AI giant Anthropic has urged the Albanese government to consider giving “conditional approval” for big tech to train its models on Australian copyrighted works under an opt-out model, after conceding it won’t secure a blanket copyright exemption.
asserted
it → urge → exemption
But Australia’s public broadcasters, the ABC and SBS, have strongly criticised AI firms, calling on the government to enact strict new rules to compensate media organisations and protect public interest journalism.
asserted
broadcasters → criticise → journalism
In submissions to a federal parliamentary inquiry, the ABC demanded AI companies be subject to the same copyright, defamation and privacy rules as media outlets, warning of a “cannibalisation” of mainstream news.
asserted
companies → demand → news
The ABC and SBS also suggested the government include AI companies in the news bargaining incentive, which would require them to make commercial deals with large media outlets to support journalism.
“As publishers, AI-based services are currently unregulated and receive more favourable treatment than established Australian media.
uncertain
services → suggest → media
This unequal treatment will accelerate the cannibalisation of the Australian news industry,” the ABC said in its submission.
asserted
ABC → accelerate → submission
SBS said AI-powered large language models – such as ChatGPT or Claude – were “challenges to the sustainability of the Australian news industry and the erosion of information integrity and public trust through their use of news content without permission, attribution or compensation”.
asserted
models → say → permission
The joint select committee on AI will hold a series of hearings in Sydney next week, with executives from Anthropic to attend along with those from OpenAI, after it admitted one of its AI agents had accessed Services Australia data in June.
asserted
one → hold → June
In a newly published submission, Anthropic said there was “light and shade” to be considered around the development of AI.
asserted
Anthropic → publish → AI
It claimed the technology could “transform the Australian economy, drive a new wave of productivity” and “solve some of the nation’s biggest challenges”, but also warned of “serious implications for Australia’s national security, the resilience of its critical infrastructure and the safety of its people”.
uncertain
technology → claim → people
The company talked up its plans for investing billions in Australia, including large new datacentres, and urged the government to support “frontier model training”.
asserted
company → talk → training
But one sticking point raised by AI companies has been access to Australian copyrighted works – such as news, books, music and other written material – to help train AI models.
asserted
point → raise → models
The Labor government has ruled out a so-called text and data mining exemption, with the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, promising “the strongest possible protection” for Australian creatives.
asserted
minister → rule → creatives
But questions have lingered about other possible copyright changes and the suggestion of an opt-out measure, allowing copyright holders to choose whether their content can be accessed by AI companies.
asserted
content → linger → companies
Anthropic’s submission called on Australia to “provide legal certainty under copyright that brings AI developers to the table while advancing its national cultural interests”.
asserted
that → call → interests
“Anthropic accepts that broad exceptions from copyright, such as a text and data mining exception, have not received widespread support and have been ruled out by the Government.
asserted
exceptions → accept → Government
As an alternative, we believe that the Government could permit AI model training through a narrow form of conditional approval,” the company submitted.
uncertain
company → believe → approval
It suggested the implementation of “do not crawl” signals through robots.txt files – which tell bots what they may and may not access – and said the company was “open” to supporting Australian creators.
uncertain
company → suggest → creators
However SBS said that such an opt-out measure may not work.
uncertain
measure → say → ?
“Robots.txt mechanisms are routinely ignored or bypassed, and the blocking of ever-evolving training bots increases the burden on rightsholders to monitor and update protections, when the onus should be on AI companies to avoid wrongdoing,” the broadcaster said in its submission.
asserted
broadcaster → ignore → submission
The ABC complained that AI companies did not abide by the same rules as media outlets, calling the current system “anti-competitive”.
asserted
companies → complain → system
Both broadcasters called for AI to be included in the news bargaining incentive – with which big tech platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, Google, TikTok and Snapchat have been forced to comply.
asserted
platforms → call → Facebook
The Aporia
