- Published
A new NHS-style social care system for England could take decades to be implemented, economist Sir Andrew Dilnot has told the BBC.
uncertain
Dilnot → publish → BBC
Sir Andrew, who led a commission proposing reform of the system 15 years ago, said Prime Minister Andy Burnham appeared to want social care to be completely free, including residential costs.
asserted
care → lead → costs
He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the cost of such a scheme would be "very substantial".
asserted
cost → tell → scheme
And with Burnham promising to put his plans before voters at the next general election, Sir Andrew said change "is now further away".
asserted
change → promise → election
Adult social care provides state support to help people live more independently, including assistance at home.
asserted
people → provide → home
However, unlike the NHS, social care is not free at the point of use in England, leaving some people facing huge bills.
asserted
care → leave → bills
In an interview with the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Burnham suggested his proposals for social care would mean "everyone contributes, everyone is covered" and refused to rule out tax rises to fund such a system.
uncertain
everyone → suggest → system
He promised to set out more details of his vision in his conference speech on Tuesday.
asserted
He → promise → Tuesday
However, he suggested any proposals would not be implemented before the next general election, as he wanted to stick to the commitments in Labour's 2024 election manifesto, which included a promise not to increase national insurance, income tax or VAT.
uncertain
which → suggest → insurance
Labour MP and former minister Darren Jones told Laura Kuenssberg that scrapping the pensions triple lock was an "option that the government should consider alongside others" in order to fund social care reforms.
asserted
government → tell → reforms
The triple lock pension policy guarantees that the state pension will increase by either average wage growth, inflation or 2.5% - whichever is highest - and keeping it in place is also a Labour manifesto pledge.
asserted
keeping → guarantee → place
The next general election is not due until August 2029, although Burnham could choose to call one earlier.
uncertain
Burnham → choose → one
Sir Andrew told the BBC change on social care "is now further away" than had been implied when Burnham first promised a new national care service for England in a speech in July, shortly after he became prime minister.
asserted
he → tell → July
He pointed out that if proposals are included in Labour's 2029 election manifesto, that would be 30 years after Sir Tony Blair launched a royal commission on social care and more than 15 years since his own commission reported back.
asserted
commission → point → care
By promising an NHS-style system for social care, Sir Andrew said the PM was implying it would be "entirely free".
asserted
it → promise → care
In England and Northern Ireland, people with assets worth more than £23,250 - including their home - are not currently entitled to help with care costs from their council.
asserted
people → include → council
In Wales, social care is also means-tested.
asserted
care → test → Wales
In Scotland, state-funded personal care is offered to all adults who are assessed as needing help with tasks including eating and bathing.
asserted
who → fund → eating
However, this does not include accommodation, food and everyday living costs, which are subject to means testing.
asserted
which → include → testing
Sir Andrew said a Scottish-style system would still leave people in residential care facing "very substantial bills", which Burnham has said he wants to avoid.
asserted
he → say → which
The Health Foundation has estimated a universal social care system in England, with the government funding all support, could cost around £18.5bn a year.
uncertain
government → estimate → 18.5bn
On Sunday, Burnham said he believed the costs would be lower than this but he has not set out how he would fund his plans.
Sir Andrew said he believed an NHS-style social care system could costs "well in excess of £18bn", although a Scottish model could cost half this figure.
He added: "I also think that there was an indication in what [Burnham] said that he's imagining something that could take many years, even many decades before it came to fruition."
uncertain
it → say → fruition
Sir Andrew said he would "love to see such a scheme", where all social care is government-funded, but "the cost would become very, very large".
asserted
cost → say → scheme
He added that a system where the amount people must pay towards their care is capped, "could still work well for elderly people".
uncertain
people → add → people
Sir Andrew's own commission proposed a lifetime cap of £35,000.
asserted
commission → propose → 35,000
The report's recommendations were accepted by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government, led by David Cameron.
asserted
recommendations → accept → Cameron
However, the implementation of the cap was delayed to 2020, with Cameron blaming pressure on the public finances, and the idea was eventually dropped by subsequent Conservative governments.
Other proposals to reform the system have also failed, with Theresa May's Conservative government scrapping plans to make people receiving care at home pay the full costs if they were worth at least £100,000, after this was branded a "dementia tax" by opponents.
uncertain
this → delay → opponents
Meanwhile, when he was health secretary in Gordon Brown's government, Burnham's plan for a national care service suggested this could be paid for through a compulsory contribution from people's estates after they die.
uncertain
they → suggest → estates
The idea was branded a "death tax" by Labour's opponents and the proposals went no further after the party lost the 2010 general election.
asserted
party → brand → election
The Aporia
