Donald Trump’s administration is once again returning to the Supreme Court to target gender-affirming healthcare for transgender Americans.
asserted
administration → return → Americans
This time, the president wants to prevent trans people in the nation’s prisons from getting access.
asserted
president → want → access
Court rulings that grant trans inmates access to gender-affirming care, according to the government, threaten “institutional security.”
uncertain
that → grant → security
The phrase echoes the president’s ongoing reliance on “national security” as a last-ditch legal defense as he battles lawsuits against his ballroom, a ban on media outlets from covering the White House, and construction of a 250-foot victory arch, among others.
asserted
he → echo → others
The administration’s 41st emergency petition to the nation’s high court now calls on the justices to overturn court orders that blocked prison officials from providing trans inmates with affirming healthcare, a policy that is “necessary to maintain institutional security,” according to the government.
uncertain
that → call → government
A federal judge’s order that blocks the policy “causes irreparable harm to the government and to the public,” the filing says.
asserted
filing → block → public
“The administration’s policy is a direct threat to the well-being of transgender people in federal custody and an open violation of their fundamental rights,” according to a joint statement from the Transgender Law Center and ACLU, which are representing plaintiffs in the case.
uncertain
which → accord → case
“The withholding of medically necessary health care, including gender-affirming health care, from people in prison violates their Constitutional right to serve their sentence free of cruel and unusual punishment,” they said.
asserted
they → include → punishment
“We will continue to defend the rights of our clients and all incarcerated people.”
asserted
We → continue → clients
On his first day in office, Trump issued an executive order to restore “biological truth to the federal government,” a measure that has sought to erase the concept of gender from the federal government by ordering agencies to only recognize male or female sexes as assigned at birth.
asserted
that → issue → birth
The president ordered prisons to deny “any medical procedure, treatment, or drug for the purpose of conforming an inmate’s appearance to that of the opposite sex.”
asserted
president → order → sex
The policy also blocked trans inmates from buying clothing or commissary items that prison officials claimed are inconsistent with a person’s sex at birth.
asserted
officials → block → birth
Trump’s far-reaching executive orders targeting trans people claim that an ideologically driven movement to “deny the biological reality of sex” has a “corrosive impact not just on women but on the validity of the entire American system.”
uncertain
movement → reach → system
Trans women make up only a small fraction of the federal prison population in women’s facilities — roughly 20 people, according to the Bureau of Prisons.
uncertain
women → make → Prisons
The remainder, roughly 2,200 trans inmates in federal prisons, are detained in facilities that match their sex at birth, according to court filings.
uncertain
that → detain → filings
Several lawsuits were filed to reverse Trump-directed prison policies that stripped inmates of affirming healthcare and forced trans women into men’s facilities.
asserted
that → file → facilities
Kingdom v Trump, which is now in front of the Supreme Court, stems from a case brought by two trans men and one trans woman who were diagnosed with gender dysphoria by Bureau of Prisons medical providers and prescribed hormone therapy by health care staff.
But under Trump, that care was suspended, triggering a lawsuit.
asserted
care → stem → lawsuit
The loss of hormone therapy for a trans woman who has been prescribed injections since 2016 caused her to experience “anxiety, hopelessness, panic attacks, and suicidal ideation,” according to court filings.
uncertain
her → prescribe → filings
Trans men who were denied ongoing testosterone treatments said they feared their menstrual cycles would return.
asserted
cycles → deny → treatments
Plaintiffs argue Trump’s policy violates the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment.
asserted
policy → argue → punishment
Last year, 83-year-old Ronald Reagan-appointed Judge Royce Lamberth said Trump’s attempt to deny inmates gender-affirming care isn’t based on any “reasoned” analysis.
asserted
attempt → appoint → analysis
“Nothing in the thin record” of the case shows that the administration “consciously took stock of — much less studied — the potentially debilitating effects” of stripping trans people of their healthcare, he argued.
asserted
he → show → healthcare
Lamberth said trans people receiving hormone treatments “do not seem interested in propagating any particular ‘ideology.’”
asserted
people → say → ideology
Trans inmates rely on those treatments to “lessen the personal anguish caused by their gender dysphoria, a benefit on which they have relied for years” under longstanding Bureau of Prisons policy, according to the judge.
uncertain
they → rely → judge
He wrote that the administration did not provide “any serious explanation” or “any effort whatsoever” to explain how gender-affirming care damages “scientific inquiry, public safety, morale, trust in government.”
asserted
care → write → government
In the government’s emergency appeal to the Supreme Court, the Trump administration argues that the judge should have deferred to the Bureau of Prisons’ own expertise.
asserted
judge → argue → expertise
The judge’s suggestion that prison officials “provide additional factual support for those concerns” is ‘misguided,” according to Solicitor General D. John Sauer.
uncertain
officials → provide → Sauer
“Considerations of ‘institutional security’ are ‘peculiarly within the province and professional expertise of corrections officials, and, in the absence of substantial evidence in the record to indicate that the officials have exaggerated their response to these considerations, courts should ordinarily defer to their expert judgment in such matters,’” Sauer wrote.
asserted
Sauer → indicate → matters
Security concerns “outweigh” any benefits to providing affirming healthcare, he wrote.
asserted
he → outweigh → healthcare
“Any demand for additional evidence of security concerns cannot be reconciled with the ‘wide-ranging deference’ to which [the Bureau of Prisons’] expert judgment is entitled,” Sauer wrote.
asserted
Sauer → reconcile → Prisons
“Nor can it be reconciled with the ‘deference’ owed to agencies’ policy judgments in general.”
asserted
it → reconcile → judgments
The Aporia
