Five European Union countries are pushing ahead with plans to start deporting asylum seekers whose applications are rejected to third countries outside the bloc, potentially in Africa, after the EU approved new rules this week that clear the way for the practice.
asserted
that → push → practice
Greece, Germany, Austria, Denmark and the Netherlands have agreed on a common framework to establish "return hubs" outside the EU to which people who have exhausted their legal options to remain in Europe could be transferred if they cannot be sent back to their own countries of origin.
uncertain
they → agree → origin
"When it comes to return hubs, it's progressing very well," Danish Interior Minister Morten Bødskov told reporters Thursday, according to AFP.
uncertain
Bødskov → come → AFP
"We are moving in the right direction."
asserted
We → move → direction
He previously said Denmark expected "to be ready to transfer the first irregular migrants to a partner country outside the EU within 2027."
asserted
Denmark → say → 2027
Greek Migration Minister Thanos Plevris told Politico that Greece expects to have a pilot project in place in the first half of next year.
asserted
Greece → tell → year
No potential destinations for EU return hubs have been confirmed, although Rwanda has been reported as a possible partner in the project.
asserted
Rwanda → confirm → project
A Greek government statement on the plans said the hubs would be established in safe third countries, "particularly on the African continent."
asserted
hubs → say → continent
The EU itself has presented the idea of return hubs as a potential deterrent to irregular immigration.
asserted
EU → present → immigration
A discussion paper published by the EU's governing European Council in October 2025 said the hubs could "incentivize voluntary returns," because migrants who fail to comply with a deportation order could face transfer to a hub instead.
uncertain
who → publish → hub
It said the policy could also discourage people without a valid asylum claim from making dangerous journeys to Europe.
uncertain
policy → say → Europe
The rules adopted this week by the EU establish a bloc-wide legal framework for returns and allow member states to conclude bilateral or unilateral agreements with countries outside the bloc, but with stipulations.
asserted
states → adopt → stipulations
Under the rules, "any such agreement or arrangement may only be concluded with a non-EU country that respects international human rights standards and principles of international law, including the principle of non-refoulement," which guarantees that no individual can be sent back to a country where they would face torture, cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, punishment or other irreparable harm.
uncertain
they → conclude → torture
EU follows U.S. and U.K. examples
asserted
EU → follow → U.S.
The Trump administration has enthusiastically embraced the use of third-country deportations to remove undocumented migrants from the United States.
asserted
administration → embrace → States
More than 100 deportees were sent to eight African countries over a 10-day period in August, according to internal U.S. government documents
.The deportees were sent to destinations including the African nations of Liberia, Rwanda, Eswatini and Sierra Leone.
uncertain
deportees → send → Liberia
Plevris, Greece's migration minister, has praised the Trump administration's approach.
asserted
Plevris → praise → approach
"I am a fan of President Trump," he told Breitbart in August.
asserted
he → tell → August
"But if you ask me what was the best thing he did, it was change the migration policy of the USA, because now we have a new migration policy also in Europe."
Other European governments have experimented with deportations to third nations before, however, with mixed results.
"No shortcut around the difficult parts of migration policy"
Britain's former Conservative Party government sought to send asylum seekers who arrived through irregular routes to Rwanda to have their claims processed there.
uncertain
claims → ask → Rwanda
The U.K. Supreme Court ruled the scheme unlawful in 2023, before it ever got going, over the risk that refugees could ultimately be returned to countries where they faced persecution.
uncertain
they → rule → persecution
The following year, the policy was formally abandoned by the new Labour Party government after the Conservatives were voted out of power.
asserted
Conservatives → abandon → power
The British Home Office said £715 million (almost $950 million) had been spent on the Rwanda program by June 2024, and no asylum seekers were forcibly relocated.
asserted
seekers → say → June
Four people traveled voluntarily to Rwanda under the program.
asserted
people → travel → program
"One lesson may be that European governments should expect litigation, even where the third country looks considerably less controversial than Rwanda," Peter Walsh, a senior researcher at the University of Oxford's Migration Observatory, told CBS News on Friday.
uncertain
Walsh → expect → Friday
"These policies are often justified as deterrence measures, and that assumes a sufficiently large share of people believe there is a realistic chance they will actually be transferred," Walsh said.
asserted
Walsh → justify → people
"If only a very small proportion can be moved, the deterrent may be much less credible."
uncertain
deterrent → move → ?
"The broader lesson from Rwanda is that externalization is not a shortcut around the difficult parts of migration policy," he said.
asserted
he → say → policy
"It may relocate some of those difficulties geographically, but governments still have to deal with courts, individual rights, administrative capacity, countries that may not cooperate with returns, and substantial costs"
uncertain
that → relocate → returns
The push for return hubs is part of a broader effort by European nations to tighten their immigration policies amid intense pressure on governments to increase the number of people without a legal right to remain who are actually removed.
asserted
who → tighten → right
Jacob Reynolds, policy director at the Freedom and Sovereignty Initiative Europe, a right-wing think tank based in Brussels, called the EU decision to embrace these hubs a "welcome step towards gaining control of our borders and removing those who have no right to be here."
But he added that "outsourcing the problem of illegal migration to third countries — as the EU has long done — risks avoiding the broader problem: the lack of control over EU countries' borders."
asserted
EU → base → borders
He called for "much more fundamental action" to address "the generous regimes available to asylum seekers in Europe," and said until that happened, "the problem will not be solved."
asserted
problem → call → Europe
The Aporia
