Reparations activists from a grassroots organization called the U.S. Freedmen Project told Fox News Digital that recent immigrants and non-foundational Black Americans should not be included in government reparations programs.
asserted
immigrants → call → programs
"I also think it’s not morally correct, you know?
asserted
you → think → ?
You don't give out remedies to people who haven't experienced the harm," Annette Wilcox, a spokesperson for the group, told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Wilcox → give → Digital
"A lot of these policies — the Commission on Racial Equity in the city, the Mayor’s Office on Equity and Justice — they talk constantly about slavery, Jim Crow, redlining, convict leasing.
asserted
they → talk → slavery
All of those things that happened to a specific group of people," Wilcox added.
asserted
Wilcox → happen → people
"Then, when it comes time to give out resources and remedies, it's going to everybody: underserved communities, POC [people of color], immigrants, marginalized groups.
asserted
it → come → color
You’re using one group of people's history to then give remedies to a wider group.
asserted
You → use → group
The U.S. Freedmen Project, composed of self-identified "Foundational Black Americans," aims to educate the public on the legal and historical distinctions between African Americans who are direct descendants of enslaved people in the U.S. and those who immigrated to the country voluntarily in recent decades.
asserted
who → compose → decades
Wilcox reacted sharply to efforts by New Jersey Democrats pushing the state to consider direct reparations proposals that could include residents who are not direct descendants of enslaved people.
uncertain
who → react → people
The proposed legislation — the Truth, Reconciliation, and Repair Act, spearheaded by Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson and state Sen. Angela McKnight — aims to address wealth disparities stemming from historical slavery and systemic discrimination.
asserted
legislation → propose → slavery
Informed by research from the New Jersey Reparations Council, the bill seeks to establish a framework for state-level reparative policies.
asserted
bill → inform → policies
U.S. Freedmen Project president Devine Prince told Fox News Digital that lawmakers and certain advocates are "conflating reparations with racial justice and social justice."
asserted
lawmakers → tell → justice
Fox News Digital previously spoke with New York residents who voiced similar concerns during a public hearing for the New York State Community Commission on Reparations Remedies at Hempstead High School on Long Island.
asserted
who → speak → Island
Residents warned state officials that broadening the scope of reparations to include recent immigrants and other marginalized groups risks co-opting and diluting the movement.
asserted
broadening → warn → movement
One supporter, Aubrey Muhammad, delivered tense testimony accusing politicians of misallocating resources away from historic Black communities amidst demographic shifts.
asserted
supporter → deliver → shifts
"The Democrats, in a sick way, imported 25 million immigrants.
asserted
Democrats → import → immigrants
And 70% of them came into poor Black neighborhoods," Muhammad argued in a follow-up interview with Fox News Digital.
asserted
Muhammad → come → Digital
"Hempstead, since the '90s, has been flooded with immigrants.
asserted
Hempstead → flood → immigrants
That's taking the resources, putting them towards others."
Demographic data from the U.S. Census Bureau reflect significant changes in the Village of Hempstead over the last three decades.
asserted
data → take → decades
Today, the community of roughly 59,000 is nearly evenly split between Black residents (43.2%) and Hispanic or Latino residents (45.3%).
asserted
community → split → residents
In 1990, the Hispanic population made up roughly 14% of the village.
asserted
population → make → village
"That’s why, frankly, I think we're in the situation today, where descendants of slavery in the United States are at the bottom of just about every socioeconomic parameter," Wilcox said.
asserted
Wilcox → ’ → parameter
Prince expounded on the issue, arguing that broader social challenges deserve their own dedicated solutions rather than being packaged under the umbrella of reparations.
asserted
challenges → expound → reparations
"What we're finding out coming from the left wing of the political spectrum is that they are conflating reparations with racial justice and social justice.
asserted
they → find → justice
All three are similar, but they are far from the same," Prince said.
asserted
Prince → say → same
"So what happens is when people believe a rising tide lifts all boats … you're conflating repair for the badges and incidents of slavery with discrimination like not being able to catch a cab, or with the social justice of fair immigration policies.
asserted
you → happen → policies
Members of the U.S. Freedmen Project have become vocal fixtures at public hearings across the country.
asserted
Members → become → country
They maintain that true reparations must be lineage-based — strictly reserved for direct descendants of enslaved human beings in the United States.
asserted
reparations → maintain → States
Prince argued that for any reparations policy to survive inevitable legal challenges, it must be tied strictly to lineage rather than race.
asserted
it → argue → race
"What the Democratic Party loves to do is push them all together to create 'people of color' coalitions.
asserted
loves → love → coalitions
These policies are largely being pushed in blue states, which is also where these issues are happening," Prince said.
asserted
Prince → push → states
"There is a responsibility for any political entity to address its constituents directly and, more importantly, specifically — because that's how true coalitions are built, not by cobbling people together and pretending they all have the same plight and political priorities."
asserted
they → be → plight
New Jersey and New York are part of a broader wave of state and municipal governments exploring reparative frameworks.
asserted
governments → explore → frameworks
In Illinois, the Chicago suburb of Evanston made headlines as the first city to distribute government-funded reparations to Black residents to remedy historic housing discrimination.
asserted
suburb → make → discrimination
However, Evanston’s program faces a high-profile class-action lawsuit filed by Judicial Watch, a conservative legal group, alleging the program’s race-based eligibility criteria violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
asserted
criteria → face → Amendment
"It either becomes something that is unconstitutional and will be challenged and shut down — like Evanston is on its way to being done — or you convert it into a universal program," he said.
"That is not reparations," Prince warned.
asserted
Prince → become → program
While Prince called broader social and racial justice initiatives "admirable," he reiterated that they should not hijack the legal definition of reparations.
asserted
they → call → reparations
"Reparations, in the context we're talking about, are only for those that were enslaved, emancipated, and then subject to the badges and incidents thereof," Prince said.
asserted
Prince → talk → badges
Positioning it that way circumvents any legal challenge based on race."
asserted
Positioning → position → race
The New Jersey lawmakers did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.
asserted
lawmakers → respond → comment
The Aporia
