A Palestinian careers adviser who was allegedly directed to stop wearing a keffiyeh at a Sydney government school because it was a symbol that “may cause discord” has lodged a racial discrimination case in the federal court against the state of New South Wales.
uncertain
that → direct → Wales
Wasim El-Haj, a former careers adviser at Sydney Girls High School – an inner-city selective government school – alleges the then acting principal told him in 2024 that the keffiyeh was seen as a symbol of conflict.
asserted
keffiyeh → allege → conflict
He alleges the state’s conduct is unlawful for breaching the Racial Discrimination Act.
asserted
conduct → allege → Act
El-Haj began wearing the keffiyeh – a traditional scarf linked to the struggle for a Palestinian state for decades – at school in January 2024, three months after Hamas’ 7 October attacks and Israel’s subsequent war on Gaza.
asserted
Haj → begin → Gaza
His statement of claim, filed in the federal court last month, alleges Geoffrey Denyer, the then acting school principal, met with him on 15 May 2024 and said words to the effect of “I have been directed to direct you to remove this item of clothing”, indicating to El-Haj’s keiffeyh.
uncertain
I → file → keiffeyh
Denyer also said words to the effect of the direction had come “from above, possibly from the minister” and that action would be taken if El-Haj did not comply, the statement of claim alleges.
uncertain
statement → say → claim
In an email sent the same day, after El-Haj requested the issue be laid out in writing, Denyer outlined the terms of the direction he had received.
asserted
he → send → direction
“Consistent with the Department’s Controversial Issues and Code of Conduct policies, the staff member in question should be given clear advice, from you, that this item of clothing should not be worn at school, nor in the performance of any duties in connection with his employment.
asserted
item → give → employment
That advice should be complied with immediately,” the email said.
asserted
email → comply → ?
However, our schools need to remain free of symbols which stir these emotions, and which may cause discord.”
uncertain
which → need → discord
El-Haj alleges that in a further conversation with Denyer he said words to the effect of “any symbol of Palestine is seen as a symbol of conflict”.
asserted
symbol → allege → conflict
In August 2024, El-Haj met with Maria Serafim, a NSW Department of Education official, who detailed six anonymous concerns, including that he had worn a symbol of “partisan conflict” by wearing the keffiyeh, the statement of claim alleges.
uncertain
statement → meet → claim
An internal complaint El-Haj made about the direction did not lead to its withdrawal.
asserted
Haj → make → withdrawal
The careers advisor appealed the decision about the complaint to the secretary of the NSW Department of Education, Murat Dizdar.
asserted
advisor → appeal → Education
Responding to this, Dizdar upheld the school’s decision.
asserted
Dizdar → respond → decision
In a letter to El-Haj in February 2025, he recognised the keffiyeh “is a garment of cultural significance for the Palestinian community” but said the department did not want to compromise the “safety, wellbeing and security in all our school communities”.
asserted
department → recognise → communities
“Unfortunately, our schools are not immune to external events, such as the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, with the tragic loss of innocent lives,” he said.
asserted
he → say → lives
“Regrettably, within our school communities, some individuals and groups may seek to politicise global conflicts or others may form that perception, and as such we always remain politically neutral in public schools when such events can impact on operations.
uncertain
events → seek → operations
“It is with this context that the senior officers and the school advised you to not wear the keffiyeh to school.”
asserted
officers → advise → school
El-Haj took leave from his employment from May 2024 until the end of the year and resigned from Sydney Girls High School in March 2025.
uncertain
Haj → take → March
El-Haj alleges the state of NSW has engaged in unlawful conduct under section 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act.
asserted
state → allege → Act
The state of NSW is yet to file its defence in the federal court.
asserted
state → file → court
The matter is due to be next heard for a case management hearing on 3 November, federal court records show.
asserted
records → hear → November
A spokesperson for the NSW Department of Education said it was “committed to maintaining neutral and apolitical school environments, in line with its policies.”
asserted
it → say → policies
Guardian Australia understands the department is not able to make further comments while the matter is before court.
asserted
matter → understand → court
The Aporia
