In the early autumn sunlight, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh’s extensive plant collection appears safe in their glass enclosures.
asserted
collection → appear → enclosures
But danger lurks from above for the tropical ferns, cycads and rare alpine heathers.
asserted
danger → lurk → ferns
Soon the September sunshine will give way to the storms and gales of the Scottish winter, which can bring hundreds of glass panels crashing to the greenhouse floor on the windiest days.
asserted
which → give → days
Nobody is allowed inside when the wind is above 30mph.
asserted
wind → allow → mph
“We’ve had plants that have essentially been decapitated by falling bits of glass,” says Sadie Barber, the glasshouse curator at RBGE.
asserted
Barber → have → RBGE
“You go into one of these tropical spaces in winter and there’s icy air coming in.
asserted
You → go → winter
It’s traumatic for those of us who put decades into caring for these plants.
asserted
who → ’ → plants
A storm can literally just wipe them out.
asserted
storm → wipe → them
But this week, change is in the air for the creaking infrastructure at the 356-year-old botanic garden, the second oldest in Britain after Oxford.
asserted
change → creak → Oxford
On Friday, the palm houses are reopening after five years of painstaking restoration work, complete with 5,750 panels of toughened glass to keep out the elements.
asserted
houses → reopen → elements
Before they closed for renovation works, the horticultural team had installed a net in case panels fell from the weathered structure.
asserted
panels → close → structure
The new ones are not bulletproof – but they are strong enough to resist a bird strike.
asserted
they → resist → strike
Part-Georgian, part-Victorian, the £23.5m refurbishment has kept nearly all of the original sandstone and wrought iron shell.
asserted
refurbishment → keep → shell
Inside, more than 600 temperate plants have returned to the building.
asserted
plants → return → building
The air is clean and crisp, purified by ferns that naturally remove toxins from the air.
asserted
that → purify → air
Its temperature and humidity is still controlled by the original pulleys and winches.
asserted
temperature → control → pulleys
“We have made it one vast cathedral-like space for temperate plants,” says Prof Julia Knights, the garden’s regius Keeper and the royally appointed chief executive.
asserted
Knights → make → plants
She points out her favourite tree fern, which comes from Tasmania and has a Scottish liverwort growing on its woody stem.
asserted
liverwort → point → stem
“They can grow outside in our botanic garden in Logan on the west coast of Scotland because of the oceanic climate,” she says.
asserted
she → grow → climate
Founded by two physicians in 1670 to teach doctors about medicinal plants, RBGE has morphed into one of the most important collections of plant biodiversity in the world.
asserted
RBGE → found → world
Its research glasshouses are stuffed with rare ginger species, bananas, blueberries and dozens of begonias.
asserted
glasshouses → stuff → begonias
It is a global authority on rhododendrons and ferns, houses rare plant species that have gone extinct in the wild, and its scientists have helped pioneer new technology, such as DNA barcoding which is used to identify plant species.
asserted
which → house → species
Arthur Conan Doyle studied here, infusing Sherlock Holmes novels with his botanical knowledge.
asserted
Doyle → study → knowledge
“Our conservation collections are so important to have.
asserted
collections → have → ?
The threats are extreme in the wild,” said Prof Pete Hollingsworth, RBGE’s director of science.
asserted
Hollingsworth → say → science
“The driver[s] for environmental damage are so strong, so having these ex situ safe sites is really important,” he said.
asserted
he → have → sites
But the restored palm houses aside, many of the glasshouses used to care for the plants are decades past their originally intended lifespan and are waiting for upgrades.
asserted
many → restore → upgrades
Leaks from Scottish rain rot the rootstock of plants, sometimes killing them.
asserted
Leaks → rot → them
Last year, horticulturalists were not allowed inside the greenhouses for 20 days due to high winds.
asserted
horticulturalists → allow → winds
In 2026, they have been shut out 15 times.
asserted
they → shut → 2026
When they return, they have often worn hard hats and safety gear to pick out the broken glass.
asserted
they → return → glass
“The glasshouses are the one thing we don’t want to break.
asserted
we → want → ?
It’s the plants inside that suffer,” said Barber.
asserted
Barber → ’ → ?
“I was looking at one of our records the other day of a plant we lost in the lowland tropical house.
asserted
we → look → house
It just had ‘storm’ written next to it.
asserted
It → have → it
It had either suffered from the cold, or even been cut by falling glass.”
asserted
It → suffer → glass
The Aporia
