- Published
Housing Secretary Angela Rayner has said she is concerned about Labour's proposals to change visa rules, which would make it harder for foreign workers to secure permanent residency in the UK.
asserted
workers → publish → UK
In an interview with the Times, external ahead of Labour's annual conference, Rayner questioned Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood's plans, saying they are unfair because they "change the goalposts".
asserted
they → question → goalposts
Under the proposals, most migrants would have to wait 10 years to qualify for residency - instead of the current five - while foreign workers on health and social care visas would face a 15-year wait.
asserted
workers → have → wait
Mahmood said the government would make a decision on the immigration overhaul by the end of the year.
asserted
government → say → year
Speaking to the Times, Rayner said she was concerned about shifting "the goalposts years down the line" for people who arrived in the UK at the beginning of this decade, expecting to secure permanent residence under the current rules.
asserted
who → speak → rules
She described the potential rule change as "very disruptive" and added: "I do have concerns about that."
During her interview with Times, she said that the changes would impact foreign care workers who "moved their lives here to look after our loved ones".
asserted
who → describe → ones
Her remarks represent direct criticism of a policy inherited by Prime Minister Andy Burnham from his predecessor, Sir Keir Starmer.
asserted
remarks → represent → predecessor
Rayner previously served as deputy prime minister under Sir Keir, and was brought back into cabinet by Burnham in July.
asserted
Rayner → serve → July
It is significant that a serving cabinet minister feels able to criticise an existing government proposal on the eve of Labour's conference, albeit one inherited from the Starmer era.
asserted
minister → serve → era
It is part of a growing head of steam from some parts of the party to quash the retrospective elements of these plans.
asserted
It → grow → plans
Rayner has previously criticised the measures.
asserted
Rayner → criticise → measures
In June, she said proposals to retrospectively alter the rules for migrants already working in the UK would be "wrong".
asserted
proposals → say → UK
Rayner said she believed that Mahmood was aware of her position, telling the Times she has "not changed [her] view" since re-entering the cabinet.
asserted
she → say → cabinet
Before he became prime minister, Burnham said he "understood" where Rayner was coming from on her criticisms of the migrant visa changes, telling reporters in June that Labour "would do well to listen to what Angela has to say".
asserted
Angela → become → what
In recent weeks, trade unions have put pressure on the government to soften its proposals, and a letter to Mahmood jointly-signed by dozens of Labour MPs at the start of the year described the plans as "un-British".
asserted
letter → put → plans
Lisa Nandy, secretary of state for culture, media and sport, rejected the "un-British" description of the plans.
asserted
Nandy → reject → plans
She told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I don't think they are un-British because I don't think that we have ever had an automatic right to citizenship for most people who come to the UK from overseas."
asserted
who → tell → UK
Nandy said the home secretary was trying to balance respect for people "regardless of who they or where they stand" with the need for "an immigration system that people have confidence in".
asserted
people → say → confidence
Asked if Labour could change its mind on the proposal, she told Today: "We always reserve the right to change our minds but we also will reserve the right to stick to our plans if we think we are getting them right".
uncertain
them → ask → plans
Nandy's comments are a hint the government is reconsidering.
asserted
government → reconsider → ?
She could have given a full-throated defence of the principle of backdating the changes so they apply to those foreign workers already here.
uncertain
they → give → workers
But she did not.
asserted
she → do → ?
Instead she emphasised the principle of those "contributing" to the UK and treating them fairly.
asserted
those → emphasise → them
But if the government does reverse course on applying these changes to those arriving from 2021, the large numbers who came to the UK after that date have a quicker and easier route to settlement.
asserted
who → reverse → settlement
That is a dividing line with the Conservatives and Reform UK that those parties will be keen to highlight.
asserted
parties → divide → that
The home secretary faced questions about the changes during an appearance at the Home Affairs Committee earlier this week.
asserted
secretary → face → Committee
Mahmood said she was "very aware that a large group of people who arrived in 2022, absent any change, would qualify in February 2027" for permanent settlement.
asserted
who → say → settlement
She added: "Later this year we will set out the new policy on settlement... as well as any transitional arrangements we might decide to implement."
uncertain
we → add → settlement
The Aporia
