The federal government has identified “anti-Zionism” as a driver of anti-Jewish hate — a major policy shift that has prompted a range of reactions.
asserted
that → identify → reactions
The change took place on Sept. 24 when Public Safety Canada published a progress report on federal efforts promised in January to combat antisemitism.
asserted
Canada → take → antisemitism
The report said Ottawa sought to do a better job of recognizing and responding to “contemporary manifestations of antisemitism, including anti-Zionism.”
asserted
Ottawa → say → Zionism
Here’s a closer look at the terminology, why it’s being used now and what it all means for free speech.
asserted
it → ’ → speech
The Canadian Oxford Dictionary defines Zionism as “a movement originally for the re-establishment and now the development of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel.”
asserted
what → define → nation
The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, which identifies itself as a Zionist organization, says it means supporting the idea that “the Jewish people have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland.”
asserted
people → identify → homeland
Opponents of Zionism argue the term has come to embody a colonial mentality that allows the Israeli government to subjugate Palestinians and seek to expand its borders.
asserted
government → argue → borders
The State of Israel was declared founded in May 1948, after the end of British rule over Palestine.
uncertain
State → declare → Palestine
The founding of the state saw Zionist paramilitaries violently disperse Palestinians who were living there, while Arab states around the region responded by deporting Jews to Israel.
asserted
states → see → Israel
Carleton University political scientist Mira Sucharov surveyed American Jews on their views of Zionism and anti-Zionism in 2022.
asserted
Sucharov → survey → 2022
“Self-proclaimed Zionists (Jewish or otherwise) and anti-Zionists (Jewish or otherwise) are talking about completely different things,” she wrote in a commentary in Haaretz.
asserted
she → proclaim → Haaretz
She concluded that Jews embrace Zionism when it’s defined as “a belief in a Jewish and democratic state” and reject the term when it’s defined as “the belief in privileging Jewish rights over non-Jewish rights in Israel.”
asserted
it → conclude → Israel
For decades, Jews in Canada and around the world have debated how Israel should operate and whether it amounts to a colonial project.
asserted
it → debate → project
Independent Jewish Voices identifies as an anti-Zionist organization.
asserted
Voices → identify → organization
It defines anti-Zionism as “the rejection of Jewish settler-colonialism in Palestine and belief that Palestinians deserve dignity and safety like all other people.”
asserted
Palestinians → define → people
The Association for Canadian Studies offered its own definition, which has prompted criticism from left-leaning groups.
asserted
which → offer → groups
“Anti-Zionism refers to a movement that calls for the erasure of Israel and denies the Jewish people the right to self-determination in part of their ancestral homeland,” the association wrote in a report Ottawa commissioned.
asserted
Ottawa → refer → report
The Network of Engaged Canadian Academics, a group of mostly Jewish academics, argues “the latest incarnation of Jew hatred is anti-Zionism (which) relies on libel and distortion to claim that the Jewish collective, Israel, rather than the individual Jew, is uniquely evil.
uncertain
collective → argue → libel
That ideology, the group argues, claims Jews have fabricated a claim to their ancestral land.
uncertain
Jews → argue → land
“Anti-Zionists dismiss Jews as nefarious settlers who have usurped the rights of the true Indigenous people, Palestinians,” the group wrote in a brief to senators.
asserted
group → dismiss → senators
Since the Gaza war started in October 2023, many Canadian Jews have reported that words like “Zionist” have become pejorative terms.
asserted
words → start → Zionist
Some have reported Jewish people being branded with Zionism-linked slurs such as “a Zio.”
asserted
people → report → Zio
The war started with a brutal Hamas attack on Israel that killed roughly 1,200 people.
asserted
that → start → people
That prompted Israel to launch an assault on Gaza that has killed tens of thousands of Palestinians and has led to repression in the occupied West Bank.
asserted
that → prompt → Bank
Israel also has expanded its military footprint in Lebanon and Israeli cabinet ministers have talked openly of ethnic cleansing or mass killings of civilians.
asserted
ministers → expand → civilians
What has Ottawa said?
asserted
Ottawa → say → What
Last week’s federal progress report said anti-Zionism is a modern manifestation of antisemitism.
asserted
Zionism → say → antisemitism
It cited a 2024 government report, though that report did not mention anti-Zionism.
asserted
report → cite → Zionism
The report also took note of a Windsor man sentenced in April for public incitement of hatred after he used the term “Zionists” as a derogatory term for Jews.
“This is particularly important because Ontario is increasingly seeing the use of this term by protesters who try to shield otherwise hateful speech from criminal liability,” the federal report said.
asserted
report → take → liability
The Senate human rights committee avoided weighing in on the terminology in its April study of antisemitism in Canada.
asserted
committee → avoid → Canada
Committee chair Sen. Paulette Senior said the focus of the study was on how to stop the hatred.
asserted
focus → say → hatred
What do proponents say?
asserted
proponents → say → What
Groups that advocate for Israel such as CIJA have generally been supportive of the government’s shift, and have argued that Jewish Canadians are the ones to describe how they experience antisemitism.
“Anti-Zionism is driving violence against Canadians,” CIJA wrote in a tweet before the release of the federal report.
asserted
CIJA → advocate → report
“The demonization of Israel offers a green light for extremists who target the Jewish community.
asserted
who → offer → community
This includes when governments single Israel out or hold it to a double standard.”
asserted
governments → include → standard
Liberal MP Anthony Housefather welcomed the federal shift.
asserted
Housefather → welcome → shift
He said last week’s report is “an important document” that “makes clear the Canadian government recognizes that anti-Zionism is a form of antisemitism.”
asserted
Zionism → say → antisemitism
University of Ottawa professor Michael Geist was also supportive, writing that “Anti-Zionism is too often thinly veiled antisemitism, as if substituting the word Zionist for Jew renders the unacceptable acceptable.”
What do opponents say?
asserted
opponents → write → What
Independent Jewish Voices says Ottawa is embracing terminology that will suppress free speech.
asserted
that → say → speech
“This definition isn’t only wrong, it’s dangerous,” the group wrote.
asserted
group → ’ → ?
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
