A new report by Ottawa’s fiscal watchdog warns that the planned high-speed rail project from Toronto to Quebec city could cost as much as 25 per cent more than the Carney government’s highest estimates.
uncertain
project → warn → estimates
The Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) estimated in a report released Thursday that the project’s costs would run between $75-billion and $113-billion, compared to the government’s estimated range of $60 billion to $90 billion.
asserted
costs → estimate → billion
The upper end of the PBO’s estimated range is 25.6 per cent higher than the government’s.
asserted
end → estimate → government
“This range reflects the considerable uncertainty inherent in large-scale rail infrastructure projects,” the report said.
asserted
report → reflect → projects
The report raises fresh questions about one of the Liberal government’s signature projects, as Prime Minister Mark Carney tries to balance his desire to bolster Canada’s infrastructure and the country’s growing debt.
asserted
Carney → raise → infrastructure
The high-speed rail project would add about 1,000 kilometres of electrified high-speed rail using trains designed to travel up to 300 kilometres per hour.
asserted
project → add → hour
The project was unveiled by former prime minister Justin Trudeau in February 2025, just weeks before he left office.
asserted
he → unveil → office
It was referred to Carney’s new Major Projects Office in September 2025.
asserted
It → refer → September
Construction is expected to begin in 2029 and the vast majority of the bill will be paid by the federal government, although there may be private sector involvement.
uncertain
majority → expect → government
But the project’s rising cost estimates may not be finished.
uncertain
estimates → rise → ?
PBO Annette Ryan also warned that any major changes to the rail plan, such as diverting the line to run through Kingston, Ont. or adding tunnels or overpasses would add significantly to the project’s cost.
asserted
line → warn → cost
The PBO’s analysis concluded that about 15 kilometres of tunnel would be needed to connect Laval, Que. and Montreal.
asserted
kilometres → conclude → Laval
And the government announced in June that Kingston is being considered for a potential stop.
asserted
Kingston → announce → stop
The PBO report, based largely on previous high-speed rail projects in Europe and the United States, notes that the details of the proposed route have not yet been made public, and that much of the route will need to go through costly, rocky Canadian Shield.
asserted
much → base → Shield
The report also tamps down the economic benefits of constructing the high-speed rail project, saying Canadians should expect only a “modest” near-term economic stimulus.
asserted
Canadians → tamp → stimulus
For this part of the analysis, the report focuses on the Ottawa-Montreal leg of the proposed project because it’s expected to be completed first.
asserted
it → focus → project
Each dollar spent on construction would boost gross domestic product, or the size of the economy, by about 80 cents during the first year of construction, growing to about 90 cents by the fifth year.
asserted
dollar → spend → year
Construction would mean about 4,300 new jobs during the first year, rising to about 9,000 by the fifth.
asserted
Construction → mean → fifth
The analysis does not factor in the costs of financing the project through higher taxes, reduced spending on other things and higher deficits, nor does it try to account for any possible productivity gains from the new line or the added costs of potentially displacing the advance of other construction projects.
asserted
it → factor → projects
The project was mandated to crown corporation Alto in partnership with Cadence, a consortium chosen to design, build and operate the rail line.
asserted
project → mandate → line
Alto has completed its first major round of consultations with Indigenous communities and the broader public.
asserted
Alto → complete → communities
The Aporia
