Among the many heads of government Anthony Albanese met during his successful visit to “Leaders Week” at the United Nations was Andy Burnham, the new prime minister of Great Britain.
asserted
Burnham → meet → Britain
That was the year Britons voted to leave the European Union, thereby destroying the government of David Cameron – the last tenant of 10 Downing Street to serve a respectably long term in office (six years and two election wins).
asserted
Britons → vote → office
That instability is all the more remarkable when one considers that of Britain’s three elections in the past decade, two were won by landslides – the Tories in 2019 and Labour in 2024.
asserted
two → consider → 2024
Yet both victorious leaders, Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer, were soon shown the door by their parties, despite what had initially seemed likely to be long incumbencies.
asserted
what → show → parties
Although there has been a modest honeymoon for Burnham, just 10 weeks into the job the new prime minister is struggling to get to grips with the same issues that thwarted his ill-starred predecessor.
asserted
that → struggle → predecessor
According to the biggest opinion poll since Burnham’s accession, published last Thursday, Labour would now lose 171 of the 412 seats it won at the election.
uncertain
it → accord → election
Neither Labour nor the aggregate of the two main right-wing parties (Conservative and Reform) would come anywhere close to the 326 seats needed for a majority in the House of Commons.
asserted
Labour → come → Commons
Almost three years remain in the current parliamentary term; things are only likely to get worse for Labour, while there are no signs of consolidation on the right.
asserted
things → remain → right
Unlike Australia, however, the Balkanisation of British politics arises from factors deeper than mere frustration with the party system.
asserted
Balkanisation → arise → system
The much overused word “existential” seems, for once, to be more than journalistic hype.
asserted
word → overuse → hype
The acute stresses to the body politic of Britain have been manifested within the past fortnight in two different but related ways.
asserted
stresses → manifest → ways
On September 14, the leaders of the provincial governments of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland met to sign “the Cardiff Declaration”, demanding self-determination for their respective territories.
asserted
leaders → meet → territories
(The constitutional status of the three is rather confusing for those of us who are accustomed to regarding sub-national governments as states in a federation.
asserted
who → accustom → federation
All have their own regional assemblies and governments, though subject ultimately to Westminster.
asserted
All → have → Westminster
All are united with England under the Crown.
asserted
All → unite → Crown
)
For the first time, following elections in May, the governments of all three countries – sometimes patronisingly called “the Celtic fringe” – are led by parties whose principal platform is separation from the United Kingdom.
uncertain
platform → follow → Kingdom
The Cardiff Declaration is a mutual commitment to hold referendums to do so.
asserted
Declaration → hold → referendums
An independence referendum was held in 2014 in Scotland, which failed relatively narrowly (55-45); in the years since, the Scottish National Party has relentlessly campaigned for another.
asserted
Party → hold → another
There, separation from the UK means union with the Republic of Ireland, which is favoured by all of the major parties south of the border, and which the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 (which ended “the Troubles”) conditionally allows for as a possible long-term outcome.
asserted
which → mean → outcome
It may well be that after the next UK general election, the only way Labour could form a government would be with the support of the Scottish National Party, which would undoubtedly demand a second referendum as its price.
uncertain
which → form → price
(The SNP would never support a Tory or a Reform government.)
asserted
SNP → support → Tory
There is an interesting historical parallel: after the 1885 election, the Liberal titan William Gladstone could only form a government relying on Irish nationalists, who demanded Home Rule as the condition of their support.
uncertain
who → be → support
Nationalists in Scotland and Wales see their future as independent nations within the European Union.
asserted
Nationalists → see → Union
They are not too small: 10 of the 27 EU member states have populations smaller than Scotland and seven are smaller than Wales.
asserted
seven → have → Wales
Ten years on, the UK continues to be vexed by Brexit.
asserted
UK → continue → Brexit
While Starmer took Labour to the last election refusing to entertain the issue of Britain rejoining the EU, last week Burnham deliberately reopened the question by refusing to rule out Labour taking a policy for a second referendum to the next election.
asserted
Labour → take → election
The following day, former Labour PM Tony Blair jumped on board, arguing that Labour should commit to Britain resuming membership within a decade.
asserted
Britain → follow → decade
Meanwhile, the European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen welcomed the possibility, in the interim, of Britain becoming an “associate member”, as Canada has just done.
asserted
Canada → welcome → interim
Come the next election, Burnham may well calculate that the promise of a second referendum on EU membership might save Labour seats in Scotland and Wales – and, potentially, save not just his government, but the Union itself.
uncertain
promise → calculate → Scotland
Until then, he will continue to hide behind Brexit as a convenient excuse for his government’s failure to deal with Britain’s crippling economic woes.
asserted
he → continue → woes
The next chapter of British politics will be significantly defined by the interplay between the centrifugal force of Celtic nationalism and the gravitational attraction of European internationalism.
asserted
chapter → define → internationalism
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own.
asserted
that → get → own
The Aporia
