THE war that the US and Israel imposed on Iran this year has failed to achieve any of the objectives that the two countries had intended.
asserted
countries → impose → that
The declared purpose was to prevent Iran from building a nuclear weapon.
asserted
purpose → declare → weapon
A fact-check indicates that Iran had kept its civil nuclear programme under IAEA safeguards.
asserted
Iran → indicate → safeguards
It had also willingly agreed to a nuclear deal in 2015.
asserted
It → agree → 2015
It was President Donald Trump who pulled the US out of the deal in 2018 and re-engaged with Iran in his second term under a “maximum pressure” campaign.
asserted
who → pull → campaign
While talks were still underway, Israel attacked Iran in June 2025, resulting in a 12-day war.
asserted
Israel → attack → war
Having failed to subdue Iran, the US and Israel launched joint strikes on Iran on Feb 28, this year, killing much of the Iranian leadership and relentlessly bombing Iranian facilities and installations for 40 days.
asserted
US → fail → days
All this while Iran remained in the NPT and maintained that it was not building a nuclear bomb, thanks in large measure to a directive from Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei to not pursue a nuclear weapon programme.
asserted
it → remain → programme
This means that Tehran’s nuclear programme was only a pretext to attack Iran this year.
asserted
programme → mean → Iran
Arguably, the real objective of the February strike was to change the ruling regime in Iran.
asserted
objective → change → Iran
It would be recalled that by 2020, many Arab countries had joined the Abraham Accords and normalised relations with Israel.
asserted
countries → recall → Israel
Lest the Palestinian cause be forgotten, Hamas mounted a resistance attack on Israel in October 2023, which was used by the Benjamin Netanyahu government to bomb Gaza to rubble, committing horrific genocide.
asserted
which → forget → genocide
Having weakened Hamas and Hezbollah, Israel began to entertain the idea of establishing a ‘Greater Israel’ and found the Iranian regime to be a major roadblock to its ambitions.
asserted
regime → weaken → ambitions
Since his efforts to dislodge Iran’s government had failed in June 2025, Netanyahu persuaded Trump to undertake a joint attack against Iran on Feb 28.
asserted
Netanyahu → dislodge → Feb
Two factors seem to have encouraged Trump to accept this gamble.
asserted
factors → seem → gamble
He had successfully dislodged the government of president Nicolás Maduro in Venezuela in January, and Iran had witnessed massive protests against the government on account of inflation.
asserted
Iran → dislodge → inflation
The US and Israeli leadership wrongly assessed that they would be able to wipe out the Iranian regime within days.
asserted
they → assess → days
They also failed to destroy Iran’s long-range missile programme, though they did succeed in weakening Iran’s Axis of Resistance.
asserted
they → fail → Resistance
While Iran has survived the American and Israeli onslaught, the war has been nothing less than a disaster for the US itself.
asserted
war → survive → US
The Gulf states are increasingly becoming disillusioned with America’s capacity or will to provide them with security.
asserted
states → become → security
The US bases in the region have been practically destroyed.
asserted
bases → destroy → region
The myth of invincibility of the US military machine has been shattered.
asserted
myth → shatter → machine
The Strait of Hormuz, which was open before the war, is now being contested.
asserted
which → contest → war
The war is expanding horizontally, with Iraqi militias targeting Saudi Arabia’s east-west pipeline and Yemen’s Houthis attacking Saudi cities and oil installations.
asserted
Houthis → expand → cities
Bab al-Mandeb also runs the risk of closure as the Houthis have captured all key positions and islands along the Red Sea.
asserted
Houthis → run → Sea
With oil prices soaring, most countries have run into serious economic difficulties.
asserted
countries → soar → difficulties
The Gulf countries, whose economies largely depended on energy flows, tourism, and services, have been shaken to the core.
asserted
economies → depend → core
Meanwhile, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkiye have entered into a regional arrangement for joint defence, predicated on the principle of collective security.
asserted
Pakistan → enter → security
With Israeli parliamentary elections due on Oct 27 and mid-term Congressional elections in America on Nov 3, the US is contemplating how best to handle the war with Iran.
asserted
US → contemplate → Iran
One way is to revert to the MoU that was mediated by Pakistan and signed in June by the presidents of the US and Iran.
asserted
that → revert → US
However, the MoU had received severe criticism within the US and was largely interpreted as capitulation by the US.
asserted
MoU → receive → US
Ever since, Trump has pulled back from any peace attempts.
asserted
Trump → pull → attempts
The other option being considered is to resort to another large-scale military attack.
asserted
option → consider → attack
Given what had happened in the earlier military campaigns, it can be safely assumed that another confrontation is unlikely to yield a different result.
asserted
confrontation → give → result
Pakistan, Qatar, and others must continue their efforts for peace.
asserted
Pakistan → continue → peace
Secondly, it is time for China to step in as a mediator as it depends heavily on oil flows from the Gulf and had successfully brokered normalisation between Iran and Saudi Arabia in 2023.
asserted
it → step → 2023
China should also impress upon the US leadership the futility of finding a military solution to the crisis in the Gulf region.
asserted
China → impress → region
The Aporia
