It’s easy to understand why the day-to-day operations of Canada’s four busiest airports are on the federal auction block.
asserted
operations → ’ → block
Ottawa would retain the land and infrastructure, but sell the businesses that run them, which handled 115 million passengers last year.
asserted
which → retain → passengers
When he announced the sale on Sept. 15, Prime Minister Mark Carney said that the feds would reap “tens of billions of dollars” from the sale.
asserted
feds → announce → sale
But apart from that one-time windfall, there is slight indication that the public interest would be served by selling these crown jewels among Canada’s government-owned assets.
asserted
interest → be → assets
We’ll come back to that in a moment.
asserted
We → come → moment
Let’s continue with the Carney government’s motives for this portion of its mooted dismantling of Canadian public assets, which includes ports on the Atlantic and Pacific coasts and the St. Lawrence Seaway.
asserted
which → let → coasts
The airports — in Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver and Calgary — are “turnkey” operations that will spin revenues and profits for their new owners from the moment the sale agreements is signed.
asserted
agreements → spin → moment
By contrast, the dozens of nation-building projects Ottawa has under consideration — critical minerals mines, a hydro-electic megaproject on the east coast, a West Coast crude oil pipeline in Alberta and B.C. — are in various stages of development.
asserted
Ottawa → build → development
Some are still on the drawing boards, some await regulatory approval, and a small number are under construction.
asserted
number → await → construction
None are close to completion, much less producing revenue.
asserted
None → produce → revenue
Ottawa has long wanted Canada’s giant public pension funds and asset managers to come off the sidelines and invest more heavily in projects that rebuild Canada, repatriating at least some of the enormous sums they have invested overseas.
asserted
they → want → sums
It’s not like Carney needs the money from selling airport assets.
asserted
Carney → ’ → assets
He is a year ahead of his plan to balance the government’s operating budget by 2028.
asserted
He → balance → 2028
What Carney, the career investment banker as well as central banker, needs is some dealmaking by which deep-pocketed investors at home and abroad finance planned Canadian projects that come with no small amount of risk.
asserted
that → need → risk
The theory is that a private owner of the lucrative Toronto Pearson Airport might be more persuadable in later backing a power corridor to Churchill, Man.
uncertain
owner → back → Churchill
Just about every member of the “Maple Eight” largest public pension funds is interested in buying a share of these major Canadian gateways with their reliable, long-term cash flows and captive airlines and air travelers.
asserted
member → buy → flows
It’s housing, critical minerals extraction and processing, and energy and transportation infrastructure that’s in need of capital.
asserted
that → ’ → capital
Carney has tried to sell his idea as an affordability measure that would reduce airfares.
asserted
that → try → airfares
“The evidence shows travel costs go down over time,” Carney had said.
asserted
Carney → show → time
But the evidence shows the contrary.
asserted
evidence → show → contrary
From Britain to Australia, competition authorities have found that after privatization, fees have risen for airlines, which pass them along to travelers.
asserted
which → find → travelers
In some years, the privatized Heathrow tops the list as the world’s most expensive airport.
asserted
Heathrow → top → airport
Private airport investors need to raise profits by 15-to-20 per cent to pay investors, David Macdonald, a senior economist at the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, testified earlier this year to a Senate committee.
asserted
Macdonald → need → committee
Wab Kinew, the Manitoba premier, put it more crudely: “When you privatize an airport, the only way for the big investors to make money is either making it more expensive to fly or by cutting the wages of the people who work there, or both.
asserted
who → put → people
“Colour me a little skeptical that all of a sudden handing over a ton of money-making opportunity to some rich folks is going to help the average Canadian out there.”
Privatization of major airports has never caught on in North America.
asserted
Privatization → colour → America
The likes of LAX, JFK, O’Hare and Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta are owned by public authorities, the model used in Canada and Mexico, as well.
asserted
likes → own → Canada
Some national governments in Western Europe and Australia have fully or partially privatized airports, but many have not.
asserted
many → privatize → airports
The reason is that affordability at privatized airports is almost always diminished.
asserted
affordability → diminish → airports
The Liberals don’t have an electoral mandate for one of the biggest ever sales of public assets, having chosen not to include it in their 2025 election platform.
asserted
Liberals → have → platform
The Carney government has not since conducted public hearings on the potential sale.
asserted
government → conduct → sale
Even members of the Liberal caucus were kept uninformed, and were blindsided by Carney’s Sept. 15 announcement.
asserted
members → keep → announcement
Done right, airport privatization would follow a public inquiry into the merits and drawbacks of different models of ownership worldwide in what is, after all, an essential service.
asserted
what → do → ownership
The Aporia
