Four former deans of medicine in Alberta have joined a growing chorus of critics asking Ottawa to intervene in the province’s dual-practice health care model, which allows eligible doctors to toggle between the public and private systems.
asserted
doctors → join → systems
Tom Feasby, Jon Meddings and Eldon Smith, all formerly with the University of Calgary, and Tom Marrie, who was with the University of Alberta – sent a letter on the contentious issue to Prime Minister Mark Carney on Tuesday.
asserted
who → send → Tuesday
They expressed “deep concern” about the public-private model and assert it violates the Canada Health Act.
asserted
it → express → Act
“It is clear that the Alberta government is not going to change course and, therefore, we strongly request that you and the federal government step in and defend the principles of the Canada Health Act,” said the letter, which was also sent to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith.
asserted
which → go → Smith
Alberta’s model is unlike any other in Canada, allowing some surgical specialists to bill the public purse while also privately charging patients for their services.
asserted
specialists → allow → services
The legislation, which took effect Sept. 1, covers such procedures as hip and knee replacements, cataract surgery and dermatology.
asserted
which → take → replacements
There is intense debate about whether it contravenes federal law.
asserted
it → be → law
The model has come under widespread scrutiny, including from the Canadian Medical Association and its Alberta counterpart, which argue it could create a two-tier system where people who can afford to pay out of pocket receive faster care.
uncertain
who → come → care
In March, 23 health and labour organizations across the country called on Mr. Carney to take action.
asserted
organizations → call → action
Dr. Meddings, in an interview on Wednesday, said there are other countries where a similar model has worked, but Alberta’s health care system is not conducive for a marriage between public and private care.
asserted
system → say → care
“I have nothing against dual practice per se, or some sort of private practice, in the same way as I don’t have anything against somebody paying extra money to fly business class on an airplane,” he said.
asserted
he → have → airplane
“The difference in Alberta is, because we have such a restricted number of both beds and physicians, that when somebody pays for this, it’s not an extra spot that wouldn’t have been used.
asserted
that → have → this
It is taking it away from somebody who would have needed that spot.”
asserted
who → take → spot
The Prime Minister has been largely silent on the issue, but federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel has expressed concern about how the policy will co-exist with the Canada Health Act.
asserted
policy → express → Act
Alexandre Bergeron, press secretary to Ms. Michel, did not address the letter directly in a statement on Wednesday but said the minister is in conversation with Adriana LaGrange, Alberta’s Minister of Hospital and Surgical Health Services.
asserted
minister → address → Services
“Minister Michel is engaged in ongoing, targeted discussions with her Alberta counterpart focused on ensuring access to medically necessary care and the core principles of the public system are protected while respecting Alberta’s jurisdiction,” he said.
asserted
he → engage → jurisdiction
Maddison McKee, press secretary to Ms. LaGrange, said in a statement that Ottawa must respect Alberta’s jurisdiction to determine how health care is delivered.
asserted
care → say → jurisdiction
She also reiterated the government position that dual practice does not contravene the Canada Health Act.
asserted
practice → reiterate → Act
“Our priority is a strong public system and ensuring Albertans never have to pay out of pocket for medically necessary care,” Ms. McKee said.
asserted
McKee → ensure → care
“Expanding access through dual practice does not take away from that.
asserted
Expanding → expand → that
It adds to it.
asserted
It → add → it
It is about giving Albertans more choice.”
asserted
It → give → choice
The former deans said dual practice will harm patients by allowing those who can afford private care to jump to the front of the line, rather than providing care to the sickest first.
asserted
who → say → sickest
This, they stressed in the letter, is what the Canada Health Act was designed to prevent.
asserted
Act → stress → what
Alberta has defended the dual-practice model as a way to reduce strain on the public system.
asserted
Alberta → defend → system
The signatories argue that there is no evidence that shows a parallel public-private system will have that effect.
asserted
system → argue → effect
Rather, they said, it will cause patients to wait longer in the public stream.
asserted
patients → say → stream
The province has said 400 expressions of interest were received over the summer to join the dual-practice system.
asserted
expressions → say → system
As of mid-September, physicians were able to formally apply.
asserted
physicians → apply → September
Surgeries are expected to begin later this fall when the application process is complete.
asserted
process → expect → ?
While the letter did not specify what Ottawa should do, Dr. Meddings sees two ways in which the federal government could address the Alberta practice.
uncertain
government → specify → practice
He said Mr. Carney and Ms. Michel can use the power of “moral suasion” with their counterparts in Alberta to push for changes to the legislation.
asserted
Carney → say → legislation
There is also what Dr. Meddings described as the “nuclear option,” where the federal government withholds or deducts health transfer payments to Alberta, which is permitted if a province violates the Canada Health Act.
asserted
province → be → Act
The Aporia
