Faced with recent questions about the
, the surveillance camera startup Flock Safety and its CEO have deployed a tidy statistic to tout its benefits.
asserted
startup → face → benefits
"Last year we helped clear just over a million crimes in America," Flock CEO Garrett Langley said in a March 2026 podcast interview.
asserted
Langley → help → interview
"Over a million cases were solved last year with this technology," Langley told the auto industry publication The Drive, "and the level of abuse is incredibly low relative to that."
"Today, Flock technology assists your officers in more than one million crimes solved annually," Langley said in a blog post last month announcing new privacy updates.
asserted
Langley → solve → updates
But a CBS News review finds the claim that Flock helped solve a million crimes in 2025 is not supported by the available evidence.
uncertain
Flock → find → evidence
In a statement for this report, Flock spokesman Paris Lewbel cast the statistic in a different framing.
asserted
Lewbel → cast → framing
In addition to case clearances, he said, it includes "investigative leads, cross-jurisdictional assistance, searches conducted during active investigations, and other Flock deployments.
asserted
it → say → investigations
"
"The most precise way to describe our 2025 national estimate is that Flock technology supported approximately 1 million investigations and incidents," Lewbel said.
asserted
Lewbel → describe → investigations
The company did not answer whether Langley had been imprecise in claiming Flock solved one million crimes in 2025, and did not provide CBS News with underlying data supporting that claim.
uncertain
Flock → answer → claim
Flock first explained the source of its claims of one million crimes solved in a May 2026 blog post announcing the results of its 2025 Impact Census, in which about 700 law enforcement agencies that use Flock's system participated.
uncertain
that → explain → system
Flock says agencies that formally tracked outcomes supplied raw counts, while others provided percentage estimates.
asserted
others → say → estimates
The blog post also said the study found 20% of cleared cases in customer jurisdictions in 2025 were assisted by Flock technology.
asserted
% → say → technology
In explaining the 20% finding, the company said 307 agencies supplied percentage estimates.
asserted
agencies → explain → estimates
Those responses were then referenced with FBI crime and clearance data for each responding agency.
asserted
responses → reference → agency
"Across all use cases — direct case clearances, investigative leads, cross-jurisdictional assists, and field deployments — Flock supported approximately 1 million investigations and incidents during the year," the company said in the blog post.
asserted
company → support → post
Experts in crime data say the company's crime-solving statistical claims are not reliable.
uncertain
claims → say → data
"It's worth about the paper it's printed on," said Charles Fain Lehman, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute who is a proponent of the technology.
asserted
who → print → technology
"...But I think if you look under the hood of the academic research, that still points you in a direction of there's an effect — it's just a smaller effect."
asserted
it → think → direction
Footnotes and caveats on Flock's blog post regarding its 2025 Impact Census say these figures are "directional estimates rather than audited totals" and that its methodology is "not a finished product."
The company's claims have surfaced in local government documents and deliberations as municipalities grapple with the costs and benefits of the surveillance technology.
uncertain
municipalities → regard → technology
When the city council in Costa Mesa, California, considered whether to continue its contract with Flock this summer at an annual cost of $151,800, city records show, its police department issued a positive recommendation that cited in part the claim that "Flock technology assisted in solving an estimated 20% of cleared cases" in 2025.
uncertain
technology → consider → 2025
On July 21, Costa Mesa City Council voted 6-1 to keep the cameras but renegotiate the city's contract with Flock.
asserted
Council → vote → Flock
Even if its CEO described Flock's statistical claims with all the caveats included on its website, criminologists say there are bigger issues with its methodology.
uncertain
criminologists → describe → methodology
A major issue with Flock's study is that even if Flock is used to help with a case, "it doesn't necessarily mean in a counterfactual world where Flock cameras didn't exist, the case wouldn't have been solved," said Andrew Wheeler, a criminologist and data scientist at Gainwell Technologies who has published research on automated license plate technology.
asserted
who → use → technology
Flock's study of 2025 crime, he said, did not use established empirical methods to account for this counterfactual.
asserted
he → say → counterfactual
"The 'a million crimes solved' is probably a gross over-estimate based on that particular work," Wheeler said.
asserted
Wheeler → solve → work
Disputed statistical claims
It is not the first time Flock's statistics have come under scrutiny.
uncertain
statistics → come → scrutiny
In 2024, the company began claiming that its technology "is instrumental in solving 10% of reported crimes in the U.S."
asserted
technology → begin → U.S.
(This is distinct from its later claim that an estimated 20% of cleared cases in 2025 were assisted by Flock technology in customer jurisdictions.)
uncertain
% → estimate → jurisdictions
The 10% claim was promoted publicly in a February 2024 press release connected to the release of a white paper authored by two Flock employees.
uncertain
claim → promote → employees
However, that 10% claim is not actually contained within the text of the Flock-authored white paper.
uncertain
claim → contain → paper
Rather, the paper concludes that every additional camera per sworn officer is associated with a 9.1-percentage-point increase in the agency's license plate reader-assisted clearance rate.
asserted
camera → conclude → rate
The white paper says it was "created with the consultation" of two academics — Johnny Nhan of Texas Christian University and Richard Helfers of the University of Texas at Tyler.
asserted
it → say → Tyler
The white paper is an analysis based on survey responses Flock received from 477 agencies, 123 of which supplied data used in the final model.
asserted
123 → base → model
Because the agencies were not randomly selected, it was not established that they were representative of the 18,000 law enforcement agencies in the United States.
asserted
they → select → States
Wheeler, in a blog post at the time, criticized the white paper's methodology and called the conclusion that Flock helped solve 10% of crimes nationwide "ridiculous."
asserted
Flock → criticize → crimes
Nhan, one of the two consultants for the white paper, told 404 Media in 2024 that he and Helfers helped with statistical calculations and formatting, but regarding the conclusions, he said he "personally would have done things much differently."
asserted
he → tell → things
In response to questions from CBS News, Nhan similarly backed away from the 2024 paper's conclusions.
asserted
Nhan → back → conclusions
"I did get to look at a version of the paper and did discuss a little bit, but the methods and data sources were not known to us so we didn't dive into it," he said.
asserted
he → get → it
"I personally didn't want to delve into its effectiveness or impact on crime rates, which is a very complex topic for any criminologist."
asserted
which → want → criminologist
By contrast, Flock's 2024 release attributed a quotation to Nhan praising the company as "fully transparent and accessible during every stage of the research process."
asserted
release → attribute → process
Asked in a
in August if Flock's national crime-solving claims are supported by peer-reviewed studies, Langley said peer-reviewed research was not part of the company's claims.
uncertain
research → ask → claims
…and 23 more, not listed.
The Aporia
