilson claims in a new lawsuit that officials in Moscow, Idaho, are using the city's zoning code to discriminate against its religious mission.
uncertain
officials → found → mission
In a complaint filed in federal court in early September, New Saint Andrews College argues that Moscow officials have imposed on it a long list of permitting requirements, use restrictions, and parking mandates that apply to no other entity in town.
asserted
that → file → town
While other businesses in the downtown are not required to provide any parking, the lawsuit claims, New Saint Andrews must maintain 89 parking spaces.
uncertain
Andrews → require → spaces
The city has allowed the public University of Idaho to operate an art gallery in the downtown zone, while preventing New Saint Andrews from doing the same, reads the complaint.
asserted
complaint → allow → same
Most recently, Moscow has prevented New Saint Andrews from performing administrative work in office space it rented in the city's downtown.
asserted
it → prevent → downtown
City zoning staff argue that such work would qualify as a "college and university" use that is not allowed in the downtown zone.
asserted
that → argue → zone
In order to comply with the zoning restriction on university uses, New Saint Andrews has been required to hire a third-party business service organization to do the exact work in the exact same space.
asserted
Andrews → comply → space
The college's lawsuit attributes this disparate treatment to officials' hostility to its particular brand of Protestantism, citing public statements from a city councilmember about the need to "fight" Wilson's "Christian nationalist church."
asserted
lawsuit → attribute → church
Prior to making those comments, the same councilmember had voted to reject a zoning variance New Saint Andrews had requested that would have allowed the college to use its downtown office space directly.
asserted
college → make → space
New Saint Andrews' lawsuit claims this amounts to a violation of the U.S. and Idaho's protections of individual liberty.
uncertain
this → claim → liberty
They also claim that Moscow is violating a federal law that places robust restrictions on localities' ability to regulate religious land uses.
uncertain
that → claim → uses
Wilson, who continues to be a trustee and senior fellow at the college, is a controversial figure both locally in Moscow and nationally, given his advocacy for a Protestant confessional state that restricts the public expression of other faiths and imposes legal sanctions on biblically proscribed behavior like adultery and homosexuality.
asserted
that → continue → adultery
Other affiliates of his church have made similar claims of religious discrimination by zoning officials in other Northern Idaho towns.
uncertain
affiliates → make → towns
The city of Moscow did not respond to Reason's request for comment.
asserted
city → respond → comment
New Saint Andrews declined Reason's request for comment.
asserted
Andrews → decline → comment
Hostility to Wilson and his church could well explain Moscow's seemingly arbitrary restrictions on New Saint Andrews.
uncertain
Hostility → explain → Andrews
But zoning officials need no special cause to impose arbitrary restrictions on property owners.
asserted
officials → need → owners
Zoning codes commonly regulate activities that produce the same neighborhood effects (or even no neighborhood effects) differently depending on who's doing them.
asserted
who → regulate → them
A person recording music in their garage with a friend is permissible.
asserted
person → record → friend
A person recording music in their garage for a paying client is a zoning violation.
asserted
person → record → client
A chain burrito restaurant serving the same food in the same place is a zoning violation.
asserted
restaurant → serve → place
In the New Saint Andrews case, it clearly makes no difference to the wider world whether its administrative work is performed by the college directly or if it is farmed out to a contractor.
asserted
it → make → contractor
Only in the pages of Moscow's zoning code does this physically imperceptible distinction matter.
asserted
distinction → matter → code
Fortunately for the college, federal law provides explicit protections for religious land uses.
asserted
law → provide → uses
Similar to restrictions on speech, the law requires local land use regulations of religious uses to be narrowly tailored to achieving a compelling government interest.
asserted
regulations → require → interest
New Saint Andrews seemingly has a strong case that Moscow's arbitrary restrictions on it specifically violate those federal legal protections.
asserted
restrictions → have → protections
As one final note, it is somewhat ironic that a college with such close ties to Wilson would make a religious liberty claim about the land use regulations being imposed on it.
uncertain
college → make → it
In various interviews, Wilson said that in his ideal America, there would be explicit restrictions on the public expressions of other faiths, whether that's Hindu statues, minaret-sporting Mosques, or Catholic Marian processions.
asserted
that → say → faiths
As it stands, the First Amendment does not allow explicit religious discrimination.
asserted
Amendment → stand → discrimination
Federal law would further protect the Hindu statue or the Mosque's architectural embellishments from the arbitrary whims of the zoning board.
asserted
law → protect → board
New Saint Andrews is now making use of the same neutral protections of religious liberty and religious land uses that Wilson would deny others.
asserted
Wilson → make → others
Perhaps the lawsuit will provide a teachable moment about the value of broadly applicable protections of individual liberty.
asserted
lawsuit → provide → liberty
The Aporia
