In April 2025, the West Virginia Legislature passed a law that would give itself power over state Board of Education regulations.
asserted
that → pass → regulations
Voters have twice defeated constitutional amendment proposals that would have given the Legislature control.
asserted
that → defeat → control
Lawmakers proceeded anyway, saying at the time they intended to trigger a lawsuit, so the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals would have to decide.
asserted
Court → proceed → Appeals
The school board filed suit in October of last year, and on Tuesday, the case came before the court.
asserted
case → file → court
What’s the case about?
asserted
case → ’ → What
Under the West Virginia Constitution, the state school board has wide powers to determine educational policy, from curriculum to the proper way for students to board a bus.
asserted
students → have → bus
Other state agencies and boards can set rules, but whenever those rules are proposed, lawmakers get a chance to tweak them before they go into effect.
asserted
they → set → effect
For instance, the Department of Natural Resources submitted a rule for legislative approval that sets up containment areas and disposes of carcasses for diseased animals.
asserted
that → submit → animals
In 1958, the school board became an independent body with general supervision over schools, after voters approved a constitutional amendment.
asserted
voters → become → amendment
The board filed its rules with the Secretary of State’s Office, and those rules were published in the State Register.
asserted
rules → file → Register
Over the years, the school board’s authority has been challenged.
asserted
authority → challenge → years
In 1988, the Legislature passed a law that would effectively give the Legislature the ability to review any policies passed by the school board.
asserted
that → pass → board
If the Legislature didn’t review the policy, then it was nullified.
asserted
it → review → policy
The state Supreme Court struck that law down, ruling it violated the state Constitution, in a case brought by the Board of Education against then-Secretary of State Ken Hechler.
asserted
it → strike → Hechler
In 2025, Del. Mike Hornby, R-Berkeley, introduced a bill to force the school board to submit its rules before the Legislature, like most other state agencies.
asserted
Hornby → introduce → agencies
He said he did so knowing this would spark a court challenge.
asserted
this → say → challenge
“I do believe the Supreme Court got it wrong,” Hornby said.
asserted
Hornby → believe → ?
Lawmakers passed the bill.
asserted
Lawmakers → pass → bill
Later that year, the school board filed suit after the Secretary of State’s Office referred one of its rules regarding school bus design to the Legislature instead of publishing it.
asserted
Office → file → it
Why does this matter?
asserted
this → matter → ?
The 1958 constitutional amendment was intended to separate education from partisan politics.
asserted
amendment → intend → politics
The last time the question of letting the Legislature have the final say over school board policy came to a vote, opponents cautioned that it would open the door to allowing politicians to impose their ideological will on how students are taught.
asserted
students → let → will
Voters agreed.
asserted
Voters → agree → ?
Voters rejected an amendment supported by Gov. Gaston Caperton in 1989 to give the Legislature and the governor oversight of the school board by a 9-to-1 margin.
asserted
Voters → reject → margin
In 2022, 58% of voters rejected a similar proposal offered by the Legislature.
asserted
% → reject → Legislature
But Hornby said it was never his intention to take over the school board, or even to look at matters of curriculum.
asserted
it → say → curriculum
As a member of the Legislative Rulemaking Review Committee and the Legislative Oversight Commission on Educational Accountability, Hornby said he wanted to be able to work more closely with the school board in crafting policy.
asserted
he → say → policy
“We can say all we want about school aid formulas, discipline, aides,” he said.
asserted
he → say → aid
“But if we can’t collaboratively work with the Department of Education to ensure that the rules that they’re passing meet what the standards and what the best practices are for West Virginia, then I don’t see the point.”
asserted
I → work → point
If Hornby’s law prevails, then lawmakers would have the option to strike rules offered by the Board of Education, or radically alter them.
asserted
lawmakers → prevail → them
However, the state school board argues that this kind of oversight is contrary to the will of the voters and the state constitution.
asserted
kind → argue → voters
“Additionally, requiring WVBE policies to be reviewed by the State Legislature will result in delays that will be detrimental to student success and well-being,” the board said in a statement released in July 2025 prior to filing its suit.
asserted
board → require → suit
What’s the Secretary of State Office’s argument?
asserted
argument → ’ → State
The state Supreme Court met Tuesday to hear arguments about legislative authority over Board of Education rulemaking.
asserted
Court → meet → rulemaking
While the state constitution gives the school board general supervision, it also says that “the Legislature shall provide, by general law, for a thorough and efficient system of free schools.”
asserted
Legislature → give → schools
The state constitution doesn’t give an executive agency carte blanche to decide its own rules without Legislative oversight, argued Michael Williams, an Attorney General lawyer representing the Secretary of State.
asserted
Williams → give → State
He said ultimately, the Legislature gets the final say.
asserted
Legislature → say → say
“This court has held that it lets the Legislature regulate how duties are performed, so long as it doesn’t abolish the office or empty out its functions,” Williams said.
asserted
Williams → hold → functions
Williams said the new law differs from the 1988 law in that it gives legislators a chance to approve, amend or reject the proposed rules, but if they don’t vote on the rule within 15 months, it is automatically approved.
asserted
it → say → months
In the previous law, if legislators didn’t vote on a rule it was rejected.
asserted
it → vote → rule
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
