A university building by the modernist architect who designed the National Gallery of Victoria is a step closer to the wrecking ball, after Heritage Victoria decided not to back it for protection.
asserted
Victoria → design → protection
The University of Melbourne plans to replace the twin brick John Medley Building, which faces Grattan Street and forms a gateway to the Parkville campus, with a new central education building envisioned as a “welcoming front door” and “central hub for teaching, learning and campus life”.
asserted
which → plan → teaching
Academics have been pushing for the building to be on the Victorian Heritage Register, arguing it is a significant work by architect Sir Roy Grounds, who was a student at the university before building city landmarks such as the NGV and Arts Centre Melbourne.
asserted
who → push → NGV
However, Heritage Victoria executive director Steven Avery has recommended the site not be included on the register, and said the 1971 structure was “not a pivotal example of the class” of modernist postwar university buildings.
asserted
structure → recommend → buildings
Avery said buildings such as the university’s Beaurepaire Centre and Wilsons Hall, opened in the 1950s, were examples that defined the state’s modernist campus architecture and were on the register.
asserted
that → say → register
“While the John Medley Building is a refined and attractive example of a postwar university building, it could not be considered architecturally notable when compared to examples already included in the [register],” Avery wrote.
uncertain
Avery → consider → register
The Heritage Council of Victoria, which has the final say, is yet to decide whether to grant the building protection and is currently assessing submissions, with the likelihood of a hearing that will delay an outcome until next year.
asserted
that → have → year
Tony Lee, an expert on Australian modernist architects such as Robin Boyd, said Grounds knew the campus, where he had studied, lectured and served on the building committee, and the university handpicked him to design the building.
asserted
university → say → building
“He’s been very deliberately tying the building in with the university context, not just creating a building that is philosophically driven,” Lee said.
asserted
Lee → tie → building
Still, Lee said a key issue was a lack of documentation of Grounds’ work outside his designs in Melbourne’s arts precinct.
asserted
issue → say → precinct
“No one has put it in the context of his whole career.
asserted
one → put → career
And I think it’s a very special building because, being a later building, it really shows the development of a mature architect.”
asserted
it → think → architect
The John Medley Building, Lee said, incorporates medieval and Renaissance influences such as a walkway bridge that serves as a “gateway to the university” and thin windows that reference arrow slits.
asserted
that → say → slits
The slits lean into an Italian movement known as neo-liberty that borrowed from the past and foreshadowed postmodernism.
asserted
that → lean → postmodernism
“There are a lot of pure examples of all sorts of styles, but it’s these transition buildings that help tell the story to connect these periods,” he said.
asserted
he → be → periods
“It’s probably the best building in Victoria and maybe even more widely in Australia of neo-liberty.”
asserted
It → ’ → liberty
The National Trust is opposed to the demolition of the building on environmental grounds.
asserted
Trust → oppose → grounds
Samantha Westbrooke, the organisation’s executive manager of advocacy and conservation, said the university should be doing more to consider the impact of tearing the building down.
asserted
university → say → building
“We need people to be calculating the embodied energy that we lose when we demolish these types of buildings, and it should be factored into the demolition and rebuilding,” she said.
asserted
she → need → demolition
“It’s more expensive from an environmental perspective, regardless of what you get at the other end.
asserted
you → ’ → end
The University of Melbourne spent $4.5 million refurbishing the building a decade ago.
asserted
University → spend → building
However, the plans to demolish the building were unveiled as part of a masterplan in 2023 that aims to “unite the campus with the city”.
asserted
that → demolish → city
The university’s chief operating officer, Katerina Kapobassis, said campuses needed plans for the long term “to meet the changing needs of research, teaching and students” while also “retaining their significance, layered history and connection to community”.
asserted
campuses → say → community
More than 58 per cent of the university’s infrastructure comes under various heritage protection, and Melbourne University said it prioritised the conservation, adaptation and refurbishment of existing buildings.
asserted
it → come → buildings
“However, where new development is necessary to meet functional and performance requirements, sustainability is embedded through integrated design, low-carbon outcomes, and a whole-of-lifecycle approach to materials, resources and environmental performance,” a university spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → meet → materials
“Redevelopment of the John Medley Building site will deliver a purpose-built teaching building that will become a focal point for student learning and community engagement at Parkville.”
asserted
that → deliver → Parkville
A Heritage Council Victoria spokesperson said submissions were being considered on the building’s heritage status, and parties would be notified of any hearing scheduled.
asserted
parties → say → hearing
The Aporia
