Jerry Brown took his share of indefensible positions in his final two terms as governor, but even Republicans acknowledged that he was the last adult in Sacramento—a backstop against the zaniest ideas in the Capitol.
asserted
he → take → Capitol
In an interview with NPR as he prepared to leave office, he touted his efforts at taming the budget, which provided insight into his mature priorities.
asserted
which → prepare → priorities
He slammed Republicans for only knowing how to say "no," but also chided fellow Democrats, whose "problem is they only know how to say 'yes,' even to harebrained schemes."
asserted
they → slam → schemes
I miss his blunt assessments.
asserted
I → miss → assessments
Brown racked up several notable accomplishments—eliminating tax-devouring and property-rights-destroying redevelopment agencies, solving the state's prison-overcrowding crisis by embracing a clever realignment plan that sent nonviolent prisoners to local jails, and reforming the state's overburdened public-employee pension system.
asserted
that → rack → system
He used his political capital to push through these unpopular, but necessary ideas.
asserted
He → use → ideas
Eight years later, he was proven right on all of those signature achievements.
asserted
he → prove → achievements
California's cities have done just fine without those ham-fisted planning agencies, and the state budget has benefited from the relief of backfilling all the revenue they diverted away from traditional public services.
asserted
they → do → services
Recent reports show that realignment enabled the state to comply with a court order and didn't boost violent crime.
asserted
realignment → show → crime
And Brown argued that his Public Employees' Pension Reform Act (PEPRA), which pared back benefits mostly for new hires, would stabilize the state's pension funds right about now.
asserted
which → argue → funds
Brown's successor, Gov. Gavin Newsom, has leaned more into the progressive agenda—and at times has seemed willing to undermine Brown's legacy regarding, say, state spending priorities.
asserted
successor → lean → priorities
So it was heartening that last Sunday Newsom vetoed a bill (Assembly Bill 1383) that would have obliterated one of Brown's signature legislative victories: pension reform.
asserted
that → veto → victories
This definitely was a grown-up move.
asserted
This → grow → ?
Ignoring history, lawmakers from both parties were so eager to ingratiate themselves to public-employee unions that they passed a bill that would have gutted PEPRA by allowing safety employees to receive higher pension formulas and retire at earlier ages.
asserted
employees → ignore → ages
Just as PEPRA started to work as post-PEPRA employees dominated the workforce, these legislative brain trusts wanted to return to the pre-PEPRA era.
asserted
trusts → start → era
They were willing to imperil local budgets and the pension systems based on the assumption that the stock market will keep going up forever.
asserted
market → imperil → assumption
"I was worried that Newsom would undo all of what Brown put together and would totally stomp on Jerry Brown's legacy," former Sen. John Moorlach, the Orange County Republican who championed pension reform, told me.
asserted
who → worry → me
"It's a little late in the game, but he's finally trying to protect his fiscal legacy."
asserted
he → try → legacy
Before the Newsom veto, Brown—who we've heard little from since retirement—spoke out against AB 1383 to CalMatters:
asserted
we → hear → CalMatters
"Every year there's an effort to achieve more benefits for the organizations, and some organizations like firefighters have a much more compelling case than others, but nevertheless the government has to live within limits.
asserted
government → be → limits
The great danger of pensions is that risk comes later when the current lawmakers and advocates are no longer around, so the current leadership has to act as stewards for future beneficiaries.
asserted
leadership → come → beneficiaries
Given the CEO-level pay and benefits earned by firefighters, I take issue with his first statement—but he's right about the rest.
asserted
he → give → rest
Unions make demands every year.
asserted
Unions → make → demands
Lawmakers mostly cave in to them because, well, they will be onto other offices when the bill comes due.
asserted
bill → cave → offices
During Moorlach's era, Republicans would often speak out against benefit hikes, but this year only two Republicans voted against the AB 1383 giveaway.
asserted
Republicans → speak → giveaway
That makes it even more amazing that the state's taxpayers were saved by a man whose fiscal record isn't exactly stellar.
asserted
record → make → man
"PEPRA was a necessary reform born of a crisis exacerbated by past policy decisions," Newsom wrote in his veto message.
asserted
Newsom → bear → message
"I still recall—before PEPRA's passage in 2012—the alarming forecasts, the fierce criticism of public employees, and the growing pressure to eliminate defined benefit plans altogether.
asserted
I → recall → plans
This is an era of California history I do not want to repeat."
asserted
I → want → history
It's seriously amazing the bill got this far given how closely it mirrors a 1999 law, Senate Bill 400, that set the stage for the 2012 budget crisis.
asserted
that → get → crisis
Fortunately, Newsom remembers that history.
asserted
Newsom → remember → history
Local-government groups were relieved, with the California State Association of Counties making the crucial point: "At a time of severe fiscal uncertainty and growing demand for services, it is more important than ever for state leaders to help control costs."
asserted
leaders → relieve → costs
It would have been an act of utter recklessness to boost pensions as fears of a recession loom.
asserted
fears → boost → recession
Recession reminders also remind me of Brown, who always warned about them around budget time.
asserted
who → remind → time
Sure, Newsom has come around fairly late in the game, but future California local officials will appreciate this adult decision.
asserted
officials → come → decision
This column was first published in The Orange County Register.
asserted
column → publish → Register
The Aporia
