The Russian founder of Russia’s largest private cargo airline group stepped up his battle with Ottawa over Canada’s sanctions against him in retaliation for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
asserted
founder → step → Ukraine
Aleksey Isaykin lost his court challenge seeking his removal from Canada’s sanctions list targeting Russia in August but on Tuesday he filed a notice of appeal in the Federal Court of Appeal in Ottawa.
asserted
he → lose → Ottawa
Appealing sanctions alongside Isaykin is the airline he founded, which owns a massive cargo jet — the world’s largest — that remains stranded at Toronto’s Pearson airport since landing shortly before Canada closed its skies to Russian aircraft in 2022 after Russia’s attack on Ukraine.
asserted
Canada → appeal → Ukraine
Isaykin and Volga-Dnepr Airlines were both put on Canada’s sanctions list in 2023 under regulations allowing Ottawa to list a person or corporation on reasonable grounds to believe they have directly or indirectly helped or supported Russia’s “violation or attempted violation of the sovereignty or territorial integrity of Ukraine.
asserted
they → put → Ukraine
The hulking frame of the four-engined Antonov An-124, a Russian strategic airlift cargo jet with a NATO codename of Condor and the white-blue-and-red flag of Russia on its tail fin, parked at the Toronto airport is the most public sign of the continuing rift.
asserted
frame → park → rift
The plane remains on an out-of-the-way apron at the edge of the airport, accumulating sky-high parking fees.
asserted
plane → remain → fees
Based on the plane’s long wingspan, the 1,678 days it has been there, and the average of fluctuating per-minute fees for inactive apron space between 2022 and 2026, the parking fees could exceed $4 million.
uncertain
fees → base → million
Ottawa announced plans to seize the plane for “complicity in President Putin’s war of choice” and give it to Ukraine to help compensate for war damage back in 2023, but the process has been bogged down in court.
asserted
process → announce → court
He was elected chairman of the board of Volga-Dnepr Airlines LLC in 1990 and served as the airline’s president from 2002 to 2019, according to court records.
uncertain
He → elect → records
His name is sometimes spelled Alexey Isaikin.
asserted
name → spell → ?
Although the company flies Antonov An-124 planes, which were designed as a heavy military aircraft, Volga-Dnepr told the court it has refused to carry military cargo since 2018.
asserted
it → fly → 2018
The airline is part of a larger Russian conglomerate, called the Volga-Dnepr Group (VDG), which is also on the sanctions list.
asserted
which → call → list
When sanctioning the airline, Ottawa alleged it had agreed with the Russian government in April 2022 to import goods from countries that had not imposed sanctions on Russia.
asserted
that → sanction → Russia
Ottawa said the airline’s contracts in Moscow restored supply chains that had been interrupted by sanctions and the airline received subsidies from the Russian government to counteract the impact of sanctions on the Russian economy.
asserted
airline → say → economy
Being placed on the sanctions list prevents the businessman and the company from conducting business in Canada or with Canadians.
asserted
placed → place → Canadians
The airline’s objection to their listing said they are a “peaceful carrier” and that Isaykin had divested his role as majority shareholder and resigned his position as chairman.
asserted
Isaykin → say → chairman
It said it is not owned by the Russian government, nor involved in Russian politics or war efforts, and not close to the government.
asserted
it → say → government
Isaykin was added to the sanctions list at the same time as the airline, on April 5, 2023.
asserted
Isaykin → add → April
A few months later, he asked to be taken off the list on the grounds that he no longer had any ownership or involvement with the airline.
asserted
he → ask → airline
Isaykin said that he is not close to the Russian government and did not provide military services to Russia.
asserted
he → say → Russia
“I confirm that neither I nor any of the companies that form part of the Volga-Dnepr Group provide any aviation service to the Wagner Group or otherwise in relation to the military operations in Ukraine,” Isaykin said in a sworn statement in the court record.
asserted
Isaykin → confirm → record
The Wagner Group was a notorious mercenary organization with close ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin and heavily involved in the fighting in Ukraine.
asserted
Group → involve → Ukraine
It was widely seen internationally as doing much of Russia’s dirty work.
asserted
It → see → work
Last October, the Minister of Foreign Affairs at the time, Mélanie Joly, declined to lift sanctions from him or the airline.
asserted
Minister → decline → him
Joly wrote that Isaykin was the “majority shareholder of the Volga-Dnepr Group and its subsidiaries, and actively involved in the management of the Volga-Dnepr Group when its subsidiaries benefited from subsidies from the Russian government and were awarded contracts to assist with activities intended to ease or otherwise circumvent the effects of sanctions imposed against Russia by Canada and its partners.”
asserted
subsidiaries → write → Canada
She said the airline helped mitigate the impacts of sanctions on Russia’s supply chain.
asserted
airline → say → chain
As such, he “engaged in activities that directly or indirectly facilitate, support, provide funding for or contribute to a violation or attempted violation of the sovereignty or territorial integrity of Ukraine,” Joly wrote.
asserted
Joly → engage → Ukraine
Joly said his transfer of ownership months after he was listed was a sanctions evasion tactic.
asserted
he → say → ownership
Isaykin asked the Federal Court to intervene in Joly’s decision in November 2024, claiming the decision was unreasonable and procedurally unfair.
asserted
decision → ask → November
He complained that all documentation on him and the airline was not given to Joly when she was making her decision.
asserted
she → complain → decision
He said evidence of the airline’s role in humanitarian aid, such as delivering masks, COVID testing kits and vaccines during the pandemic — including vaccines for the United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund — was not provided to her by government officials.
asserted
evidence → say → officials
The plane was delivering COVID test kits to Canada during the pandemic when it landed in Toronto and became stranded.
asserted
it → deliver → Toronto
He said that information could have changed the decision.
uncertain
information → say → decision
The government argued that while the specific documents weren’t given to Joly, the information in them was summarized for her.
asserted
information → argue → her
Similar arguments were made by the airline in its motion for a judicial review and the two cases were heard together at a five-hour hearing in April.
asserted
cases → make → April
Justice Ann Marie McDonald ruled in August on both cases that the procedural fairness protection required in such government decisions was minimal and that Parliament granted the minister wide latitude when passing the sanction regulations.
asserted
Parliament → rule → regulations
As for the documentation complaints, McDonald said missing information would have to have been completely omitted from the record to have an impact, but in these cases information from the documents was summarized in the government’s memorandum to Joly and in Isaykin’s delisting application.
asserted
information → say → application
“Mr. Isaykin has not identified any errors or misinformation in the summaries that were before the Minister,” her judgment said.
asserted
judgment → identify → Minister
McDonald dismissed both requests for judicial appeals.
asserted
McDonald → dismiss → appeals
Her decisions are now being appealed.
asserted
decisions → appeal → ?
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
