- Published
Andy Burnham's comments about Manchester City's breach of Premier League financial rules were "completely out of touch" with fans and the public, the Conservatives have said.
asserted
Conservatives → publish → fans
The prime minister said on Wednesday he would be "really concerned" if the club's owners decide to sell up after City was found guilty by an independent commission of most of the 115 charges they faced.
asserted
they → say → charges
His remarks raised many eyebrows in the football community, with the Tories now weighing in to call them "frankly extraordinary".
asserted
Tories → raise → them
Downing Street has been contacted for comment.
asserted
Street → contact → comment
Man City deny any wrongdoing and have until Friday to submit an appeal.
asserted
City → deny → appeal
Among the independent panel's findings were that City arranged "sham contracts" with a number of commercial partners as part of a scheme to disguise secret funding of more than £830m.
The Premier League said City "systematically broke Premier League Rules for nearly a decade".
asserted
City → arrange → decade
The Tories accused Burnham of "publicly backing the owners even as the investigation continues" and questioned whether "political pressure" was being applied.
asserted
pressure → accuse → owners
In an interview with the BBC's political editor Chris Mason, Burnham - who was mayor of Greater Manchester until June - said he was "not getting directly involved in the process", adding: "This has to be a process undertaken independently by the Premier League."
He said the situation was "contested by Manchester City" and it would be "wrong" to "jump to a conclusion".
asserted
it → say → conclusion
Asked if he was worried the club's owners since 2008 - led by Sheikh Mansour, a royal and the United Arab Emirates deputy prime minister - might sell up, Burnham said: "I would be really concerned to lose them.
uncertain
I → ask → them
I can't intervene more in the process, it would be wrong for me to do that."
asserted
me → intervene → that
Responding to his comments in a statement on Thursday, shadow minister for sport Louie French called for the government to "keep politics out of football and ensure the Premier League's independent commission can do its job free of outside influence".
asserted
commission → respond → influence
"The club face unprecedented allegations and fans are horrified by what they are reading in the papers," the Tory MP said.
asserted
MP → face → papers
"Yet Burnham is publicly backing the owners even as the investigation continues.
asserted
investigation → back → owners
Fans will rightly ask whether political pressure is being applied here and how it relates to the owners' well-reported investments in Manchester.
asserted
it → ask → Manchester
"Football must be governed independently, with the rules applying equally to everyone.
asserted
rules → govern → everyone
Fans deserve confidence that no club or owner is above those rules."
asserted
club → deserve → rules
In his BBC interview, Burnham also said he was "of course" confident that his own interactions with City's owners as Greater Manchester mayor would stand up to scrutiny.
asserted
interactions → say → scrutiny
He compared City's situation to how the club he supports, Everton, had been charged with a more minor breach of Premier League financial rules in 2023, but said he "hold[s] the view very firmly that they weren't fairly treated in that process".
asserted
they → compare → process
Burnham made his comments amid widespread shock in football about the scale of the independent commission's findings – and the strength of Premier League comments about City's actions.
asserted
Burnham → make → actions
The independent panel that found City guilty of rule breaches will hold a sanctions hearing – which could take months to convene – to decide the punishment, which could include a huge fine or points deduction.
uncertain
which → find → fine
City can appeal both the guilty verdicts and the sanction, leaving the club and the Premier League in a state of chaos and uncertainty.
asserted
City → appeal → chaos
City have said in a statement they are "both disappointed and surprised by the opinion of the Premier League Commission" and maintained their innocence of all the accusations made.
asserted
they → say → accusations
The chairman of the Independent Football Regulator (IFR) – set up by the government in 2025 – said the case had raised "serious issues".
asserted
case → set → issues
In a statement, David Kogan said the IFR "has powers to assess the suitability of owners, directors and executives and we will use these powers where appropriate", while "taking account of the findings made by the Leagues".
asserted
we → say → Leagues
He added that proceedings remain ongoing and he hoped for a quick resolution.
asserted
he → add → resolution
The Aporia
