What should the president of the United States do with an illegal alien rapist or murderer who cannot be deported to his home country?
asserted
who → do → country
Should he release him inside the United States or deport him to somewhere else?
asserted
he → release → him
Over the last year he has been using a bold new strategy to send criminal aliens out of our country and keep our country safe.
asserted
he → use → country
Under international law, illegal aliens cannot be sent anywhere they would face persecution on the basis of their race, religion, nationality, political beliefs or membership in a particular social group.
asserted
they → send → group
In addition, many countries don’t want us to return their criminals to them.
asserted
us → want → them
Others don’t have diplomatic relations with the United States.
asserted
Others → have → States
Before Trump, most presidents usually released illegal aliens in these circumstances into the United States.
asserted
presidents → release → States
But under the Trump administration, this has finally changed.
asserted
this → change → administration
Advocacy groups estimate that the second Trump administration has now deported some 25,000 illegal aliens to countries other than their own, which is unprecedented.
asserted
which → estimate → own
This is the result of incredible work by the Department of Homeland Security and some 30 international agreements brokered by Secretary of State Marco Rubio.
asserted
This → broker → Rubio
The left has responded, as usual, with a barrage of well-funded lawfare and judicial activism intended to halt the president’s agenda or at least delay it.
asserted
left → respond → it
Shortly after the president returned to office, the Trump administration attempted to send a group of criminal illegal aliens to South Sudan.
asserted
administration → return → Sudan
The ACLU, the National Immigration Litigation Alliance and the American Immigration Council immediately intervened and filed a class-action lawsuit to stop third-country removals.
asserted
ACLU → intervene → removals
Bear in mind that these criminals had been convicted of crimes including murder, arson, armed robbery, kidnapping, sexual assault of a mentally handicapped woman and child rape — but the left wanted them to stay in this country.
asserted
them → bear → country
Ultimately, the ACLU burned months of the government’s time in court, but the Trump administration successfully completed the deportations, and, in fact, doubled down.
asserted
administration → burn → fact
Just weeks later, the Trump administration deported another group of criminals to Eswatini, formerly Swaziland.
asserted
administration → deport → Eswatini
These criminals included a Vietnamese child rapist, a Jamaican murderer, a Laotian murderer, a Yemeni murderer and a Cuban murderer and attempted cop killer.
asserted
criminals → include → rapist
As the courts reaffirmed, immigration law allows deportation to a third country when deportation to the home country is "impracticable, inadvisable" or even just "inadvisable."
asserted
deportation → reaffirm → country
This broad phrasing gives Trump a rock-solid legal authorization to use third-country deportations to accelerate the mass deportation agenda that the American people voted for.
asserted
people → give → that
Case law limits the time that the government can detain an illegal alien, with up to six months being held "presumptively reasonable" by the Supreme Court.
asserted
months → limit → Court
This short window of time often forces the government’s hand.
asserted
window → force → hand
In many cases, the Trump administration then has to deport an illegal alien to a third country rather than, say, charter a private jet for him back to his homeland.
asserted
administration → have → homeland
This new tool is already proving effective, and it may even serve as a deterrent for illegal immigration: If you don’t want a ticket to South Sudan, then don’t come here illegally.
uncertain
you → prove → Sudan
The courts are still considering the question of how much notice the Trump administration must give the illegal aliens before deporting them to a third country.
asserted
administration → consider → country
A Biden-appointed judge in Massachusetts held that the illegal aliens have rights under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) — a 1946 law which governs the process of issuing government regulations — and another Biden-appointed appeals judge upheld it.
asserted
judge → appoint → it
Bear in mind that these criminals had been convicted of crimes including murder, arson, armed robbery, kidnapping, sexual assault of a mentally handicapped woman and child rape — but the left wanted them to stay in this country.
asserted
them → bear → country
Applying the APA to illegal alien murderers is absurd, but both judges affirmed the legality of third-country removals as a tool in the president’s toolbox.
asserted
judges → apply → toolbox
The Supreme Court has allowed the government to continue deportations to third countries, but arguments are scheduled for December.
asserted
arguments → allow → December
Third country removal is yet another example of President Trump using tools that were always available but almost never used.
asserted
that → use → tools
As the President has often said, America didn’t need new immigration laws to end the border crisis—we just needed the right President.
asserted
we → say → President
The American people voted for mass deportations, and the Trump Administration is delivering.
asserted
Administration → vote → deportations
The Aporia
