Claims extracted
25
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
8%
2 of 25 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
68/100
Daily Mail's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
The family of an elderly murder victim are calling for a retrial of the Scots nurse convicted of killing her and three others on a hospital ward.
Suspicion fell on Colin Norris, a 26-year-old nurse from Glasgow, after patient Ethel Hall fell into a hypoglycemic coma while she was recovering from a broken hip in 2002.
asserted
she → see → 2002
He was convicted six years later of killing the 86-year-old in Leeds General Infirmary by injecting her with insulin and using the same method to kill three other patients and attempting to kill two more.
asserted
He → convict → two
The serial killer has lost two appeals but a new BBC Disclosure podcast reveals that members of Ms Hall’s family have growing doubts about his guilt.
asserted
members → lose → guilt
The case has gained greater traction due to the debate over the guilt of neonatal nurse Lucy Letby, convicted of killing seven babies and trying to kill seven more in a Chester hospital 10 years ago.
asserted
case → gain → hospital
In the podcast, family spokeswoman Helen Hall says legal moves have failed to provide the closure they had hoped for.
asserted
they → say → closure
Ethel Hall died after she fell into a hypoglycemic coma while recovering from a broken hip
Nurse Colin Norris was convicted of killing four patients by injecting them with insulin and attempting to kill two more using the same method
Ms Hall, the wife of Ethel’s son Stuart, adds: ‘If he’s guilty, then fine, that’s it.
asserted
that → die → son
But if he’s not guilty and he hasn’t done it, the evidence that they’re trying to keep him inside for is not enough.
asserted
they → ’ → him
She said the family now believe the only thing that will give them peace of mind is a retrial.
asserted
that → say → mind
‘I’m not saying that he should walk free, I’m not saying he should stay behind bars – he should have a fair trial,’ she added.
asserted
she → say → trial
The condition known as hypoglycemia lies at the heart of Norris’s appeal as well as the medical evidence
asserted
condition → know → appeal
which convicted him
asserted
which → convict → him
Hypoglycemia occurs when someone’s blood sugar levels fall dangerously low.
asserted
levels → occur → ?
It can normally be treated by medicine or by taking a high-sugar drink or food item.
asserted
It → treat → drink
Ms Hall died after falling into a hypoglycemic coma, something considered rare then and now.
asserted
Hall → die → coma
Norris quickly became a suspect after a colleague said he had predicted that the pensioner would not make it through the night.
asserted
pensioner → become → night
A subsequent police operation went through all the deaths on wards where Norris had worked, looking for potential murders that may have gone unnoticed.
uncertain
that → go → murders
It identified three other cases of unexplained hypoglycemic deaths and one where the patient recovered.
asserted
patient → identify → deaths
After his conviction, Norris, now known as Colin Campbell, lost his first appeal within a few years.
asserted
Norris → know → years
The BBC says that two years later new scientific evidence came to light which claimed hypoglycemia in the frail and elderly is not as vanishingly rare as was once thought, suggesting the jury had been misinformed.
asserted
jury → say → frail
This new evidence was submitted for a second appeal, which was not heard until last year.
asserted
which → submit → year
Lawyers for the Crown successfully argued that the patients’ deaths could only be explained by deliberate insulin poisoning.
uncertain
deaths → argue → poisoning
The new BBC podcast says: ‘It is possible that a strong opioid prescribed to Ethel for her post-op pain put her in a coma, and insulin meant for somebody else was accidentally given to her before the blood sample, which proved poisoning, was taken.’
asserted
which → say → poisoning
Campbell’s mother, June Campbell, said she will not stop seeking what she believes is justice for her son.
asserted
she → say → son
‘If you’re a mum, you know,’ she said.
asserted
she → ’re → ?
‘You’ll fight for your kids till the very end.’
asserted
You → fight → end
The Aporia
