A woman who was knocked back for a job as a garbage collector has failed in a gender discrimination claim, despite several men getting more notice of the interview than she did for the role in the male-dominated industry.
uncertain
she → knock → industry
The female casual garbage truck driver was applying for a permanent role with Sydney’s Inner West Council, but was only told at 4am that she would be interviewed at 10.30am the same day, with a shift in between, preventing her from preparing or changing out of her work clothes.
asserted
she → apply → clothes
Recycling and waste collection is classed as an “almost completely male-dominated” field, with 95 per cent male workers, according to the federal government’s Jobs and Skills Australia agency.
uncertain
Recycling → class → agency
The case, heard in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, involved one of the few women working as a garbage truck driver at Sydney’s Inner West Council, and highlighted how hard it can be to show an employer has breached anti-discrimination laws.
asserted
employer → hear → laws
The woman, who this masthead has chosen not to name, began working with the Inner West Council in 2023 as a casual garbage truck driver via an external company, and applied for a full-time job in March the next year.
asserted
masthead → choose → March
She was told she lacked enough experience, which she then obtained.
asserted
she → tell → which
When permanent loader and driver positions opened up later that year, she applied and was interviewed for them.
asserted
she → open → them
However, she said that in July 2024, she became aware that a number of her male colleagues had been notified that they would be interviewed for the position.
asserted
they → say → position
Approximately two weeks later, she had not yet been notified.
asserted
she → notify → ?
She said she was only told by one of her superiors at about 4am on August 7, while starting one of her ordinary shifts, that she was required to return to the depot by 10.30am that morning because she had an interview.
asserted
she → say → interview
She said she was therefore required to do her ordinary work before attending the interview, and had no meaningful opportunity to prepare or change into what she suggested was more appropriate clothing.
uncertain
she → say → opportunity
She also complained the male candidates had been notified by text, rather than verbally.
asserted
candidates → complain → text
There was no dispute that the male candidates had been informed of their interviews at least a few days earlier than her.
asserted
candidates → be → her
While the interview panel convenor accepted that having more notice of an interview would give an advantage to a candidate, the tribunal ruled there was no evidence that suggested her performance at the interview was compromised by short notice or what she wore.
uncertain
she → accept → what
She also said she was verbally informed she had a medical assessment for the job shortly after returning from leave, and that she was briefly shown the appointment details on a mobile phone which she hurriedly tried to photograph before the phone was put away.
asserted
phone → say → which
She argued the successful male candidates had been notified by email, and not merely by being shown details on a phone.
asserted
candidates → argue → phone
The female driver argued this all formed a “broader pattern of differential treatment” during the recruitment process on the ground of her sex.
asserted
this → argue → sex
The council said while the female driver performed well in the interviews, she was “not among the most meritorious candidates”, with her supervisor noting she had been in “quite a few accidents”, more than most other employees.
asserted
she → say → employees
The supervisor also said the woman was included in the interview process for the driver position despite not initially progressing to the interview stage, after he realised interviews for the loader position would probably occur while she was on leave.
asserted
she → say → leave
She had not initially been selected because she did not have as much driving experience as the other candidates, but scored third- or fourth-highest in the interview.
asserted
she → select → interview
The full-time positions were offered to male candidates who the female garbage truck driver claimed had equal or lesser relevant experience than she did.
asserted
she → offer → experience
The tribunal ruled there was no evidence showing that any of the council’s conduct was on the basis of her sex.
asserted
any → rule → sex
“There is, as it is sometimes called, no smoking gun to which [she] can point,” the tribunal said.
asserted
tribunal → be → which
Peter Roney, KC, who oversaw the case, said the female driver’s supervisor had no issue working alongside women in the workplace.
asserted
supervisor → oversee → workplace
“That is, in our view, significant because absent that, there is little to explain why he may have engaged in the conduct [she] accused him of,” Roney said.
uncertain
Roney → be → him
The tribunal, which described the woman as “an ambitious and articulate woman who had great confidence in herself”, said she was not materially disadvantaged by the recruitment process, and that the different treatment she faced was not on the ground of sex.
asserted
she → describe → sex
“Clumsy, disorganised or less than optimal management practices they may have been, but none was shown to have occurred consciously or unconsciously on the ground that she was female.”
uncertain
she → show → ground
Inner West Council General Manager Peter Gainsford said the council respected the tribunal’s finding which dismissed the complaint and found there was no basis to conclude that the recruitment decisions were made based on gender.
asserted
decisions → say → gender
“The tribunal also identified improvements needed in the council recruitment processes,” he said.
asserted
he → identify → processes
“As a result, we are reviewing these processes.
asserted
we → review → processes
Council is committed to the highest standards of employment conditions.
asserted
Council → commit → conditions
The applicant continues to be employed by council.
asserted
applicant → continue → council
”
Get workplace news, advice and perspectives to help make your job work for you.
asserted
job → get → you
Sign up for our weekly Thank God it’s Monday newsletter.
asserted
it → sign → newsletter
The Aporia
