A marvel of engineering and a model of sustainable public transportation, the San Francisco Bay Area’s transit system, financially distressed after years of declined ridership, is now staring down a fiscal cliff – and a potential death spiral that would have massive repercussions for everyone in the globally influential metropolis.
asserted
that → decline → metropolis
As soon as early 2027, Bay Area Rapid Transit could be forced to close as many as 15 stations, reduce frequency of service by 63%, increase the cost of rides and parking fees by 30% and end all service at 9pm.
uncertain
Transit → force → 9
If service becomes less frequent and more expensive, there will be fewer commuters, less fare revenue and a downward cascade of financial austerity with ripple effects for all Bay Area residents, not just those who use public transit regularly.
asserted
who → become → transit
In a doomsday scenario, the whole system could be deemed unsafe and shut down.
uncertain
system → deem → scenario
The transit system, known locally as Bart, has served the Bay Area for more than five decades, connecting 50 stations in five counties.
asserted
system → know → counties
Given the region’s sprawling geography, formed around a large body of water, the area’s freeways and bridges are notoriously gridlocked.
asserted
freeways → give → water
With 131 miles (210km) of track linking cities like San Francisco and Oakland with the wider south and east bay regions, Bart allows commuters to bypass congested roads and hefty bridge tolls.
asserted
commuters → link → roads
Its underwater tunnel, known as the transbay tube, sits 135ft (41 meters) beneath the chilly waters of the San Francisco Bay.
asserted
tunnel → know → Bay
It was designed with flexible joints to absorb the seismic activity of the region’s two active faultlines, and emerged from the 1989 earthquake unscathed.
asserted
It → design → earthquake
Bart is a model of self-sufficient funding, and was the first US transit system made fully accessible for people with disabilities.
asserted
Bart → make → disabilities
At its high point in 2016, the agency boasted 435,000 riders each weekday and brought in nearly half a billion dollars annually.
asserted
agency → boast → dollars
But since the pandemic, it has struggled to regain enough riders to sustain its funding model.
asserted
it → struggle → model
Now its future is riding on voters approving a half cent sales tax across four Bay Area counties and a $0.01 sales tax in San Francisco.
asserted
voters → rid → Francisco
The regional transit measure would generate approximately $1bn annually to fund the four largest transit operators for 14 years.
asserted
measure → generate → years
“Losing Bart destroys the Bay Area economy,” said Jeffrey Tumlin, former head of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA), now on a sabbatical.
asserted
Tumlin → lose → sabbatical
“All of the large Bay Area technology companies and the business associations that represent them understand that there’s no Bay Area tech economy without Bart.”
asserted
that → represent → Bart
‘Traffic is going to get a lot worse’
asserted
Traffic → go → ?
On a Wednesday morning, the yellow line from Antioch bustles with commuters relaxing as they glide past the gridlock.
asserted
they → bustle → gridlock
Out the window, the highway is already choked with cars crawling along into Oakland, Berkeley, San Francisco and other hubs for work and study in a region home to more than 7.5 million people
“Sometimes I sit here on Bart and just look out the window and laugh – ha, ha, ha! – at the people in traffic,” said Carissa Spencer, an executive assistant for Airbnb in her 40s who takes Bart almost daily from Antioch to downtown San Francisco.
asserted
who → choke → Francisco
The prospect of losing this rail line and ending up in traffic seems like a cruel joke.
asserted
prospect → lose → joke
“It just is shocking to me that that’s how we operate in the United States of America in 2026, where people have to have a car to be able to survive,” she said.
asserted
she → ’ → car
As slow as traffic is today, it could more than double if voters reject the ballot measure.
uncertain
voters → double → measure
Riding the red and yellow Bart lines during the early morning commute, the Guardian spoke with families and commuters from the outer reaches of the Bay Area who rely on the system to take them to schools, and jobs at banks, universities, hospitals, tech companies and fast-food chains.
asserted
who → rid → banks
Unlike transit systems in other world-class cities that receive significant government funding, Bart has generated 60%-70% of its operating revenue through passenger fares, making it uniquely self-sustaining – and uniquely exposed to the low ridership during the pandemic and the Bay Area’s nation-leading shift to remote and hybrid work.
asserted
it → receive → work
To lure back riders, the agency upgraded safety, cleaning, restrooms, fare gates and payment systems, while shortening trains, retiring legacy cars, re-aligning schedules for off-peak demand and syncing operations regionally.
asserted
agency → lure → operations
Despite multiday delays due to old equipment overheating earlier this month and the rocky rollout of the new Clipper 2.0 card, Bart has a 95% customer on time performance and record high rider satisfaction.
asserted
Bart → overheat → performance
David, 42, a surgeon taking Bart’s red line to work at dawn, supports the ballot measure, but would like to see big companies in the region who benefit from Bart to step up: “I think that they should pay some portion of the subsidy for our transportation to work for them,” he said.
asserted
he → take → them
The economic, climate and equity stakes of both measures failing at the ballot box couldn’t be higher.
asserted
stakes → fail → box
A new report by the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (Spur), which spearheaded the regional transit measure, paints the bleakest picture yet: traffic delays on the Bay Bridge and other chokepoints would more than double during peak hours.
asserted
delays → spearhead → hours
“Traffic is going to get a lot worse and I think this is a best-case scenario,” said Laura Tolkoff, the transportation policy director at Spur and author of the report.
asserted
Tolkoff → go → report
The transit system is largely what keeps the road systems moving, and people who cannot switch to driving, including low-income workers and people with disabilities, will be hit hardest.
Alvina, 70, takes Bart every day from Oakland to her job at McDonald’s in Lafayette.
asserted
Alvina → keep → Lafayette
If Bart goes down, she would use Uber, she said in Spanish, which would significantly cut into her hourly wage.
asserted
which → go → wage
On the yellow line between Oakland and Antioch, the Guardian spoke with a half dozen riders who made decisions about buying homes or working certain jobs because of the area’s relative affordability and proximity to the Bart.
asserted
who → speak → Bart
Now that segment of rail could be gutted.
uncertain
segment → gutte → rail
Regina, 34, who studies risk for JP Morgan Chase, said she and her husband bought a house in Antioch three months ago because her job required her to commute into the office every day and she hates driving: “The biggest reason why I moved out here is knowing that there was a Bart line.”
asserted
I → study → driving
Commuters displaced from transit to cars would potentially face multiple bottlenecks and have to drive an additional 10 miles (16km) each way to reach an open station, according to Spur estimates.
uncertain
Commuters → displace → estimates
They would also incur an estimated $3,280 per year in additional transportation expenses – the sales tax, Spur estimated, will cost 3% of that.
asserted
Spur → incur → that
On a Friday evening in San Francisco’s Sunset district, nearly three miles away from the closest Bart station, a group of young men with signs, clipboards and polling data went door-knocking in search of persuadable voters.
asserted
group → go → voters
Anki, a 33-year-old software engineer, has spent months walking up to strangers at bus stops, farmers’ markets and protests to pitch them on approving the ballot measures.
asserted
Anki → spend → measures
Motivated by fear of how the cuts will affect him personally and the region as a whole, he gathered a record 2,501 signatures to get the measures on this November’s ballot.
asserted
he → motivate → ballot
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
