In these cash-strapped times, I’m often asked how governments can save money.
asserted
governments → strap → money
One area Australian leaders have so far largely failed to consider is our prisons – the money we spend to build and staff them for the vast numbers of people who enter those gates and usually end up making at least one return visit.
asserted
who → fail → visit
Australian taxpayers spend more than $7.3 billion a year on adult incarceration and over $1.1 billion a year on locking up children.
asserted
taxpayers → spend → children
The cost of keeping one adult in prison for a year is almost $120,000.
asserted
cost → keep → year
Spending on youth detention has more than doubled over the past decade and now costs an average of $1.3 million per year for each child.
asserted
Spending → double → child
Yet despite these massive outlays (imagine how we could support a child in the community and change their trajectory with $1.3 million), the evidence overwhelmingly shows that jailing is failing.
uncertain
jailing → imagine → million
Imprisonment makes further offending more likely (not less) and entrenches disadvantage that inevitably means greater spending down the line on unemployment support, health and housing.
asserted
that → make → support
From a fiscal perspective, it’s almost nonsensical.
asserted
it → ’ → perspective
Policymakers around the world and from all sides of politics have recognised this.
asserted
Policymakers → recognise → this
In the US, 21 states partially or fully closed at least one correctional facility between 2000 and 2022, reducing capacity by 81,444 prison beds.
asserted
states → close → beds
Here in Australia, the conservative Institute of Public Affairs has argued that the 37 per cent of people incarcerated for non-violent offences should not be dealt with by a prison sentence.
asserted
cent → argue → sentence
When governments chase votes by being seen to be “tough on crime”, the economic arguments against overreliance on prisons often fall by the wayside.
asserted
arguments → chase → wayside
This may change with the launch of a new coalition (which I have joined), Economists for Justice Reform, which believes that the economic case against prisons as our default policy response to crime and disadvantage should be given much more weight.
uncertain
case → change → weight
The number of people in Australian prisons has soared over the past three decades from 18,193 in 1996 to 49,295 in the most recent data, growing more than three times faster than the population itself.
asserted
number → soar → population
The surge is largely driven by much higher numbers of people who are on remand waiting for court, including many who have been charged with minor offences.
asserted
who → drive → offences
This surge does not reflect higher crime rates, but rather the policy and legislative settings which are driving more people into prison and making it much harder for people to access bail.
asserted
people → reflect → bail
As a result, our prisons have become even more overcrowded and cost more to staff and maintain.
asserted
prisons → become → more
Access to education and services within prisons to help prevent reincarceration remains limited, as does post-release support.
asserted
support → help → reincarceration
We are setting people up to fail again, with community safety also at risk.
asserted
safety → set → risk
Recidivism rates in Australia are far higher than most comparable countries, with 45 per cent of adults released from prison returning there within two years and 84 per cent of children released from detention returning to sentenced supervision within 12 months.
asserted
cent → release → months
Some work has been done to attempt to quantify the costs of this approach.
asserted
work → do → approach
A 2019 study of children at risk of criminalisation in NSW found that 7 per cent of individuals under the age of 25 will account for half the estimated cost of the state’s social services by the time they are 40 years old.
asserted
they → find → time
Additionally, 1 per cent of this group will be responsible for 32 per cent of NSW’s total justice service costs, highlighting that early intervention targeting a small but critical group can reduce future costs significantly.
asserted
intervention → highlight → costs
While there are long-term savings to be had, a change of tack would require governments to make large upfront investments into prevention and early support and intervention initiatives.
asserted
change → be → initiatives
The long-term savings can then be (re)invested into new or continued prevention and early intervention initiatives.
asserted
savings → re)investe → initiatives
The Productivity Commission did some work on this in 2021, releasing a report on “Australia’s prison dilemma” and highlighting alternative approaches to prison that could achieve better outcomes at lower costs, such as diversion programs, restorative justice and home detention.
But the missing part of this equation to date has been the political courage to say that locking people up isn’t always the smartest approach.
uncertain
locking → release → people
Getting politicians to do what makes economic or moral sense is often challenging amid rising populism and media cycles driven by clickbait algorithms.
asserted
what → get → algorithms
Continuing to throw billions at a system that drives further offending is poor policy and fiscal negligence.
asserted
that → continue → offending
At a time when governments are stretched and debt is growing, a reassessment of our costly overreliance on prisons and the relative lack of investment in evidence-based alternatives to incarceration would prove valuable.
asserted
reassessment → stretch → incarceration
We will see far greater returns from investing upfront where the dividend is highest: keeping people out of prison in the first place.
Saul Eslake is an independent economist and an inaugural member of Economists for Justice Reform, established by the Justice Reform Initiative.
asserted
Eslake → see → Initiative
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own.
asserted
that → get → own
The Aporia
