A former patient of disgraced neurosurgeon Sam Eljamel has expressed her “shock” at NHS Tayside’s approach to an inquiry into his wrongdoing, after a former executive at the health board was unable to answer questions.
asserted
executive → express → questions
Sandra MacLeod, who was interim deputy chief executive for NHS Tayside from February 2024 to February 2026, had been lined up to answer a number of questions about records management at the health board.
asserted
who → line → board
However on Thursday evening, the health board notified the inquiry that many of those questions should have been directed to Margaret Dunning – who gave her evidence last week.
asserted
who → notify → evidence
Reporting this to chair Lord Weir, counsel to the inquiry Jamie Dawson KC said this was “difficult to understand”, since it contradicted what the inquiry was told last week about who those questions should be directed to.
asserted
questions → report → who
Mr Dawson told the inquiry: “The information that we now have is that certain of those questions, it would appear, should have been posed to Margaret Dunning when she gave evidence last week, in particular questions 103 to 105.”
asserted
she → tell → evidence
He continued: “We’re told that (Ms MacLeod) is able to answer questions in relation to health records, but that any data protection or freedom of information aspect of the response would fall under information governance, which at the relevant time would have fallen under Margaret Dunning.
asserted
which → continue → Dunning
“Now that that’s difficult to understand in the context of having been told that Ms Dunning did not, in fact, answer certain questions last week.
asserted
Dunning → ’ → questions
“For example, question 104, which is to do with the accuracy of medical records, which we were told that she did not speak to.”
asserted
she → do → which
He said the episode had left the inquiry in “a degree of confusion”, but stressed that “further investigations” would be made to fill in any gaps in the evidence heard.
asserted
investigations → say → evidence
During questioning, Ms MacLeod read frequently from written notes, and at one point it emerged the parts of the inquiry statement for which she was responsible had been written by other people.
asserted
she → read → people
When challenged on this, she told the inquiry: “My role was (one of) executive oversight, this was pulled together from the subject matter experts who felt that those were the relevant documents.”
asserted
those → challenge → experts
Mr Dawson pressed her: “So, all of the answers that you gave were written by someone else?”
asserted
you → press → someone
She replied in the affirmative, but said she had signed them off in her executive role.
asserted
she → reply → role
The witness also explained that the decisions about who was put forward to answer questions about which area had been made by a group that included, among others, NHS Tayside executive medical director Dr James Cotton, who appeared before the inquiry earlier this week.
asserted
who → explain → inquiry
Mr Dawson put it to her: “So can we deduce from that that it appears that it was Dr Cotton, along with the other people on the committee, who took the decision that it would be best for not the person who answered these questions, but for someone who didn’t answer these questions, to come before the inquiry about these important matters today.”
asserted
who → put → matters
Ms MacLeod responded: “That would be a reasonable assumption, (but) I don’t have the facts in front of me.”
asserted
I → respond → me
She said: “I’m just so shocked.
asserted
I → say → ?
The NHS Tayside representatives have all come to this so totally unprepared, all of them.
asserted
representatives → come → them
In in her defence, she seems to have been sent to talk about stuff she didn’t know.
asserted
she → seem → stuff
“But why would you send someone like that to something as important as this?”
asserted
you → send → this
She said her reaction was shared by other former patients who were in the room during the hearing.
asserted
who → say → hearing
“We were all kind of looking each other and thinking, ‘what on earth?’
asserted
We → look → earth
“My hope is, and I think this might happen, that these people will be brought back and have to answer these questions themselves because it seems like they’re hiding.”
uncertain
they → think → questions
Ms Davidson added: “To me, they didn’t seem to grasp the seriousness of what this is all about, and it is very serious because we do not want this to happen again.”
asserted
this → add → what
A spokesperson for NHS Tayside said, “As The Eljamel Inquiry is ongoing, it would not be appropriate to comment on evidence being considered as part of its proceedings.
asserted
it → say → proceedings
“We will continue to assist the Inquiry constructively and respectfully.”
asserted
We → continue → Inquiry
The inquiry, before Lord Weir, continues.
asserted
inquiry → continue → Weir
The Aporia
