When Abdul Samad Arshad cut in past a Philippines defender before shooting the ball along the ground to beat the goalkeeper on Tuesday, it was a moment of disbelief for the Pakistan fans — those in small numbers at the Si Jalak Harupat Stadium in Bandung, Indonesia, and those watching on screens back home and around the world.
asserted
it → cut → world
The shot — now etched in Pakistan football history as the one that brought the side its first-ever point in a FIFA competition, the FIFA ASEAN Cup, and against a side ranked more than 60 places above it — equalled the scores to 2-2 after Philippines had scored two early, and sparked celebrations in equal measure.
asserted
Philippines → etch → measure
The delight was special because it came with a surprise element.
asserted
it → come → element
How could a team that had prepared for the tournament in a short training camp, without its head coach, stun a higher-ranked side in this manner?
uncertain
that → prepare → manner
How could a team from a country without even a semblance of a proper football competition and grassroots structure challenge one from a country that has all of that and more?
uncertain
that → challenge → all
And how could a federation beset by a prolonged crisis field a side so competitive?
uncertain
federation → beset → side
Samad provided one answer.
asserted
Samad → provide → answer
The Pakistan player based abroad had arrived in Indonesia on Sept 25, a day before the team’s opening FIFA ASEAN Cup match against Thailand, which Pakistan lost 4-0.
asserted
Pakistan → base → which
Several of his fellow diaspora players also joined the squad directly in Indonesia rather than being part of the national-team camp in Islamabad.
asserted
Several → join → Islamabad
The Peruvian coach missed the camp after applying for the wrong type of Pakistan visa.
asserted
coach → miss → visa
His documents had to be resubmitted, delaying his arrival until the team was already in Indonesia.
asserted
team → have → Indonesia
In his absence, assistant coaches Titus Bramble and Walid Javaid oversaw the sessions.
asserted
Bramble → oversee → sessions
For a national team whose players largely do not play together, those lost days matter.
asserted
days → play → team
Yet two days after Samad arrived, Pakistan were back on the pitch against the Philippines and, after falling 2-0 behind, produced the sort of comeback that had rarely been seen from the national side.
asserted
that → arrive → side
Mohammad Ali Akbar pulled one back two minutes after half-time before Samad equalised around the hour.
asserted
Samad → pull → hour
Pakistan had never previously scored in, or taken a point from, a FIFA competition.
asserted
Pakistan → score → point
They had now done both in the same match.
asserted
They → do → match
“This is a fantastic result for Pakistan football, arguably its most impressive result of the 21st century,” Ismail Farooq, a football analyst at FC Nuremberg in Germany and a keen observer of Pakistan football, tells Dawn.
asserted
Farooq → tell → Dawn
Ismail puts the achievement into perspective by pointing to the gulf between the two teams.
asserted
Ismail → put → teams
Pakistan are ranked 198th in the world while the Philippines are around 60 places higher and have the kind of regular domestic football and established structures that Pakistan have lacked.
asserted
Pakistan → rank → that
Pakistan, he said, were “massive underdogs”.
asserted
he → say → ?
That makes the fightback significant.
asserted
fightback → make → ?
But it also makes what happened before it harder to ignore.
asserted
happened → make → it
The players arrived from different parts of the world, trained together for a limited period and entered the tournament without having had the benefit of a full camp under their head coach.
asserted
players → arrive → coach
The result therefore says as much about the resilience of the players as it does about the possibilities that exist within Pakistan’s player pool.
asserted
that → say → pool
It is also where the country’s diaspora footballers become part of a much larger conversation.
asserted
footballers → become → conversation
The overseas-based players have increasingly provided Pakistan with a pool of talent that would be difficult for the domestic system to produce on its own.
asserted
system → base → own
But their late arrival also highlights the absence of a sufficiently strong structure at home to prepare and develop players consistently.
asserted
arrival → highlight → players
Shaikh Hamdan, head coach of Karachi United Football Club and a UEFA B-licensed coach, believes the result could nevertheless have an important effect well beyond the national team.
uncertain
result → license → team
“Any positive result for Pakistan football can only be a good thing for the game at grassroots level,” he tells Dawn.
asserted
he → tell → Dawn
“Results inspire participation.”
asserted
Results → inspire → participation
Children watching Pakistan score and compete, he added, could begin to dream of representing the country, while positive performances could also help convince parents that football can be more than simply a recreational pursuit for their children.
uncertain
football → watch → children
That is the opportunity presented by Bandung.
asserted
That → present → Bandung
But it is not the same as having a functioning football system.
asserted
it → have → system
Pakistan have not had a proper domestic league since 2015.
asserted
Pakistan → have → 2015
Youth competitions remain limited and competitive opportunities for young players are scarce.
asserted
opportunities → remain → players
“There are passionate coaches, academies and football communities doing excellent work across the country,” Hamdan says.
asserted
Hamdan → be → country
“But there is still no structured pathway that consistently takes talented young players from grassroots football through youth competitions and into the professional and international game.
asserted
that → be → game
That gap has consequences.
asserted
gap → have → consequences
Talented youngsters can spend crucial developmental years without enough meaningful competitive matches.
asserted
youngsters → spend → matches
…and 50 more, not listed.
The Aporia
