Proponents of a massive, five-county sales tax hike in the Bay Area want you to think their money grab is needed to save transit and prevent congestion.
asserted
grab → want → congestion
But the activists working hardest to pass the levy have a bigger agenda.
asserted
activists → work → agenda
They want you to drive much less, or not at all.
asserted
you → want → ?
Start your day with all you need to know
Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.
asserted
Report → start → news
They want fewer driving lanes, less parking, more tolls, traffic calming, bike lanes and streets redesigned to discourage driving.
asserted
They → want → driving
They are not hiding it.
asserted
They → hide → it
The car-haters at Streetsblog, for instance, called one East Bay Area arterial a “traffic sewer” with “too many lanes of fast-moving traffic” and cheered protected bike lanes that give cars less space.
Indeed, much of the sales-tax-hike money will flow to county transportation agencies that devote much of their energies to complicating driving.
asserted
that → call → driving
Do taxpayers really want to shell out more money to make traffic worse?
asserted
traffic → want → money
Although the new sales tax funds are mostly said to support transit, we know that money is fungible — and the agencies collecting the cash are committed to projects that slow cars, reallocate roadway space away from motorists and elevate bicycling over driving, even when impractical.
The anti-car crowd can only hope that frustrated drivers will give up and take the bus or train.
asserted
drivers → say → bus
Los Angeles’ Measure HLA generally requires the city to install Mobility Plan bike, bus and pedestrian projects whenever it resurfaces a qualifying stretch of street.
asserted
it → require → street
That means hundreds of miles of lane reallocation can be baked into standard repaving work — leaving even less space to drive in congested LA.
asserted
hundreds → mean → LA
San Diego’s City Council in 2025 adopted a Mobility Master Plan ranking hundreds of projects whose shared goal, as one report put it, is encouraging people to stop commuting by car.
asserted
report → adopt → car
The city is now pairing lower speed limits with traffic calming and street redesign.
asserted
city → pair → calming
Southern California is running the same playbook: Take space from cars, slow what remains and call it safety or climate rescue.
asserted
what → run → it
This war on cars started in the Bay Area, and has been running for decades.
asserted
war → start → decades
Government planners increasingly treat changing how people travel as part of the job.
asserted
people → treat → job
At the same time, the rationale for the entire anti-car crusade has crashed and burned.
asserted
rationale → crash → crusade
Modern gasoline cars emit 98% to 99% less of most conventional tailpipe pollutants than vehicles of the late 1960s.
asserted
cars → emit → 1960s
Electric vehicles eliminate tailpipe pollution entirely.
asserted
vehicles → eliminate → pollution
Also: More shopping and meals come to the door, more meetings happen on Zoom, and hybrid work has replaced five-day-a-week commuting for a large share of office workers.
The automobile is not swallowing California, as hysterics once anticipated.
asserted
hysterics → come → California
If anything, its footprint is shrinking.
asserted
footprint → shrink → ?
Yet the war on cars rolls on.
asserted
war → roll → cars
The five-county sales tax hike on the November ballot would raise roughly $1 billion a year for 14 years.
asserted
hike → raise → years
Adding 0.50% to 1% onto the things people need to buy will make the Bay Area even less affordable.
asserted
Area → add → things
All of this serves a movement whose traditional case against cars has faded.
asserted
case → serve → cars
Yes, mass transit is struggling, in large part thanks to its own decisions, including an unwillingness to control labor costs and failures to ensure safety and sanitation on systems such as BART.
asserted
transit → struggle → BART
But such problems can be addressed without a vast new tax steered to bureaucrats who want you to stop driving.
asserted
you → address → bureaucrats
The Aporia
