As Flock continues to be the center of a nationwide conversation about automatic license plate reading cameras, the company has said that it doesn’t, and won’t, do facial recognition: “We will not add facial recognition to our devices,” Flock CEO Garrett Langley said in a recent video.
asserted
Langley → continue → video
But other, third-party companies are telling cops that they are willing to add facial recognition to data gathered by Flock cameras in order to “close that gap.”
asserted
they → tell → gap
A company called VIDIZMO is advertising the capability to export footage from FlockOS to its own platforms that do facial recognition, behavior prediction, and racial and gender analysis on live camera feeds.
asserted
that → call → feeds
VIDIZMO is a several decades-old video analysis and database company that has started offering facial recognition technology to cops within the last six months.
asserted
that → start → months
In a May email to Johnson City, Tennessee, deputy police chief Michael Adams, a salesperson from VIDIZMO wrote that the company’s product could do facial recognition on both Flock and Axon data in “one searchable platform.”
uncertain
product → write → platform
“Flock Safety generates plate reads and clips continuously.
asserted
Safety → generate → reads
Your investigators use that data on active cases.
asserted
investigators → use → cases
But that Flock data does not connect automatically to your Axon evidence system,” the salesperson wrote.
asserted
salesperson → connect → system
“VIDIZMO Intelligence Hub closes that gap.
asserted
Hub → close → gap
It brings Flock Safety data, Axon body worn camera footage, and any other evidence source into one searchable platform.
asserted
It → bring → platform
Investigators search across all of it simultaneously — by face, vehicle, or object in seconds.”
asserted
Investigators → search → seconds
The email was obtained using a public records request by DeFlock Johnson City and was shared with 404 Media.
asserted
email → obtain → Media
The Johnson City PD told 404 Media in a statement that it did not take a call with the company.
asserted
it → tell → company
VIDIZMO’s CEO, Nadeem Khan, told 404 Media on a video call that the company has not yet started running facial recognition tech on footage from Flock cameras, and that it has not actually built the specific tool that would export data from Flock’s system to its own platform (though the company advertises this capability online, and the company already sells other facial recognition products).
asserted
company → tell → products
But Khan said VIDIZMO “would love to do the integration,” and that he believes facial recognition “is the way the world is going, the way the world will have to be,” and that he thinks Flock should offer the capability itself in a way that “balances privacy, security, and the freedom that we enjoy in this country.”
asserted
we → say → country
“It is completely in line with what we want to do,” Khan said.
asserted
Khan → want → what
“All of these technologies are already implemented [in the real world].
asserted
All → implement → world
I think Flock is trying to get out of the way rather than trying to implement the technology right [correctly] by saying they will not do recognition.
asserted
they → think → recognition
But this is the way the world is going, it is the way the world will have to be, but with the right sort of technologies where privacy and security are balanced.”
asserted
privacy → go → technologies
In marketing material and technical documentation available online, VIDIZMO does claim that it can ingest data from Flock’s automatic license plate reader (ALPR) and livestream cameras into several of its own products, which do further AI analysis on the data.
uncertain
which → claim → data
“An agency can import plate reads or clips that it has exported under its own authorized access,” Khan said in an email.
asserted
Khan → import → email
“Flock has not been involved in or informed of this.”
asserted
Flock → involve → this
VIDIZMO’s online documentation for customers has extensive information about its facial recognition and AI analysis products, and contains a page about integrating data from FlockOS — Flock’s “real time crime center” product — into AI Live Insight, Nexus, and AI Intelligence Hub, which are three different VIDIZMO products.
asserted
which → have → Insight
“Detection tells you a person is in frame,” VIDIZMO says.
asserted
VIDIZMO → tell → frame
“Face recognition tells you which person.
asserted
recognition → tell → you
It is the capability that takes a face seen on a live camera and matches it against the people you enrolled in the Object Library, so the moment someone on your watchlist walks past a camera, the system names them, on the video, in the event feed, and in the recording, without an operator having to recognize the face themselves.
asserted
operator → take → face
The company’s “AI Live Insight” page also claims that it can detect “situations” such as trespassing, or “behavior” by individual people, “turning raw video into behavioral and situational understanding.”
uncertain
it → claim → understanding
“Instant alerts fire from the live pipeline with snapshots attached.
asserted
snapshots → fire → pipeline
A second layer runs your queries over recorded events: a plate and a person together,” VIDIZMO’s website says.
asserted
website → run → events
VIDIZMO already works with several police departments and government agencies, according to its website.
uncertain
VIDIZMO → work → website
The company’s documentation says that police departments need to upload individual faces as “objects” in the software’s library, which can be added to a “watchlist” that automatically triggers tracking and recording when they are detected by a camera.
asserted
they → say → camera
“With faces enrolled and recognition on, the camera starts naming people as they appear,” the documentation says.
asserted
documentation → enrol → people
“The recognized person’s name appears on the bounding box around their face […] if you turned on Create Recording, a clip is captured around each recognition.”
asserted
clip → recognize → recognition
The company says that police can set a “Match Threshold,” which is a numerical confidence score about the person’s identity.
asserted
which → say → identity
The company also tells cops that it can automatically try to classify faces by “age, gender, and race,” and that cops can search by these categories, which are notoriously inaccurate in facial recognition systems.
asserted
which → tell → systems
“By running face detection, you can search for and identify specific individuals in your media or evidence via attribute filters [
asserted
you → run → filters
You can identify individuals from seven races: White, Black, Indian, East Asian, Southeast Asian, Middle Eastern, and Latino Hispanic,” VIDIZMO says on its website.
asserted
VIDIZMO → identify → website
The company adds, “Law enforcement agencies can save time analyzing security, CCTV, or dashcam footage.
asserted
agencies → add → security
If they have a description of the suspect, such as their supposed age, gender, or race, they can utilize attribute filters to yield effective results.”
asserted
they → have → results
VIDIZMO says that in other contexts, cities or stores can also use its products to quietly do “demographic analysis,” for marketing purposes, by determining which races or ages of people are showing up to specific events or to specific stores: “By analyzing the activity in their store, sellers can determine which group spends the most time and makes the most purchases of their products.
asserted
group → say → products
…and 20 more, not listed.
The Aporia
