I rarely pay attention to advertisements, but one that targeted neuropsychologists like me recently caught my eye.
asserted
that → pay → eye
Sponsored by the social justice and advocacy committee of the Hispanic Neuropsychological Society, it invited me to join online training sessions focused on immigration.
asserted
it → sponsor → immigration
Specifically, it promised to help me and my peers document illegal immigrants’ “cognitive impairments or severe emotional barriers that may justify exceptions to procedural requirements.”
uncertain
that → promise → requirements
The implication was that psychologists could help people avoid deportation.
uncertain
people → help → deportation
Concerned about advocacy overriding objectivity in immigration-related psychological practice, I decided to attend four training sessions over the summer.
asserted
I → concern → summer
What I saw deeply concerned me about the intellectual integrity of my profession, as well as the strength of the rule of law.
asserted
saw → see → law
The sessions focused on “immigration evaluations,” which are mental health assessments, frequently authored by psychologists, that can influence an immigration proceeding.
asserted
that → focus → proceeding
They are widely used when deportation is on the table.
asserted
deportation → use → table
Several presenters stated that they considered these evaluations a form of social justice advocacy, and one psychologist said that evaluations don’t need to be comprehensive because Immigration and Customs Enforcement attorneys lack the expertise to challenge a psychologist’s conclusions.
asserted
attorneys → state → conclusions
It turned out that another presenter had written favorably about psychologists resisting ICE.
asserted
presenter → turn → ICE
Altogether, I left the trainings concerned that biased evaluations may be undermining America’s immigration system.
uncertain
evaluations → leave → system
In immigration law, a psychologist’s findings can fundamentally alter the outcome of a case.
asserted
findings → alter → case
A trauma diagnosis, for instance, supports an illegal immigrant’s claim that they experienced persecution in their country and therefore deserve asylum in the United States.
uncertain
they → support → States
Psychological evaluations have been shown to roughly double an immigrant’s chances of a positive outcome.
asserted
evaluations → show → outcome
Psychological reports can also explain away credibility-damaging discrepancies in an illegal immigrant’s testimony; psychologists may claim that the errors are due to trauma-related memory distortion.
uncertain
errors → explain → distortion
Psychiatric diagnoses are also used to buttress illegal immigrants’ requests for what’s known as an “extreme hardship waiver,” which allows the immigrant to remain in the U.S. rather than be deported if extreme mental or physical hardship to a close relative who is a U.S. resident can be demonstrated.
asserted
who → use → relative
U.S. Customs and Immigration Service data show that such waivers had an approval rate approaching 90% in 2025.
asserted
waivers → show → 2025
Though humanitarian exceptions to deportation exist for justifiable reasons, Americans should worry that trauma and other mental-health diagnoses are being manufactured by sympathetic psychologists to unfairly aid illegal immigrants.
asserted
trauma → exist → immigrants
Recent state changes to licensing laws mean that most psychologists can now conduct telehealth evaluations in most of the nation without leaving their desk, and entrepreneurial practitioners have built group telehealth practices capable of evaluating multiple illegal immigrants daily all over the country.
asserted
practitioners → mean → country
One psychologist who markets her practice as uniting families — which raises concerns of bias in her evaluations — claims it has completed more than 34,000 immigration evaluations.
uncertain
it → market → evaluations
In May 2026, illegal immigrants filed a class action lawsuit against an immigration attorney in Washington who reportedly served 80,000 immigrants and allegedly sent some to a psychology practice called En Solidaridad for fraudulent psychological evaluations.
uncertain
who → file → evaluations
In other forensic arenas, such as personal injury and criminal cases, expert witnesses are commonly retained by both sides to help the trier of fact determine the credibility of each side’s claims.
uncertain
trier → retain → claims
But the government infrequently uses experts in immigration cases, which means that biased psychological examinations on behalf of immigrants go mostly unchallenged.
asserted
examinations → use → immigrants
A 2025 study showed that although psychologists can assess the veracity of a patient’s symptoms using established credibility tests, only 25% of psychologists conducting immigration evaluations use those tests.
asserted
% → show → tests
In forensic psychology, an evaluation that excludes credibility testing is substandard, and substandard analyses are apparently the norm in immigration cases.
asserted
analyses → exclude → cases
Only a few years ago, people were paying psychologists to write letters certifying their pets as emotional support animals so they could fly with them on planes.
uncertain
they → pay → planes
Initially begun to help people with genuine disabilities, the loophole was abused and eventually reined in by the federal government.
asserted
loophole → begin → government
We face a similar situation with immigration evaluations, so the government should take steps to limit abuse.
asserted
government → face → abuse
It should restrict evaluations to the most extreme immigration cases, mandate court-overseen credibility testing across the board, and increase prosecutions of unethical psychologists who abuse the system.
asserted
who → restrict → system
If such efforts don’t bear fruit, immigration evaluations should be reconsidered altogether, though only as a last resort.
asserted
evaluations → bear → resort
Without immediate reform, biased psychological evaluations will continue to undermine both the rule of law and the integrity of the nation’s immigration system.
asserted
evaluations → continue → system
Larry Brooks is a board-certified neuropsychologist in Florida.
asserted
Brooks → certify → Florida
The Aporia
