New York state prosecutors have reopened a case involving an alleged gang rape at Cornell University after a woman filed a civil lawsuit accusing the school and law enforcement officials of not doing enough.
asserted
woman → reopen → enough
According to court documents filed in the lawsuit on September 16, which include screenshots of a group chat purportedly between members of the university fraternity at the centre of the allegations, the woman, referred to as Jane Doe, alleged she was drugged and raped at the fraternity house in 2024.
uncertain
she → accord → 2024
The case has sparked anger on social media directed at Cornell and the District Attorney’s Office in Tompkins County, New York, over their handling of the allegations.
asserted
case → spark → allegations
On Monday, District Attorney Matthew Van Houten said in a statement that while at the time of the assault his office had found that evidence from the complainant’s initial statement did not meet the legal threshold to bring charges, he would now let a grand jury decide.
“Once we determine the appropriate charges, the case will be prosecuted in the most objective and impartial means available – by testimony to the Tompkins County grand jury,” Van Houten said.
asserted
Houten → say → jury
Here’s what we know about the case:
What’s the case about?
asserted
case → ’ → What
According to the 101-page lawsuit, the complainant visited a friend at the Chi Phi fraternity house at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, on October 19, 2024, while she was already intoxicated after drinking at a local, off-campus bar.
uncertain
she → accord → bar
She stated that two members of the house propositioned her to sleep with both of them and later pressured her into taking ketamine and smoking marijuana.
asserted
members → state → marijuana
Doe, 20 at the time, alleged she was then raped by seven men at the Chi Phi fraternity house over the course of seven hours before blacking out about 5:45am.
asserted
she → allege → hours
She said in the lawsuit that because she was under the influence, there was no way she was able to provide consent.
asserted
she → say → consent
Doe added that although she reported the incident to the university’s police department on November 8, 2024, prosecutors filed no criminal charges.
asserted
prosecutors → add → charges
In a statement to US broadcaster CBS News on Monday, Doe’s lawyer, Thomas Giuffra, said she went to the police because she believed she was the “victim of a crime”.
asserted
she → say → crime
“Other than her initial contact with Cornell Police, she was not contacted by investigators from the Tompkins County District Attorney’s Office or any investigators trained in interviewing rape survivors,” Giuffra said.
asserted
Giuffra → contact → survivors
He added that Cornell expelled two fraternity members after an internal review of the allegations, but five others received lesser repercussions, including suspensions, workshops and essay assignments.
asserted
others → add → suspensions
“Not one of these guys was arrested.
asserted
one → arrest → guys
That I can tell you for a fact,” Giuffra told CBS New York, adding that Doe dropped out of school after her ordeal.
asserted
Doe → tell → ordeal
The lawsuit names Matthew Ingalls, Johnathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris and Scott Kretzschmar as the men in question.
asserted
lawsuit → name → question
It also names Cornell; the Chi Phi fraternity; Doe’s sorority, Delta Delta Delta; the off-campus bar; and the seven men as defendants and accuses them of breach of contract, negligence and violations of state law.
asserted
It → name → law
Doe is seeking monetary damages, including compensatory and punitive damages.
asserted
Doe → seek → damages
The lawsuit did not specify how much Doe was asking for.
asserted
Doe → specify → much
The lawsuit includes images of a group chat on Snapchat among members of the fraternity in which one person alerted others crudely that they could sleep with the victim for “free”.
uncertain
they → include → victim
An image of the group chat shows a message from one person who wrote: “I f****** love Chi Phi.”
asserted
I → show → Phi
Kretzschmar, a then-fraternity member, allegedly sent two responses in the Snapchat group but has denied involvement.
uncertain
Kretzschmar → send → involvement
Have any of the defendants responded?
asserted
any → respond → defendants
Kretzschmar’s attorney, Jeremy Saland, told CBS News that the messages were inappropriate but were not evidence of sexual assault.
asserted
messages → tell → assault
“This is a situation where there was an ugly Snapchat – ugly, period. …
asserted
This → be → ?
But that doesn’t make my client a rapist, and it certainly doesn’t make anyone a sex offender,” Saland said.
asserted
Saland → make → ?
He added that his client had briefly entered the room where Doe was but did not touch her “in any way, shape or form” and left quickly afterwards.
asserted
Doe → add → way
Regarding the accusation of ketamine use, Saland said Kretzschmar took a hair follicle test that found he did not have the drug in his system, adding that no one has contacted him about a renewed investigation.
“We are available to present exonerating evidence.
asserted
We → regard → evidence
I just hope the right thing is eventually done, this case is closed and my client can live his life and not be subject to this selfish, repugnant, vile claim by this woman about him,” he added.
uncertain
he → hope → him
Meanwhile, Andrew Miltenberg, an attorney representing Lopes, also told CBS New York that his client “unequivocally denies the allegations against him”.
What has the university said?
In a statement published on Monday, Cornell said it supports the district attorney’s decision to have Doe’s story heard by a grand jury.
asserted
story → represent → jury
It explained that the university initially conducted its own investigation into the allegations over several months and sent the matter to a hearing in which a panel of trained faculty and staff heard evidence from Doe and the defendants.
“At its conclusion, the hearing panel issued a range of sanctions, which included expulsions and suspensions from Cornell.
asserted
which → explain → Cornell
None of the individuals charged were offered the opportunity to write essays as a sole consequence of their involvement,” the statement read, adding that Chi Phi fraternity was closed in 2024 and remains barred from campus.
asserted
fraternity → charge → campus
“Any suggestion that the university did not impose consequential punishments for those involved is false.
asserted
university → impose → those
A continuation of the false narrative that there were minimal consequences in this case is irresponsible, will make survivors feel less safe and supported, and will perpetuate the underreporting of sexual assault,” it added.
asserted
it → be → assault
What has the district attorney said?
asserted
attorney → say → What
According to Van Houten’s statement on Monday, in Doe’s initial statement in November 2024, she did not allege that she was drugged against her will or gang-raped.
“On the contrary, Jane Doe’s statement described her participation in drug use and sexual conduct as voluntary, conscious and consensual.
uncertain
statement → accord → use
My office obviously did not and could not have based our November 2024 decision on the allegations in a civil lawsuit that would not be filed until nearly two years later,” he said.
uncertain
he → do → lawsuit
“I recognise the reality that it can take years of therapy and healing for victims of sexual assaults to fully process and understand what happened to them.
asserted
what → recognise → them
Seeking justice sometimes requires us to reconsider or reopen cases when we are provided with additional evidence,” the statement added.
asserted
statement → seek → evidence
Van Houten said a female senior prosecutor from his office who has significant experience in prosecuting sex crimes and has been involved in conducting jury trials in college sexual assault cases will prepare the case for the grand jury.
asserted
who → say → jury
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
