On July 27, 2026, a family had gathered to celebrate a birthday when their three-storey home in Lahore’s Harbanspura locality folded in on itself, one storey after another, killing 11 and injuring six.
asserted
home → gather → six
In an instant, the celebrations turned into panic and horror.
asserted
celebrations → turn → panic
Less than a month earlier, on June 30, a residential building that also served as a tuition centre in Lahore’s Kahna town, had collapsed, killing 14 children.
asserted
that → serve → children
The fact that both incidents occurred in Lahore, within weeks of each other at the height of the monsoon rains, brings two basic questions into sharp focus: can the homes of low-income families withstand shocks and is Punjab’s housing policy, which is centred largely on new construction, doing enough for the fragile, rickety homes that vulnerable households call ghar [home]?
It is a cruel irony that the rains that bring relief from the summer heat can also threaten the very shelter meant to protect families.
asserted
that → occur → families
Heavy rainfall can weaken walls, bring down roofs and, in the worst cases, leave families searching through rubble for those they love.
asserted
they → weaken → those
This season, across Punjab, successive spells of rain between June 26 and September 22 have claimed 69 lives and injured another 392, according to the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA).
uncertain
spells → claim → Authority
Among those killed were 29 men, 12 women and 28 children.
asserted
men → kill → those
It is reported that 71 percent of these deaths — 49 people — have occurred due to houses collapsing.
asserted
houses → report → deaths
Some 104 houses have been destroyed and 122 partially damaged across Punjab.
asserted
122 → destroy → Punjab
During the 2025 floods, Punjab recorded the highest housing losses in the country, with 55,134 houses completely destroyed and another 157,963 partially damaged.
asserted
157,963 → record → country
Against this backdrop, the Punjab government’s Apni Chhat Apna Ghar (literally: Own Roof, Own Home; ACAG) programme, its construction-loan design and ambitious claims are drawing scrutiny from housing experts and developers over whether the policy will ultimately translate into adequate, safer and accessible homes for those who need them most.
uncertain
who → draw → them
The collapse of homes during Punjab’s monsoon season has exposed how vulnerable low-income families are and raised questions about the province’s affordable housing policies.
asserted
families → expose → policies
As the Punjab government expands housing construction programmes and loans, experts and developers question whether building homes is enough if issues such as structural safety, infrastructure and accessibility are not addressed
TACKLING THE HOUSING PROBLEM
Soon after the Kahna tragedy, Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz launched the ‘Apni Chhat, Mahfooz Chhat’ [Own Roof, Secure Roof] programme in July.
asserted
Nawaz → expand → July
The director-general of the Punjab Housing and Town Planning Agency (PHATA), Sikandar Zeeshan, tells Eos that the programme offers interest-free loans of up to Rs500,000 for constructing additional rooms, repayable over nine years in monthly instalments of approximately Rs4,700; Rs500,000 for roof repairs, on the same repayment terms, while Rs1,000,000 is offered for constructing an additional floor, with monthly instalments of approximately Rs9,500.
asserted
Rs1,000,000 → tell → Rs9,500
The initiative is an extension of the Punjab government’s flagship ACAG programme, launched in August 2024, under which low-income households owning plots of up to five marlas in urban areas and 10 marlas [one marla is 272.25 square feet] in rural areas can obtain interest-free loans of up to Rs1.5 million to construct homes.
asserted
marla → launch → homes
It requires applicants to provide a valid computerised national identity card (CNIC), own or occupy an eligible plot or house, have no criminal record and provide two non-family guarantors.
asserted
It → require → guarantors
Applicants also undergo a social appraisal before a loan is approved.
asserted
loan → undergo → appraisal
Zeeshan claims that the ACAG programme has revolutionised the whole ecosystem of house-building in Punjab, stating, “In merely two years, 200,000 families have benefitted and, by 2028, 300,000 will benefit from the programme.
uncertain
300,000 → claim → programme
It may not solve the housing problem completely, but we are confident that no previous low-income housing programme has delivered as much as Apni Chhat Apna Ghar.”
uncertain
programme → solve → Ghar
In May 2026, Maryam Nawaz had echoed similar claims, by announcing that more than 100,000 houses had been completed under the ACAG programme, with another 600 to 700 houses being constructed each day.
uncertain
houses → echo → programme
But experts and developers are questioning the scale, design and the evidence base of the ACAG programme.
asserted
experts → question → programme
They ask: was there a comprehensive, province-wide assessment of how many households needed housing assistance and what form that assistance should take?
asserted
assistance → ask → form
Will the assistance improve housing conditions and reach those most in need?
asserted
assistance → improve → need
Jawad Aslam, founder and CEO of the Ansaar Management Company, a social-enterprise developer focused on affordable housing, says, “I find it difficult to believe that 100,000 affordable houses have actually been delivered.
asserted
houses → focus → housing
While some projects have certainly been completed, I have yet to see evidence of housing being delivered on anything close to the scale claimed publicly.
asserted
housing → complete → scale
While the people for whom the programme is intended are aware of the schemes, many still remain apprehensive about applying for the loans.
asserted
many → intend → loans
Samina, a domestic helper, says, “For a person earning 40,000 rupees a month, repaying nearly 14,000 rupees a month in instalments is impossible.”
asserted
repaying → say → instalments
Faisal, who works as a sports coach at an elite club, says, “These loans are approved for only those with jaan pehchaan [connections].”
asserted
loans → work → connections
Clearly, scepticism remains widespread and, whether well-founded or not, may be a barrier to the very people the schemes are designed to reach.
uncertain
schemes → remain → people
Their doubts are rooted in a longer history of housing schemes that have failed to deliver on their promises.
asserted
that → root → promises
It aimed to provide subsidised housing for low-income families, but it became embroiled in allegations of corruption and irregularities.
asserted
it → aim → corruption
Then came the Naya Pakistan Housing Programme, launched by the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) government in 2019, which relied on public-private partnerships and housing finance to deliver on its promise of five million homes nationwide, including an estimated 2-2.5 million in Punjab.
asserted
which → come → Punjab
That initiative also failed to deliver on its promise.
asserted
initiative → fail → promise
Nowhere near those numbers were ever achieved.
asserted
Nowhere → achieve → numbers
During this year’s monsoon season, along the residential streets of Ahlu Road in Lahore’s Kahna locality, almost every vacant plot became a receptacle for garbage, rainwater and sewage.
asserted
plot → become → garbage
In the middle of this mess stand rows of newly built concrete and steel houses, some of which have been built with ACAG loans.
asserted
some → stand → loans
In its Punjab Affordable Housing Programme appraisal, the World Bank estimated Punjab’s urban housing gap at 2.3 million units in 2017, with the largest in Lahore (302,000), Multan (215,000) and Faisalabad (208,000).
asserted
Bank → estimate → Lahore
It projected that the shortage could rise to 11.3 million units by 2047.
uncertain
shortage → project → 2047
But measuring the shortage of housing is only one way of looking at the problem.
asserted
measuring → measure → problem
The Pakistan Institute of Development Economics’ (PIDE) analysis of data from the 2019-20 Pakistan Social and Living Standards Measurement (PSLM) survey suggests that Punjab’s more fundamental housing problem is inadequacy, including the quality and structural condition of homes and access to basic services, than simply a deficit of housing units.
uncertain
problem → suggest → units
…and 112 more, not listed.
The Aporia
