Sugar millers and Pakistan’s government are once again locked in a dispute — this time over a claimed surplus of over one million tonnes of sugar in the country.
asserted
millers → lock → country
Millers are pushing for its export, arguing that this would boost their liquidity, clear warehouses, settle outstanding dues to farmers, and enable them to procure the next sugarcane crop, due in November.
asserted
this → push → November
The government, however, remains wary.
asserted
government → remain → ?
Last year, exporting 750,000 tonnes triggered a sharp price hike.
asserted
exporting → export → hike
A few months later, it had to import 300,000 tonnes to stabilise the domestic market.
asserted
it → have → market
Understandably, policymakers are reluctant to repeat this costly cycle of exports followed by panic imports.
asserted
policymakers → repeat → imports
Surprisingly, the Pakistan Kissan Ittehad has also entered the fray, demanding sugar exports.
asserted
Ittehad → enter → exports
With a bumper crop expected, it warns that millers could use liquidity and warehousing constraints to delay crushing and depress sugarcane prices.
uncertain
millers → expect → prices
Already, the sugarcane minimum support price regime is no longer in effect under the conditions agreed with the International Monetary Fund.
asserted
regime → agree → Fund
In reality, without a coherent policy or long-term strategy for the sugar sector, the government repeatedly ends up making hurried import or export decisions.
asserted
government → end → decisions
Over time, this pattern has reinforced a widely held perception: among the sector’s three main stakeholders — millers, farmers, and consumers — millers have often emerged as the principal beneficiaries of government decisions.
asserted
millers → reinforce → decisions
The elite capture and institutional inertia have made the sector notoriously difficult to regulate
The core question is whether the government will keep managing the sugar sector on an ad hoc basis, resorting to temporary fixes only after public outcry, or finally address the concerns that various quarters have been raising for years — concerns that fall into three broad categories.
First, the area under water-intensive sugarcane continues to expand.
asserted
area → make → sugarcane
Between FY16 and FY26, sugarcane production rose 37 per cent, outpacing population growth.
asserted
production → rise → growth
In contrast, per capita sugar consumption fell by 4pc, from 1.28kg to 1.23kg (per month) between FY19 and FY25.
asserted
consumption → fall → FY19
These trends collectively indicate a potential surplus in the coming years — a red flag for the government, particularly if the cost of sugar production exceeds global sugar prices.
asserted
cost → indicate → prices
Meanwhile, dwindling water resources raise a more fundamental question: how sustainable is the continued expansion of sugarcane acreage?
asserted
expansion → dwindle → acreage
From the farmers’ perspective, this shift toward sugarcane — particularly at cotton’s expense — reflects a rational economic decision based on better returns, not a planning failure on their part.
asserted
shift → reflect → part
Second, the sugar sector has faced persistent allegations of cartelisation for decades, with most mills owned by a handful of politically influential families.
asserted
mills → face → families
This political clout reportedly allows millers — working in tandem with brokers, stockists and other intermediaries — to push up market prices.
uncertain
millers → allow → prices
Unsurprisingly, the government’s price-control system for this essential commodity has proven futile, while the Competition Commission of Pakistan has remained largely ineffective.
asserted
Commission → prove → Pakistan
Compounding the problem, Punjab — which accounts for around 70pc of the country’s sugarcane production — has maintained a ban on the establishment of new sugar mills since December 2006.
asserted
which → compound → December
The ban has reduced competition, strengthened the market power of the 79 (operational) mills and potentially facilitated price-fixing.
asserted
ban → reduce → fixing
The elite capture and institutional inertia have made the sugar sector notoriously difficult to regulate.
asserted
sector → make → ?
Third, the government has repeatedly provided subsidies to the sugar sector to export surplus sugar, citing the price differential between local and international markets.
asserted
government → provide → markets
Yet the deeper question remains: does the government have a long-term policy to align the sugar sector with international markets without providing subsidies to millers, while ensuring a fair return to farmers?
asserted
government → remain → farmers
To address these concerns and curb market volatility, the government must abandon its reliance on ad hoc interventions and reactive regulatory steps.
asserted
government → address → interventions
What the sector needs is a long-term policy that protects the interests of both growers and consumers, built around the following priorities.
asserted
that → need → priorities
Water is a pressing concern behind sugarcane’s expansion.
asserted
Water → press → expansion
Many advocate restricting sugarcane cultivation through crop zoning or acreage caps.
asserted
Many → advocate → zoning
However, without a dedicated crop diversification fund to support farmers, policy must focus on improving water-use efficiency rather than further restricting their crop choices.
asserted
policy → support → choices
The sugar industry should channel its corporate social responsibility funds towards promoting drip irrigation, trench planting, wider row spacing, and other water-saving practices, while also supporting groundwater recharge through rainwater harvesting.
asserted
industry → channel → harvesting
Before the Supreme Court in 2016, the Punjab government defended its ban on new sugar mills, arguing that new capacity would drive further expansion of water-intensive sugarcane, particularly in cotton-growing areas.
asserted
capacity → defend → areas
Sugar beet offers a compelling alternative — maturing in just six months and requiring far less water than sugarcane’s 12-15-month cycle.
asserted
beet → offer → cycle
Worldwide, beet accounts for 20–22pc of total sugar production, and a few Pakistani mills also process it.
asserted
mills → account → it
Pakistan produced 92,786 tonnes of beet sugar in FY25.
asserted
Pakistan → produce → FY25
Moving forward, the government should permit the setting up of new mills that predominantly process beet.
asserted
that → move → beet
This would encourage a more sustainable and water-efficient sugar industry.
asserted
This → encourage → sustainable
With rising surpluses of sugarcane, maize, and coarse rice, Pakistan must seriously evaluate the viability of ethanol production for fuel blending.
asserted
Pakistan → rise → blending
Several countries including India have already taken this path.
asserted
countries → include → path
Expanding ethanol output through multi-feedstock — sugarcane juice, maize, rice and other grains — plants would offer farmers a strategic alternative market while reducing oil imports, lowering carbon emissions, and strengthening national energy security.
asserted
Expanding → expand → security
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
