“We’re going to win everything…
asserted
We → go → everything
Canada is going to come in and say: ‘Sir, we are very sorry’.”
asserted
we → go → ?
U.S. President Donald Trump told reporters in the White House on Monday that he thinks a trade deal with Canada that gets rid of tariffs will be struck, possibly within three to four weeks.
uncertain
that → tell → weeks
Recommended Videos
The impression left by the president is that all the pain from the trade war is being felt on a Canadian side that is ready to kow-tow and submit to his authority.
asserted
that → leave → authority
Steel producer Stelco has told customers that it is “indefinitely idling” the cold-rolled and coated lines at its Hamilton, Ont. works because of tariffs, impacting 350 jobs.
asserted
it → tell → jobs
On the same day, Trump unveiled plans for a US$15-billion steel mill in Iowa that will create 1,750 jobs: a timely announcement, given Iowa’s Senate seat is a toss-up in the looming midterm elections.
asserted
seat → unveil → elections
“The steel industry is roaring back to life.
asserted
industry → roar → life
Everyone’s building their plants here because they don’t want to pay tariffs,” the president said.
asserted
president → build → tariffs
“(Mark) Carney is the world’s best talker and the world’s worst negotiator,” was the reaction of one person, and there were many others lamenting Canada’s lack of leverage.
asserted
reaction → be → leverage
To be fair to the president, there are signs that his efforts to lure manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. are paying off.
asserted
efforts → be → U.S.
American voters will decide in the midterm elections whether a marginal increase in manufacturing employment is worth the increase in the cost of living and the scapegoating of loyal allies.
But the Stelco case does not indicate that Canada is heading for humiliating defeat.
asserted
Canada → decide → defeat
For one thing, the Canadian economy is proving more resilient than many predicted.
asserted
many → prove → thing
The GDP numbers for July were flat, but advanced estimates for August indicate the economy remains on course for third-quarter growth (annualized) of 1.8 per cent.
asserted
economy → indicate → cent
Canada’s economy is still expanding, despite the trade war.
asserted
economy → expand → war
The government pointed to Tuesday’s announcement by LNG Canada (a consortium of five global energy companies) that it plans a massive $30-billion expansion to its Kitimat, B.C. terminal as indicative of the sense of possibility that still exists.
asserted
that → point → possibility
At the announcement in B.C., Wael Sawan, Shell’s global CEO, said the expansion is a sign of confidence in Canada as a place to invest and do business.
asserted
expansion → say → business
Carney said the commitment to build the second largest LNG facility in the world is a demonstration that “Canada is working.”
asserted
Canada → say → world
“(We) fully value export diversification and the greater sovereignty it confers,” he said.
asserted
he → value → diversification
Another reason that too much should not be read into the Stelco announcement is that it is an atypical case.
asserted
it → read → announcement
The company is owned by the U.S.-company Cleveland Cliffs, whose chairman, Lourenco Goncalves, is a vocal supporter of the president and his tariff policy.
asserted
chairman → own → president
Canadian officials say privately it seems as if Goncalves wants to shut the Hamilton plant.
asserted
Goncalves → say → plant
They say the company made unrealistic demands on Ottawa, including a call for billions in loans, without employment security or payback conditions.
asserted
company → say → security
The federal government has responded to U.S. tariffs with support programs like the $1-billion liquidity fund administered by the Business Development Bank and $500 million for smaller firms through the Regional Tariff Response Initiative.
asserted
government → respond → Initiative
Canadian primary steel producers have traditionally exported half their output to the U.S.
Tariffs have closed that market and companies such as Stelco were forced to sell exclusively in Canada.
Canadian production was in decline, even before the tariffs, falling to 12.2-million tonnes in 2023 from 16.6-million tonnes in 2000.
asserted
production → export → 2000
The government has responded by trying to boost domestic demand and limiting imports.
asserted
government → respond → imports
Tariff rate quotas have been adjusted to reduce the amount of subsidized foreign steel entering Canada, which used to account for two-thirds of demand.
asserted
which → adjust → demand
Steel volumes from countries without free-trade agreements with Canada are now set at 20 per cent of 2024 levels tariff-free, after which a 50 per cent tariff applies.
asserted
tariff → set → which
Officials suggest imports of flat-rolled steel have fallen by a third, which directly benefits domestic businesses.
asserted
which → suggest → businesses
Yet Stelco refused all help, including last-minute emergency funding that would have sustained operations and avoided layoffs, one official claimed.
asserted
official → refuse → layoffs
Anyone who has ever lived in Hamilton (as I have) knows steel is at the core of its identity, its economy and its blue-collar culture.
asserted
steel → live → identity
Hundreds of well-paying jobs are not easily replaced.
asserted
Hundreds → pay → jobs
Fingers will be pointed in Ottawa’s direction, but the blame rests squarely in the White House and in the executive suite at Cleveland Cliffs.
asserted
blame → point → Cliffs
Strangely, the Stelco news makes a deal more likely.
asserted
deal → make → ?
Carney’s biggest challenge may have been convincing Canadians that any kind of accord with Trump is desirable.
uncertain
kind → convince → Trump
The prospect of job losses may dampen bravado.
uncertain
prospect → dampen → bravado
But if a deal is struck, it will not be because Trump is “winning everything.”
asserted
Trump → strike → everything
Predictive markets suggest Senate seats in Republican strongholds including Alaska, Iowa, Ohio, Maine, Michigan, North Carolina and Texas are in play.
asserted
seats → suggest → play
Most of those states count Canada as their No. 1 export destination.
asserted
Most → count → destination
Ottawa has leverage and Canadians should hold their nerve.
asserted
Canadians → have → nerve
A deal is likely, but no one is going to rush, cap in hand, to the White House to apologize and accept whatever terms the president dictates.
asserted
president → go → terms
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
