When assessing British political speeches, even many critics of the New Labour years measure success against Tony Blair, a leader whose podium appearances are regarded as the peak of oratory.
asserted
appearances → assess → oratory
On that measure, Andrew Marr, the former BBC political editor and now the New Statesman’s chief political commentator, reached for the ultimate accolade.
asserted
Marr → reach → accolade
“Rather to my surprise, I have to report Andy Burnham is at least as good a platform speaker” as Blair, he said.
asserted
he → have → Blair
Piers Morgan, the former News of the World editor, concluded that Burnham’s speech to the Labour party conference on Tuesday was “one of the best, and most powerfully delivered, by a British politician in a very long time”.
asserted
speech → conclude → time
Burnham’s onstage performance was also praised by Tim Shipman, the right-of-centre Spectator magazine’s political editor.
asserted
performance → praise → centre
He concluded it was sub-Blair but “as good as anything we’ve seen since”.
asserted
we → conclude → anything
Shipman wrote: “I’ve been attending party conferences since 2001 and in that time I’ve heard about 70 leaders’ speeches from all the parties.
asserted
I → write → parties
This was one of the most important and defining – I expect it will remain among the half-dozen most memorable.”
asserted
it → expect → dozen
Patrick Maguire, the Times’s chronicler of Labour’s inner workings, agreed.
asserted
Maguire → agree → workings
“The Labour party will talk about this speech for years and it will be remembered, as so few speeches are, as a formative, watershed moment in the history of this young century, for better or worse,” he said.
asserted
he → talk → century
Quentin Letts, the Mail’s sketch writer, said the speech was so saccharine in its plea for unity that “I got diabetic twinges”.
asserted
I → say → twinges
While there was both fulsome and grudging praise for Burnham’s delivery – the Daily Mail’s highly critical editorial on the speech said the “PM’s performance was slick, oozing everyman charm” – its radical nature placed it squarely in the crosshairs of the right-leaning media.
asserted
nature → be → media
A new Brexit deal, the prospect of a proportional voting system and his social care and housing plans were all targeted.
asserted
deal → target → system
The Mail’s front page described the “triple shock” of Burnham’s pension changes, care plans and Brexit rethink.
asserted
page → describe → changes
It regarded the speech as the “most leftwing speech by a PM since [the] 1970s”.
asserted
It → regard → 1970s
The Telegraph said it was a “road back to a failed past”.
asserted
it → say → past
The Sun, which has a difficult relationship with Burnham amid claims that he will not give any interviews or opinion pieces to the once dominant red top, did not hold back.
uncertain
he → have → top
It labelled the speech the “locky horror show”, a reference to Burnham’s pledge to end the pensions triple lock that guarantees big increases in the state pension.
asserted
that → label → pension
“The British vote system ‘rigged’,” it said.
asserted
it → say → ?
“Government to seize private homes,” it claimed, a reference to Burnham’s plan to remove homes from bad landlords.
asserted
it → seize → landlords
He described the address as “the most divisive speech I’ve heard from any prime minister”.
asserted
I → describe → minister
He even described the prime minister’s emotional reference to his late father as “a blatant pitch for sympathy from voters who might otherwise have been shocked by what we can all now see as Burnham’s truly socialist revolution”.
uncertain
we → describe → revolution
The Sun’s editorial column lamented Burnham’s lack of action on cutting the “ballooning welfare bill”.
asserted
column → lament → bill
Attacks on Burnham’s lack of attention to the welfare bill –a theme for both the Conservatives and Reform UK – was reflected across the rightwing media.
asserted
Attacks → reflect → media
“Who pays for PM’s New Jerusalem,” asked the Mail’s editorial column, suggesting the speech would have pleased Labour supporters in the hall but concerned the general voter.
asserted
speech → pay → voter
It also took the chance to put the boot into Burnham’s predecessor, Keir Starmer.
asserted
It → take → predecessor
“There’s no question he is an oratorical improvement on his incorrigibly wooden predecessor, a strong candidate for worst public speaker in political history,” it jibed.
asserted
it → ’ → history
“[Burnham] knew his audience, enthralling them with his northern working-class boy made good life story.
asserted
Burnham → know → story
The truth is that Middle England is about to be deluged with new tax rises, but ‘Honest Andy’ is too craven to admit it.”
The Daily Express’s front-page headline decried the speech as a “crying shame for our nation”.
asserted
headline → deluge → nation
Despite praising the delivery, the Spectator’s Shipman cited “room for improvement” in the speech’s content, citing potential flaws in his plan for a national care service and the limited early savings from ditching the pensions triple lock.
asserted
Shipman → praise → lock
He argued Burnham had “no plan for growth” – the issue that has plagued prime ministers of both main parties.
asserted
that → argue → parties
Shipman concluded that the speech amounted to “the most partisan leftwing set of priorities we have seen since the days of Harold Wilson”.
asserted
we → conclude → Wilson
What united coverage was a conclusion that unlike Starmer, Burnham had produced a clear statement of intent about who he was and what he wanted to achieve – for better or worse.
asserted
he → unite → what
The Times’s Maguire concluded: “There will be a hell of a row before we know whether it’s an epoch-defining Thatcherism of the left or Truss with charisma.
asserted
it → conclude → charisma
But for the first time in recent history, the leader of the Labour party wants that argument and is making his own.”
asserted
leader → want → own
The Times’s editorial column, however, reflected the political right’s early verdict on Burnham’s address – an appeal based in Labour’s comfort zone.
asserted
column → reflect → zone
“Mr Burnham’s speech was in some ways a curious throwback,” it stated.
asserted
it → state → ways
“Labour is becoming more middle class by the year, in composition and support, yet he imagines it as a vehicle dedicated to the working class of his memory.
asserted
he → become → memory
What exactly are wealth creators supposed to make of this charming man?”
asserted
creators → suppose → man
The Aporia
